Social Profile: 
✔️Breakfast ✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out
… View more
Family-owned and operated, we’re the original Bagel Boss that’s served Hicksville since 1976. Every day, you’ll find us making every baked good from scratch. Think bagels that make your mouth water, croissants, danishes, and cookies for your sweet tooth! We’re open 24/7 and are Kosher dairy. Every item is made fresh, and our selection is just about endless.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 432 S Oyster Bay Rd, Hicksville, NY 11801
Phone: (516) 681-1856
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Home – Bagel Boss Hicksville – Bagel Shop in Hicksville, NY
Bagel Boss serving Hicksville since 1975. View Our Menu. Open 24/7! Click here to place an order. Welcome to Bagel Boss Online Ordering.
Bagel Boss Hicksville – Facebook
Bagel Boss Hicksville, Hicksville. 2032 likes · 3 talking about this · 4675 were here. Family owned and operated. Kosher Dairy, and home of the best…
Bagel Boss Hicksville – MapQuest
Get more information for Bagel Boss Hicksville in Hicksville, NY. See reviews, map, get the address, and find directions.
Reviews
William Cheung
Added: Its so telling when you see the owner respond to a 5 star review the day I posted and notice none of the negative reviews even get a response. Even the ones from weeks ago but yet 4 days ago responded to a positive one.
I can only believe the owner is fine with customers getting this quality of product and don’t care about the customers that aren’t happy.
The audacity to charge $5.50 for an everything bagel with scallion cream cheese and give this little cream cheese? I ordered 2 bagels and they both had this little in each.
My 3 year old daughter was so excited to have a cream cheese bagel. She likes to lick the cream cheese. Theres practically none.
The bagel shop in syosset gives a nice generous portion.
… moreI can only believe the owner is fine with customers getting this quality of product and don’t care about the customers that aren’t happy.
The audacity to charge $5.50 for an everything bagel with scallion cream cheese and give this little cream cheese? I ordered 2 bagels and they both had this little in each.
My 3 year old daughter was so excited to have a cream cheese bagel. She likes to lick the cream cheese. Theres practically none.
The bagel shop in syosset gives a nice generous portion.
michael heffez
Great place. Great Service. Great environment. Great options! What’s not so great: prices and size of bagels but otherwise very very good! Bagel was nicely toasted and fresh and egg salad was very fresh and good! They were even open Xmas day!!!
… moreKaren Pierre-Louis
Stopped by as we headed to our long road trip. I said we didn’t get bagels and that was on my NY list. When I saw “24 hours” we headed there! Large shop, good variety of bagels! The cream cheese was absolutely delicious! Would certainly come again. The wait was a little long, but worth it!
… moreHumble Mom12
New: What a great start to our Sunday! The bagels are absolutely delicious, and the recipe never changes! Our family relocated to the South from this area, and we could not wait to stop for bagels on our NY visit. My teen grew up Southern but has been coming here with us for years, and hopefully, someday, he brings his kids here, too.
Service is friendly and quick!
12 months ago here: The best! A must stop when we visit our families in NY. Until next time! Susan
… moreService is friendly and quick!
12 months ago here: The best! A must stop when we visit our families in NY. Until next time! Susan
Kimberly Faraci
Not sure of the reason but this place is it the best it’s ever been. Came in today and had a warm sesame bagel with scallion cream cheese, tomato and nova and it was simply sensational. Freshness matched customer service! I will be returning soon. Whether you ask for Scott or not…you are in the best possible hands SOOOOOO if you’re looking for a great place for breakfast, brunch, lunch, dinner or a late night snack…this Kosher 24 hour bagel place will definitely make you happy! SIMPLY DELICIOUS!
… moreMohammed-Ali Dewji
Been coming to this location for a very long time, but today my wife and I asked for 2 bagels with cream cheese and this is what we got
… moreGayatri Chandan
We visited here 5-7 times and every time the taste of bagel is great. Loved their everything bagel with veggie cream cheese & everything bagel with jalapeños cream cheese. We asked them to add tomato with salt & pepper today, the taste was great. Staff is attentive & make everything as per instructions. Recommended.
… moreThomas Wang (tomtom)
Having heard a lot of buzz about Bagel Boss, and being a Queens native, I decided to check it out.
The bagels themselves were decent, but the standout was definitely the exceptional walnut raisin cream cheese.
It’s worth noting that because it’s a kosher establishment, you won’t find options like bacon to go with your egg, and cheese.
While the staff provided attentive service, the system for ordering and waiting for pickup could be more streamlined.
Both hot and iced coffee is on the side for diy.
It’s a little expensive, Manhattan price for long Island…
… moreThe bagels themselves were decent, but the standout was definitely the exceptional walnut raisin cream cheese.
It’s worth noting that because it’s a kosher establishment, you won’t find options like bacon to go with your egg, and cheese.
While the staff provided attentive service, the system for ordering and waiting for pickup could be more streamlined.
Both hot and iced coffee is on the side for diy.
It’s a little expensive, Manhattan price for long Island…
Rachel Epstein
We could not have found a better place, on every level, than Bagel Boss Hicksville, for a family gathering for a lite bite together last Sunday. Through the kindness of Terri, who we were working with, we secured the back dining room for our group. The “buffet” of bagel sandwiches, salads, fruit and cookies, was perfect. The platters were decorated beautifully and the food plentiful. Thanks to the good care of Terri and Delaney (forgive if misspelled), throughout the time we were there, helping, refilling, accommodating every request and assisting in packing up what was leftover, for all of us to take, made our time there just perfect. Everyone enjoyed fully. On behalf of our family, a sincere thank you Bagel Boss. Thank you Terri and Delaney for your kindness to our family and your exceptional service and attention to us throughout.
… moreFrank Feeley
Disappointing…I’ve been to other Bagel Boss locations and stopped at this one because I was working in the area looking to get a BE&C. They told me this location was kosher so no meats. I get it and it’s fine to eat kosher but I just wish it were advertised clearly on the outside. You expect a chain restaurant to all serve the same food, call it “Bagel Boss Kosher” or something. The BE&C is a New York staple so you expect to see it in all bagel stores and it’s a shock when you don’t, and you’re already inside the restaurant having waited in line.
I did end up ordering an Egg and cheddar on an everything bagel. Unfortunately the bagel was dry (even at 6:30am) and I’m pretty sure I was given American cheese, it had little flavor. Cost me almost $10 even without the meat. Definitely a disappointing breakfast.
… moreI did end up ordering an Egg and cheddar on an everything bagel. Unfortunately the bagel was dry (even at 6:30am) and I’m pretty sure I was given American cheese, it had little flavor. Cost me almost $10 even without the meat. Definitely a disappointing breakfast.