Social Profile: 
![]()
✔️Breakfast ✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Classic bagels, speciality sandwiches & salads are the focus at this buzzing, deli-style locale.
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
bagelmasters-n4ei7gc7.toast.site
Related Web Results
Bagel Masters
See our latest menu, find our hours, and order online directly from us. Locations in Shrewsbury, NJ.
Bagel Masters | Shrewsbury NJ – Facebook
Bagel Masters, Shrewsbury. 4315 likes · 23 talking about this · 1223 were here. Voted BEST BAGELS in all of Monmouth County and New Jersey!
Bagel Masters (@bagelmasters) • Instagram photos and videos
4.1K+ followers · 487 following · 749 posts · @bagelmasters: “ Monmouth County, NJ Follow us on TikTok• @bagel_masters (732) 224-0333 …
Reviews
M- T-
Ordered an egg and cheese and got a bacon egg and cheese so didn’t like the lack of attention to detail but I do appreciate they have mini bagels in diff flavors. Make your own coffee too which was cool. Nice local spot
… moreTravis R
Sad dried out little egg, sad little piece of cheese, flavorless doughy bagel, extremely unpleasant woman working behind the counter, you can’t just call in an order on the way work, it has to be done online. Way too many better options to ever go back here.
… moreCarol Vanessa
Best bagels outside of NYC. Nothing like it in all of Monmouth County. And priced right! What a bagel experience is supposed to be like
… morePower Wash Plus Chris Nickel
Tried ordering online. Shuts of at 1pm ok. Called 110pm wouldnt accept order over the phone. Ok drove there got there at 125pm told me the grill was off and they were closing soon. Though I can see the guys cooking on the grill. I walked out. Will never be back and I will be sure to tell everyone about this experience
… moreAlessandra Loffredo
Love this place! Always packed with good reason. Having a dairy allergy it’s hard finding alternatives for cheeses/cream cheeses especially with bagel shops but they have vegan cream cheese, regular and vegetable too! Tastes just like regular cream cheese. And of course the bagels/ sandwiches are great as well. I love that they offer mini bagels because honestly the mini ones are just enough. Definitely the spot to come.
… moreMichael Dolan
Ordered a plain bagel toasted with butter and a super cinnamon with cream cheese. Got home and it’s a plain with cream cheese and a raisin bagel with cream cheese. The receipt is correct, worker messed up. CHECK YOUR ORDERS BEFORE YOU LEAVE THE STORE. This is definitely not the first time this place has done this with me.
… moreDeacon Christopher Germak
Traditional NJ bagel. Yes. Pork Roll and Egg.
Food: …
… moreFood: …
David M. Dwight
Starting our shift on Medic Unit #1202 with a cancel at Complete Care of Shrewsbury, made a stop at a place we haven’t been to since before COVID…
Today’s sandwich was Bacon, Egg, Cheese, Jalapenos on a toasted Rye Bagel with SPK!!!
Fantastic tasting sandwich, fresh ingredients, eggs and bacon fried to perfection!!!
It’s a shame we made this stop at the end of the 8 week rotation…
… moreToday’s sandwich was Bacon, Egg, Cheese, Jalapenos on a toasted Rye Bagel with SPK!!!
Fantastic tasting sandwich, fresh ingredients, eggs and bacon fried to perfection!!!
It’s a shame we made this stop at the end of the 8 week rotation…
Joshua Harris
I am Hugh and I am 8. I think Bargemasters is great! I go there once a month, it’s truly the best. If I could rate it on a scale of 1 to 10 it would be… 6,7… (my dad posted it to his account for me upon my request because I don’t have one…)
… moreJustin Anderson
Absolutely the best bagel shop. Bagels are the perfect mix of fluffy on the inside and chewy crust on the outside. They have all the best toppings and the best part is that they put them on both sides of the bagel. The breakfast egg sandwiches are really good. They are super quick despite the long lines. Cash only.
… more