Social Profile: 
✔️Breakfast ✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Handmade Old-fashioned Baked Goods Made Fresh Daily! Baked by Susan is a full service bakery located in Croton on Hudson, New York. We make all baked goods including: cakes, wedding cakes, cupcakes, pies, cookies, breads, and more! We have ample indoor and outdoor seating and we also offer hot soup and paninis on our homemade focaccia bread. We have our beer, wine and cider license and we often have live music.
Snug, family-owned bakeshop making pies, cookies & pastries, plus custom special-occasion cakes.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 379 S Riverside Ave, Croton-On-Hudson, NY 10520
Phone: (914) 862-0874
Website: https://bakedbysusan.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Baked by Susan: Best Local Bakery | Westchester NY
Baked by Susan Bakery opened in the fall of 2010 in Croton-on-Hudson in the heart of the upper village in a glass-fronted store where the baking takes place in …
Home | Baked by Susan Online Store
At Baked by Susan, we make everything from scratch – everyday – using only whole fruits in season, real butter, eggs and King Arthur Flour.
Baked by Susan (@Bakedbysusan) – Facebook
Baked by Susan. 3455 likes · 223 talking about this · 488 were here. Delicious baked goods for any occasion in Croton on Hudson, NY. Big bright space…
Reviews
Sarah T – Hudson Valley Guide
This should be your go-to local bakery. Everything is consistently delicious -cinnamon rolls, cupcakes, cakes… you really can’t go wrong. I’ve ordered their cakes for parties and they are not only beautiful, but genuinely delicious too. Nothing is overly sweet; everything tastes fresh, homemade, and made with care. We love this place. Sharing photos of their coconut cake and a unicorn cake they made for us – both were a huge hit!
… moreLisa Weinstein
I ordered a smash cake and some cupcakes for my daughter’s 1st birthday. The cake and cupcakes were so so delicious. The cream cheese frosting on the red velvet cupcake was to die for, I might need to order that as a cake in the future. The smash cake was beautiful and exactly what I hoped for. The team was wonderful from taking my order over the phone, to pick up, to the baked goods themselves. Baked by Susan never disappoints!!
… moreMichelle Milanes
The cake was absolutely beautiful and exactly what I envisioned for my wedding day. The dulce delish filling was truly delicious, and the overall design was simple and elegant, perfectly matching the tone of my ceremony. When I arrived to pick it up, Susan personally came out to make sure I was happy and that everything was perfect, which to me is the definition of quality service. This isn’t the first time I’ve ordered from Baked by Susan—my husband’s German chocolate cake (for his birthday) was such a hit that I didn’t even get a slice because it was gone so quickly. Baked by Susan is truly my go‑to bakery for special occasions; her bakery is about 40 minutes away, and I will happily make the trip every time!
… moreMarisa Butin
My daughter just had an amazing 8th birthday party at Baked by Susan! She and her friends got to go behind the scenes to make their own pizzas and then get a special tour of the bakery. They played a “Who Knows the Birthday Girl Best?” game and the winners got take-home cookie packages. Then they all decorated cupcakes with icing and various toppings–one of which they ate at the party and one that they got to take home! They also got to take home candy necklace kits, which my daughter had a great time making today. It was a wonderful one-stop-shop birthday party–all I had to do was show up. Everyone had a great time! Definitely give it a try for one of your kiddos!
… moreLidia Milio
I had a custom birthday cake made for my daughter’s 4th Birthday by Baked by Susan. & I Couldn’t be happier with the experience. Communication was quick and easy from start to finish, which made the whole process pretty easy.
The cake itself tasted delicious ! Everyone loved it. We choose a vanilla cake with strawberry-whipped cream filling. It beautifully crafted, even with the short notice.
Highly recommend Baked by Susan for anyone looking for a custom cake!!!
… moreThe cake itself tasted delicious ! Everyone loved it. We choose a vanilla cake with strawberry-whipped cream filling. It beautifully crafted, even with the short notice.
Highly recommend Baked by Susan for anyone looking for a custom cake!!!
Mark Mellea
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
If there were an option to give 10 stars, Baked by Susan would deserve every single one! Our engagement cake was everything we dreamed of and even better—beautifully designed and absolutely delicious. From start to finish, Susan was patient, kind, and hands-on, guiding us through every detail with care and genuine passion.
What really sets this bakery apart is how much Susan truly cares. She doesn’t just make cakes—she creates experiences that become unforgettable memories. The cake was not only a centerpiece at our celebration, but also a reflection of the love and effort she puts into her craft. We are beyond grateful and will recommend Baked by Susan to anyone who wants perfection, quality, and heart all in one.
… moreIf there were an option to give 10 stars, Baked by Susan would deserve every single one! Our engagement cake was everything we dreamed of and even better—beautifully designed and absolutely delicious. From start to finish, Susan was patient, kind, and hands-on, guiding us through every detail with care and genuine passion.
What really sets this bakery apart is how much Susan truly cares. She doesn’t just make cakes—she creates experiences that become unforgettable memories. The cake was not only a centerpiece at our celebration, but also a reflection of the love and effort she puts into her craft. We are beyond grateful and will recommend Baked by Susan to anyone who wants perfection, quality, and heart all in one.
Edward Farez
We had an amazing cake for my son‘s third birthday. I provided Susan with a picture and some toppers and her team did an excellent job at executing the cake. my entire family loved the cake. The birthday boy was super happy unfortunately I did not take a picture of the cake before. They removed all the toppers
… moreAnthony Ngo
The cake tastes as good as it looks! I cannot recommend this bakery enough! They have the best tasting cakes with beautiful buttercream decorations. So grateful for their assistance and recommendations when placing a cake order. Susan and everyone at the bakery were so kind and helpful, they made our daughter’s dream cake come true!
… moreAllie Fraase
Susan created the most beautiful “cottage fairy witch” cake for my 10 year old’s birthday party. It was both beautiful and delicious (funfetti cake with cream cheese frosting). Highly recommend!
… moreMeredith Hayman Hanson
I loved working with Susan so much! I had a personalized cake topper that I wanted included on the cake and she did it beautifully. I had a health issue and had to reschedule my order at the last minute and she handled it great. My cake was ready on time the way I wanted it and everybody thought it was delicious. I would definitely order again.
… more