Social Profile: 
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 2066 Cherry Valley Rd, Newark, OH 43055
Phone: (740) 522-4563
Website: https://bavelliespizzeria.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Bavellies Pizzeria
Select A location Johnstown Newark Copyright bavellie’s Pizzeria – All rights reserved.
Bavellie’s Pizzeria | Newark OH – Facebook
Get $5 OFF 2 Large Pizzas! Order online at Bavelliespizzeria.com! (Open 4:30pm-10pm) 2066 Cherry Valley Rd. 740-522-4563
Order Bavellie’s Pizzeria – Newark, OH Menu Delivery [Menu & Prices]
Get delivery or takeout from Bavellie’s Pizzeria at 2066 Cherry Valley Road in Newark. Order online and track your order live. No delivery fee on your first …
Reviews
Timothy Ross
Good pizza but very odd they put pizza sauce on their taco pizza and Italian sub pizza . Just changes the taste and doesn’t taste right .
… moreJ P
I don’t know what they do to their pizza that makes it so good, but every place else should take note. If you order online the website will tell you it’ll be ready in 10 minutes, the truth is they have a pair of ninjas there that psychically link with every pizza fanatics in a 5 mi radius and your order is in the box before youve finished submitting it. Hivemind for real. Highly recommend.
… moreAndrea Rudin
Where this beautiful little gem of a pizza parlor has been hiding out, I will never know. HOLY COW, this pizza is fantastic! We ordered a sausage and a pepperoni, both with double cheese, super low key, and it blew our socks right out the window. The toppings were crisp, fantastic cheese pull. Thin crust, but still a little soft. I would like to try well done next time for a crisper crust, but it was absolutely top tier. Can’t wait to order again!
… moreSammy G
We tried this place for the first time. We got plain and Hawaiian pizzas. The ingredients were very tasty. The crust was not my favorite though we are very picky about our crust especially coming from New York and Chicago. I don’t know what it is about Columbus and their pizza crusts.
… moreBrett Lampron
We typically love this place. This is the 2nd time we’ve ordered extra cheese and didn’t get it. Also, the delivery took well over an hour and for the 2nd time in a row it was cold. Maybe one more chance…..then that’s it.
… moreAndrew Schirtzinger
Honestly really disappointed got an Italian sub and Stromboli. The sub came with basically a tossed salad on it. Also small pieces of salami and pepperoni . The Stromboli is a small pizza folded … I’m not coming back.
… moreFully Armed
Amazing Amazing Amazing calzone best one Ive eaten to date. Made to perfection nice flavorful crust and cheese. Definitely recommend getting pepperoni and sausage put a little hot sauce and you have a miracle. Im absolutely flabbergasted on how great it tasted. Its like reading a Shakespeare’s poem you are waiting in anticipation for the food then it just hits you out of no where with the climax of the story arriving in front of you. Ending with a nice and satisfied with a sprinkle of sadness since you ate it all and want more. Wonderful atmosphere
Fin. Yours truly Moe Money
… moreFin. Yours truly Moe Money
Joshua McGee
Great local pizza! My wife and I were staying at nearby AirBnB and looking for pizza. A review we read said this pizza tasted like Donatos and that’s our favorite pizza. It does taste like Donatos! Sauce is a little sweeter but we still loved it. Pepperoni and the works were great. Salad was nice and fresh too. Highly recommend if you are in the area.
… moreAndrew Bowden
Ordered two pizzas, the one below had “extra cheese”. As you can see, the enitre right side of pieces has very little cheese. Okay, so on to the taste. Salty. The crust is crazy salty and was chewier than I like. The sauce didn’t taste like anything other than the standard non doctored sauce from a can. The cheese quality seemed low as well.
The staff was very nice, although they didn’t ring me up correctly for their Friday special. (Cost me an extra couple bucks I think). The pepperoni was great, but the sausage tasted like average pre cooked pizza topping sausage that comes frozen. Newark has several amazing mom and pop pizza places, but this unfortunately isn’t one of them.
… moreThe staff was very nice, although they didn’t ring me up correctly for their Friday special. (Cost me an extra couple bucks I think). The pepperoni was great, but the sausage tasted like average pre cooked pizza topping sausage that comes frozen. Newark has several amazing mom and pop pizza places, but this unfortunately isn’t one of them.
Dean Annett
Was my 1st time going and i was very satisfied. Pizza and garlic bread were both very good
… more