Jacob D
One of our favorite pizza places. We come all the way from Milwaukee for their delicious pizza and amazing crust. Old school pizza parlor with lots of charm. Highly recommend!
… moreRhonda Wong-Calace
Food was all delicious! The atmosphere was relaxed and friendly. We all really enjoyed it here! The pizza and all of our food was delicious and made us all happy!
… moreHagz
Love Barnabys…There thin crust pizza snappy crunch of the crust is perfect when dining in like any pizza way better dining there in person than having it get soggy /cooler transport home etc. Plus they serve Green River soda pop at the bar, a real treat in Chicago. Went out the norm for me and ordered half pepperoni and half cheese..I am a pizza snob and i actually think this is one of the best thin crust for the north suburb Chicagoland area 100% recommend!
… moreMatthew Bardy
My family lives in Chicago & since I’ve been old enough to remember, we have always made a stop (or three) to Barnaby’s when in town to visit family. I’m now 42 years old.
I’m guessing I’ve eaten here 120+ in my life. Every single time, it’s amazing.
Weeks before an upcoming trip the excitement & anticipation begins to grow that Barnaby’s Pizza is in my future…
Then the fear sets in…what if it’s changed? What if it’s not the same? What if I’m disappointed? What if…?
Happy to report that I was back last night & it’s better than it’s ever been. Yet at the same time, it’s the still the same old amazing Barnaby’s!
… moreJeff M Delgado
Soooo I get the nostalgia of coming here for a meal especially for those who grew up coming here. Unfortunately, there’s better cracker crust type pizza out there.
A few nights ago, my son I shared a large sausage pizza. The service was great and everyone was friendly. The pizza itself was nothing special. The crusts reminded me of a frozen home run inn pizza which was disappointing. The sausage was ok and the cheese was sparely on there. I did enjoy their bar as they had Schlitz in a bottle! Score!
There is plenty of parking lot spaces available.
If you want ok pizza come here especially if you an old school 70’s wooden booth type of restaurant.
… moreAdam
This line is manned by one person who is managing a blend of pickup, phone orders, and order for sit down at the resturant. I waited 25 minutes to pickup my carry out food. I don’t understand why they don’t have a pickup window like every other pizza place in Chicago.
… moreCharles Noe
“Barnaby’s of Northbrook delivers that Neighbor Proof–level consistency with real local trust that Northern Illinois families have counted on for decades.” The food comes out hot, the service is steady, and the atmosphere feels like a true community anchor. Their pizza has that classic, reliable flavor you expect every single time, and the team moves with the kind of confidence that only comes from years of doing things the right way. It’s the kind of place where you see real stories play out — families, regulars, and neighbors all sharing the same dependable experience. A Northbrook staple that continues to earn its reputation.
… moreRaymond Ward
Used to come here as a kid, have many fond memories of the place. It looks almost exactly the same as I remember and the pizza is still great. The crust is thin and crunchy. Very unique.
… moreMadeline B
Based on the 4.5 star rating and over 1,000 reviews I thought the pizza would be good but I was disappointed. I am not picky about pizza and like almost all types, but I did not like this pizza. The crust was way too thin, lacked flavor and had a very crumbly texture. Normally the crust is what makes a pizza whether it is thick and chewy or thin and flakey Napoleon style pizza. I was disappointed and wouldn’t get it again.
The service was friendly, but it took longer than you would think for it being a slow weekday lunch.
Atmosphere was great and reminded me of old pizzerias growing up.
Maybe the other Italian food on their menu it good, but not the pizza 🙁
… moreCarl Mucker
Great pizza , actually it’s one of my favorites if not my favorite pizza. The atmosphere is great it’s got that old time Italian restaurant vibe from back in the day. Friendly service and professional. I gotta be honest I never tried any of their other food because I’m in love with their pizza.
… more