Social Profile: 
✔️Breakfast ✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out
… View more
Breakfast and Lunch!! Open every day!! Hand rolled water bagels made fresh every day! The best breakfast sandwiches, Omelets, egg platters, muffins, etc. Full Deli!! All Boars Head products. Salads, Chicken Cutlets, Grilled Chicken, Eggplant, Grilled Veggies, knish, Potato pancakes all made in house!!!
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Bagel Girls Cafe | Chester NY – Facebook
We are Hiring!!!! Full time counter help and kitchen help!!!! Please call (845) 469-8505 and ask to speak with Toni or Michele
Bagel Girls Cafe – “Award-Winning Bagels & Breakfast in Orange …
Best in Orange County, NY. Bagel Girls Cafe. A Dream, Hand-Rolled. Welcome to Bagel Girls Cafe, where every bite is made with love and tradition. For over 9 …
Bagel Girls Cafe – Chester, NY 10918 – Whereisthemenu.net
Bagel Girls Cafe No. 894 Bagel Girls Cafe 69 Brookside Ave Chester, NY 10918 (845) 469-8505 – none – Instagram Facebook Yelp
Reviews
Courtney Hintze
Went in unknowingly close to closing time so our options were limited but we were still graciously accommodated. This place deserves way more stars than it has. It is nearly impossible to get a GOOD shmear of cream cheese in this area and it’s been so long since I’ve had a cream cheese bagel this good with the perfect amount of cream cheese. The pre-made sandwich was also very good which can be tough to perfect.
… moreStephanie R.
Great bagel shop offering sandwiches, god variety of bagels and even a good choice for gluten free bagels and even wraps. Excellent service and friendly people who took the time to make sure they were celiac safe with the handling and preparation of bagels.
… moreCarmen K. Thomas
10/10 delicious sandwiches. They have a wide variety of options. We ate a cinnamon raisin bagel with Taylor ham (which they said is a breakfast ham) and cranberry cream cheese and chicken parm on a roll. The bagel flavors are on display next to the register. You order straight ahead and while they make your order you take your receipt to the counter on the left to pay. The service was friendly and fast. The portions are very large. The pictures are only half of each sandwich and they cut them for you so it’s easy to manage. Definitely recommend!
… moreLu H
Ordered sausage eggs and cheese on Jalapeño bagel, farm made chocolate milk, cookies, and coffee.
It was a good breakfast to fill my stomach until 2~3 pm. The jalapeño bagel was a brand new flavor, and as a jalapeño bagel lover, I would say it needs improvements on texture and taste.
… moreIt was a good breakfast to fill my stomach until 2~3 pm. The jalapeño bagel was a brand new flavor, and as a jalapeño bagel lover, I would say it needs improvements on texture and taste.
Douglas Roberts
I visited in the area for a week and it took me a couple days to find a bagel shop this good and I ate here 5-6 times. I personally loved they had egg everything, but also loved the French toast bagel.
I also want to talk about some of the bad review. I met the cashier and while I understand the abrasiveness, I just took him as your everyday New Yorker, and never actually had a problem.
I’ve also seen a couple complaints about the charges coming up one price and when you give a credit card it comes up higher. This is because all New York vendors say give a cash only price, but then if you pay with card you pay a extra percentage. I myself loved that I could get a sandwich, large snapple, and a 5-6 bagels to go and it cost less than 20 bucks.
… moreI also want to talk about some of the bad review. I met the cashier and while I understand the abrasiveness, I just took him as your everyday New Yorker, and never actually had a problem.
I’ve also seen a couple complaints about the charges coming up one price and when you give a credit card it comes up higher. This is because all New York vendors say give a cash only price, but then if you pay with card you pay a extra percentage. I myself loved that I could get a sandwich, large snapple, and a 5-6 bagels to go and it cost less than 20 bucks.
Alex Rousak (Enjoyer of Cake)
The place is impressively large with a wide variety of options. I got two bagels and two pastries. The prices were above average but I was excited to give the place a try.
Unfortunately, the bagels had a funky aftertaste and the pastries were stale. At the prices they wanted, this was really disappointing.
… moreUnfortunately, the bagels had a funky aftertaste and the pastries were stale. At the prices they wanted, this was really disappointing.
kick rocks
EDIT – Since posting this, the bagels I get have been much more consistent with the amount of cream cheese, so I am changing this to a 5 star review. Thanks Bagel Girls
I love Bagel Girls and come here probably 4 times a week and have considered writing a review just like this several times. Half the time I go, they put on so much cream cheese and its amazing, and the other half, like today, I get little to zero cream cheese. In the pictures I posted this is unacceptable for a bagel store to sell a bagel with cream cheese like this. Please remedy this as its made me consider going somewhere else.
… moreI love Bagel Girls and come here probably 4 times a week and have considered writing a review just like this several times. Half the time I go, they put on so much cream cheese and its amazing, and the other half, like today, I get little to zero cream cheese. In the pictures I posted this is unacceptable for a bagel store to sell a bagel with cream cheese like this. Please remedy this as its made me consider going somewhere else.
Bella Swan
A rude man took my order & was making food – he was very passive aggressive about a very common order that he found ridiculous perhaps culturally.. essentially something very simple and realistically none of his business.. A truly standard order that he found lavish & not to his taste.
It was totally abnormal so i left.
… moreIt was totally abnormal so i left.
Lisa Blackman
The way bagels should be – big, warm, and fresh. The choices are great – jalapeno, asiago – yummy. Staff are on point. Bagel Bill always a super friendly checkout.
… moreSusan Tobin
This place is extremely expensive. I ordered a bagel with cream cheese and 2 bagels with butter, 3 drinks, and a cake that said $13 on it and my total came out to $39? And I didn’t get a receipt so I can’t even see how much they were but the menus online are saying bagel with cream cheese $3.50 and bagels with butter are $2.25 so my total didn’t make sense unless they are charging $6 per beverage. Also the last 2 times I went there, I got a muffin and it was stale and hard. How to you not feel that when you are putting it in my bag? Anyway this last time will be my last.
… more