Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Hours
| Tuesday | 12–8 PM |
| Wednesday | 12–8 PM |
| Thursday | 12–8 PM |
| Friday | 12–8 PM |
| Saturday | 4–8 PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday | Closed |
Address and Contact Information
Address: 100 Cedar St, Suttons Bay, MI 49682
Phone: (231) 866-4494
Website: https://bay-pizzeria.com/
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Bay Pizzeria: Delicious Pizza in Suttons Bay, MI
Enjoy delicious pizza in Suttons Bay, MI at Bay Pizzeria, where quality ingredients meet great taste! Check our menu and order now!
Bay Pizzeria | Suttons Bay MI – Facebook
Plenty of delicious food right here at Bay Pizzeria! We would love to feed you today! Give us a call at 231-866-4494. May …
Bay Pizzeria | Suttons Bay, MI 49682 – Traverse City Tourism
Bay Pizzeria · Address: 100-A S Cedar St, Suttons Bay, MI, 49682 · Phone: (231) 866-4494 · View More Details. About. From family …
Reviews
Joan Giddis
We drove 35 miles to get here because we heard there was a really good almost authentic Cudighi Sandwich. We weren’t disappointed. The sandwich is huge.The bread for the cudighi to rest on was crisp on the outside and tender to bite through. The sautéed green and red peppers with onions were perfect. The cheeses were good quality. You can always tell good mozzarella cheese. I would have preferred a little less pizza sauce but it was still a wonderful sandwich. The star of the show was the cudighi though. This rates right up there with the UP. The gentleman that made this new exactly what he was doing, and it is seasoned perfectly. I love this sandwich and we will certainly be back again. Kudos to you and your staff.
… moreMarcia LvD
Outstanding veggie pizza! Fresh, tasty ingredients, and their pan crust is probably one of the best pizza crusts we’ve ever had. Their calzones are also excellent. Staff are friendly, and the service is great. This is now our go-to pizza place in Suttons Bay!
… moreTM E
The best pizza I’ve had in the Suttons Bay Area with very good crust and lots of fresh toppings. We loved the pizza sauce, too. There are many things I’d like to try here, so I’ll def be a return customer. Conveniently located close to the bike trail. A good choice on a great trail. Unfortunately no seating inside but a few tables outside.
… moreRyan Morency
Had their pizza a few months back and was super impressed. Pay no attention to the 1-star review, it sounds like a local business owner who is salty about having some competition and never actually tried the pizza. Their seasoned crusts are a delicious addition to an already amazing pie and the owners are down to earth, good folk. So great to have another pizza joint in town!
… moreChris Alpers
Best meatball sub I’ve ever tasted.
Sub ingredients are NYC deli quality. Check this place out for subs and calzones. Lilly, that works the front always has a smile on her face and is super friendly.
… moreSub ingredients are NYC deli quality. Check this place out for subs and calzones. Lilly, that works the front always has a smile on her face and is super friendly.
KP
Ooooooo May have just found us our new go-to pizza on the peninsula! Two words: YUM-MO!
I’m so glad I gave this new little place a try. There’s nothing I would have changed if given the option. (Okay, well, I certainly wouldn’t have passed on it being FREE .) Calling in to place the order: friendly and accommodating; picking up the order: friendly and attentive; eating the pizza: freakin’ yum!
I was fascinated at how many ingredients the pizza (crust) could support without being limp or greasy. (How could the “hoity-toity” LL pizza not do the same with only pepperoni – and less of it… ) And not just “supportive” – tasty! Ditto the cheese and sauce. And mushrooms and ham and…
What a great little “find”!
… moreI’m so glad I gave this new little place a try. There’s nothing I would have changed if given the option. (Okay, well, I certainly wouldn’t have passed on it being FREE .) Calling in to place the order: friendly and accommodating; picking up the order: friendly and attentive; eating the pizza: freakin’ yum!
I was fascinated at how many ingredients the pizza (crust) could support without being limp or greasy. (How could the “hoity-toity” LL pizza not do the same with only pepperoni – and less of it… ) And not just “supportive” – tasty! Ditto the cheese and sauce. And mushrooms and ham and…
What a great little “find”!
susanna brown
The BEST club sub I have ever had!
On top of the friendly staff, food portions, and top quality ingredients, what more can you ask for! Great job bay pizzeria!
… moreOn top of the friendly staff, food portions, and top quality ingredients, what more can you ask for! Great job bay pizzeria!
Angela Bowen
We had the pleasure of their pizza for dinner last night, it was pretty good, coming from me….I’m not a huge fan of pizza…..BUT…… I spied a gem in their cold case…a Pastie!!!!! Now…growing up in the Yoop, it was almost like eating my homemade pastie…yup it was that good. Good job!!!! Trust me, I’ll be back…if you’re in the mood for a great Pastie…hit up this place….will not disappoint..
… morec p
We wanted roman wheel but it was closed and like fools we thought this would fill the void. We thought it couldn’t be much worse considering it’s barely a block away… like I said… we were fools. We have had better pizza at Little Caesar’s. We have had better pizza at Chuck E. Cheese. We have had more authentic pizza at gas stations. I don’t just mean it tastes better at a gas station, I mean you are closer to the spirit of Italian cousine waiting in line at a 711 to get a one dollar slice of cold day-old pizza than you are eating at bay pizzeria. You are better off diving into lake and eating sand. The breadsticks were bad and that’s like one ingredient. My middle school cafeteria had better pizza. I am shocked and appalled.
… moreEmily Fjerstad
We are so happy to have this local pizza place close by. We have been wanting to try them and finally did tonight for the first time. We tried the “gluten friendly” aka gluten free crust with pepperoni and their house made sausage with garlic parm crust. They make the dough themselves. It was hands down the best GF pizza crust I’ve had in the area. My husband (who eats all the gluten) even loved it. The service was super friendly and quick too. Highly recommend.
… more