Social Profile: 
✔️Breakfast ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Bagel Supreme is Wallington, NJ’s favorite spot for fresh, handcrafted bagels, breakfast sandwiches, and more. Conveniently located in the heart of town on 457 Paterson Avenue in Wallington, our shop has been serving the community with premium bagels made daily using time-honored techniques: hand-rolled, kettle-boiled, and baked to perfection. Whether you’re looking for the perfect breakfast bagel, a hearty lunch sandwich, or a variety of spreads to go, Bagel Supreme has something for everyone. From our classic bacon, egg, and cheese to our specialty sandwiches and coffee, we’re here to make every meal memorable. We also offer catering services for your next event, as well as online ordering for added convenience.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 457 Paterson Ave, Wallington, NJ 07057
Phone: (201) 587-5101
Website: https://www.bagelsupreme.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Wallington – Location Info – Bagel Supreme
Conveniently located in the heart of town on 457 Paterson Avenue in Wallington, our shop has been serving the community with premium bagels made daily using …
Bagel Supreme | Fresh Bagels, Breakfast & Lunch | Multiple NJ …
Discover Bagel Supreme — your go-to spot for fresh bagels, breakfast, and lunch. Visit any of our locations across New Jersey and New York or order online …
Bagel Supreme | Wallington
Official Website of Bagel Supreme in Wallington NJ. Get latest news, coupons and order ahead.
Reviews
Chris
I go to this place often. I keep giving them a chance. Depending on who is working definitely has an effect on how your bagel will be. If it’s the man that I believe to be the owner your food will be amazing. If it’s not him sometimes I don’t stop in. Today I made the mistake of stopping in when he wasn’t working. Anyhow I order an egg bagel with EXTRA butter. I got a hard bagel with minimal butter. I feel bad but it’s just been to many times. I’ll drive to the bagel place in heights.
… moreAmanda Feliciano
Tried ordering the morning after my birthday celebration, Called and asked to add a small black coffee to my order. The first girl was super sweet and going to add it and suddenly some man got on the phone aggressively, asking for my card information and REPEATING IT OUT LOUDin front of whoever was there several times, Then saying it declined (When I know very well that it definitely Has money available and even offered to repeat it Once again-Knowing that this man would literally scream it out in front of anybody) My coffee maker literally broke yesterday, so I’m waiting on my replacement and it’s crazy to think that people can be so rude knowing other peoples circumstances. I highly suggest the bagel supreme and Rutherford over Wallington. (Which is the one I meant to order from and didn’t realize until I called back)
… moreAnthony C.
Place is unsanitary. Workers not wearing gloves while handling foods. Found piece of what looks like Saran Wrap in bagel. Do not recommend.
… moreRobert Pattinson
Used to come here often and I recommended this place to my mom
She wanted an egg sandwich on a roll and a hashbrown. They ended up putting the hashbrown inside the sandwich which could be an understandable miscommunication but they responded by saying it will cost extra to have it separated
Not so pleasant to hear
… moreShe wanted an egg sandwich on a roll and a hashbrown. They ended up putting the hashbrown inside the sandwich which could be an understandable miscommunication but they responded by saying it will cost extra to have it separated
Not so pleasant to hear
Mathias Zaba
Thought I’d give these guys another shot. Received stale croissants a few times and a muffin with mold growing on it. They lost my business after today. Asked if the croissants are fresh and the guy behind the counter told me they are “soft”. Oh and another muffin with mold on it that my two year old was going to nibble on. Stay away. Quality check isn’t great and the bagels are decent at best. Photos of the muffin attached.
… moreGicell Reyes
They are supreme bagels for real.
We have a bagel spot closer to us but love making the drive to pick up breakfast here. Also they have fresh squeezed orange juice!
… moreWe have a bagel spot closer to us but love making the drive to pick up breakfast here. Also they have fresh squeezed orange juice!
Kim Alterio
I had ordered a bacon egg and cheese on a bagel and asked for the bacon to be well done. They gave me undercooked, chewy, soggy bacon that made me gag and there was no cheese on my sandwich. I wanted to
Give them another shot because it is conveniently close by so I ordered from them again. Same exact order. I just figured they made a mistake the first time and things happen. But when I got my sandwich, it was the same exact problem! From the previous reviews that I have read, I am not the only one complaining about their bacon. I don’t think they know how to cook the bacon properly. Will not be coming back here!
… moreGive them another shot because it is conveniently close by so I ordered from them again. Same exact order. I just figured they made a mistake the first time and things happen. But when I got my sandwich, it was the same exact problem! From the previous reviews that I have read, I am not the only one complaining about their bacon. I don’t think they know how to cook the bacon properly. Will not be coming back here!
Amanda Martinez
Food was great. 5 stars for food. Ordered pick up thru their website around 2:30pm on a Monday. I get a call at 2:57 saying they close in 3 minutes and to hurry and pick up my food because they’re gonna close at 3pm. I told them online it says they’re open till 5pm on Mondays. I don’t mind if it’s a mistake but the man on the phone sounded upset about it. Idk just fix your hours on Google.
… moreCarla C
Disappointed…I finally got to try this place and ordered a WW everything with CC and bacon. They must use already cooked bacon because it was so salty and smokey, not a fan. I love bacon and didn’t think it was possible to NOT like bacon. He didn’t heat the bacon enough so it was still cold. The bagel tasted like it was old and from Saturday. I also ordered a TEC on a roll and the roll was hard in spots and didn’t taste fresh either.
… moreJacob Bizub
The hours list the place opening at 5AM.
However, there have been multiple times when I arrive around 5:30AM and either the staff is just getting there or non of the bagels are ready yet. The exception is Edwin who is ALWAYS there on time and has bagels ready to go at 5AM
If the business is set to open at 5AM don’t you think bagels should be ready by then? Myself, along with other customers have been turned away because the bagels just aren’t there.
Certainly a way to lose business and have your customers go to Dunkin next door to get their food.
Shame, as I really do like the bagels here – just annoying for the early risers that want a yummy bagel and aren’t able to buy one.
… moreHowever, there have been multiple times when I arrive around 5:30AM and either the staff is just getting there or non of the bagels are ready yet. The exception is Edwin who is ALWAYS there on time and has bagels ready to go at 5AM
If the business is set to open at 5AM don’t you think bagels should be ready by then? Myself, along with other customers have been turned away because the bagels just aren’t there.
Certainly a way to lose business and have your customers go to Dunkin next door to get their food.
Shame, as I really do like the bagels here – just annoying for the early risers that want a yummy bagel and aren’t able to buy one.