AM T.
Good atmosphere, very pleasant service. The clam chowder is excellent, great flavor. Wonderful location at the marina. Really enjoyed this place. Recommend to all.
… moreJackie Espejo
Hands down, Miriam is the best. My team and I drove down from the Bay Area for my fight this past weekend and Miriam was the highlight to our stay. She handled multiple tables and still managed to make great conversation with us over breakfast. Overall, very sweet woman and super honored to have met her and share a couple moments with her before and after my win.
… moreM. Lo
Restaurants like this are never as full as they deserve to be. Everything we had was really excellent. The wedge salad was crisp and fresh with just enough dressing. The shrimp and bacon Mac and cheese was a HUGE portion, and so very comforting. Delicious. The prime dip was tasty too. Definitely massive portions tho! We couldn’t finish our food. Haha
… moreRJ C
I found the food to be good, but hotel quality. Service was really slow, but really nice staff, I’m thinking they may have been understaffed.
… moreBrandi Sealy
Place is nice an relaxing. Decent food, good drinks. Great people.
… moreHeather Hucal
We waited in line for 10 minutes after 3 servers said they’d be right with us. We were finally seated and waited another 15 minutes to get water. Then no one came and took our order for yet another 20 minutes. Sadly our order was taken before others who were seated before us.
My husband is diabetic and couldn’t wait any longer even to get just a Coke as we never had a server.
This was supposed to be a night for celebration as our son is graduating from the Marines tomorrow yet it was a night we want to quickly forget.
… moreAlison
This is the perfect spot for happy hour on Shelter Island! My boyfriend and I were staying at The Bay Club and stopped in for some drinks and their cheesy bread. We loved sitting outside by the marina, and the service was excellent–Dane took great care of us. The cheesy bread–not pictured because we ate it too quickly–came with this delicious garlic sauce and I would definitely go back for it again.
… moreLaura Edwards
Miriam was the most wonderful waitress. She is always cheerful and smiling and made me feel very welcome. She works really hard and keeps up the pace too!
… moreTim Cornia
It is a hotel bar and grill so we went in with lower expectations. My wife and sister (two different people, LOL) both ordered the Teriyaki Salmon and I had the short rib. My meal was EXCELLENT and the two ladies raved over the salmon. My sister claimed it was the best salmon she has ever had and both LOVED the unique flavor. The food seriously could have passed off as four star fair. Totally blown away. The one complaint was that they were out of the garlic potatoes
The service was good. It was slow but the waiter was great, personable, and engaged.
I scratch my head at why they weren’t busy. The next time we are in town, I’ll eat there again, even if I don’t stay at the hotel it’s attached to
… moreSuzie Lopez
Great view! The prices were reasonable. We tried the ahi, fish and chips, and steak which were good. The steak was a little over cooked. Overall it was the perfect place for dinner before heading to a concert at Humphrey’s
… more