F Haseq
First time trying this place and really disappointed. I’ve had vodka slices in the past. I’ve had gluten free thin crust. And they all had taste and looked amazing. This was not it. No taste at all. Did not look appetizing one bit. Waste of $20. This is not a vodka pizza. I only had one slice and forced myself to eat it since I paid for it. It is so hard to look for a place that does GF thin crust vodka pizza. And the one place I found here was beyond disappointing. Covering the slices with all that mozzarella cheese? No thank you. And the sauce underneath had no taste. First and last time trying this place.
… moreCassie Maloney
We’ve ordered a few times at work—delivery always quick and friendly! Yesterday I finally went into the shop and it’s just such a classic pizzeria vibe with amazing service. Growing up in Bensonhurst I know a thing or two about classic pizzerias!
Fantastic regular slice! Thin and gooey and delicious. The potato croquettes are out of this world as well.
Great spot for a slice after a long day at work!
… moreiam Toussaint
I am very upset with this place, I ordered chicken ceaser salad and meatballs. First the chicken was not fresh tasted like leftovers. The meatballs wasn’t fresh but no taste. I don’t understand how you servings people those kind of food.
… moreArgy Samakovlis
I always order catered food from Bay Ridge pizza for the holidays or for birthday parties. They never disappoint. Most recently yesterday for my daughter‘s birthday. All of my guests were asking where I got the food from because it was so delicious. One of the shrimp trays I got was phenomenal. The shrimp was huge and high-quality and so good. And their prices are very reasonable. I love this place!
… moreLittleCesar2000
Came here a month ago first time, got a whole pizza siciliana with pepperoni. Its an old school pizza joint. So good and the kids of course loved it. They were super busy but cranked it out during peak dinner rush. Now I’m hungry just thinking about it.
… moreScott Miranda
Cheese gluten free pizza rocked. My son has Celiac and this was cooked well. No gooey dough that some places struggle with cooking right.
Saw guy walking an order out to someone too. This place cares!
Great job everyone and thank you!
… morePaula V
This has to be the biggest joke of a pizza I’ve ever seen in my life. The cheese is not even on the damn pizza. is literally coming off, also the dough is raw. Absolute garbage. Shame on you for even thinking to send out such monumental crap .
… moreLaura McKenna
Stopped in for the first time for a quick slice while in the neighborhood when I saw they’d been in business since 1978. They had just brought out a tray of square pizza. I ordered a slice and it was so good, I got a second. I can’t speak for the other slices, but a half-mushroom, half-olive pizza fresh out of the oven looked delicious. I’ll be back!
… moreRandi Oyervides
First stop from JFK, it was truly the best. We ordered a mushroom Alfredo mini pizza and a gluten-free, black olive pizza and meatball roll and a single cheese slice. When I tell you that Alfredo straight from the pan . Everything was hot and fresh. Amazing host and good people.
… moreCarlos
Bro.. I’m not even exaggerating. This has to be the best pizza I’ve ever had in my 31 years of life. The atmosphere is warm and welcoming. I’m a native new yorker. I’ve had my share of New York pizza. Bay Ridge Pizza takes the gold. My 5 stars are genuine. Highly recommend.
… more