Alfonso Vivar
I don’t know where to start with this one. I think this has to be one of the most difficult places to review. I want to start by sharing that the area does not really welcome visitors or tourists. Every store in town purposely does not have restrooms or facilities so the only way to use a restroom is to either live in the area or have a rental nearby. This is all important because the shops including this one are designed to serve people in town not visitors or tourists. Aside from all this the coffee was great and the bagels are not your common bagels they have a strange dough to crust ratio they are very doughy. They are still good though if you like doughy bagels. The place looked clean and well decorated. Many options to choose from and lots of healthy choices. I would not come back if the line and wait was the same as today.
… moreErin Gillespie
Honestly I can’t take it anymore, I need to keep it real! The coffee here is an abomination. I tried it multiple times this summer trying to understand why there was always a crowd. The coffee plain sucks. It tastes like dirty plain water dyed brown. And the woman who works there rolled her eyes at me when I rolled my sleeping infant in with the stroller. The coffee sucks- go to Wawa or literally anywhere else! Please stop watering down the coffee and put some love into it for the love of god!
… moreNicole W.
Coffee was amazing but bagels/pastries were a few days old. I had a bagel from here a few days ago and it was super fresh so I returned today.. only to be serve a completely stale bagel. Disappointed to say the least.
… moreL Check
The service is horrific! Took 20 minutes to get someone’s attention! One of the short order cooks took our order and kept his gloves on while handling money and then returned to the grill. The food was not cooked as ordered and once recooked remained inedible. I WOULD NEVER GO BACK!!!!
… moreGraham Snyder
Great bagels, unfortunately you don’t get what you order. Overwhelming atmosphere and while staff does not make you feel rushed, setup of the store incentivizes competing to cut the line. I have gone here 3 days in a row and not received my correct order once.
… moreTaylor Lucas
Had two bagels a couple of coffees. The bagels are thick and very filling. The latte was decent but cold brew left something to be desired. As others mentioned, it’s a little chaotic inside.
… moreGabrielle Lewis
Great bagels, good pastries and fair prices on an otherwise outlandishly expensive island. Not the best coffee but with how consistent other items are that’s fine. Great when the college kids are running it, service drops off with the High School staff but it is still a prime summer location!
… moreSusan Lizbeth
This quaint coffee shoppe is the bomb! It’s the social place to be, relaxing on the outside patio with some iced- coffee and pasties / bagels. The staff is smiling and busily preparing your egg bagel sandwiches. The pork roll is sliced thin and plentiful. Dog friendly with a water dish and a leash hook up! I visit this place daily, try it out..it’s the only place to get your morning Joe while on vacation.
… moreChristopher Cloutier
Ordered a pork roll, egg, and cheese on an everything bagel. Bagel itself was okay, but for over $10 they only put two slices of pork roll and one egg, pretty disappointing for the price. I also grabbed an iced coffee, which was over $5. At this point I’m numb to high coffee prices on the island, but for the sandwich, the value just wasn’t there.
… moreThe GOOD Meow
Best coffee in Avalon!
Breakfast, lunch, coffee and drinks Mike Nester and Sean Ford opened Avalon Coffee Co. doors the summer of 1994. Our philosophy is simple, like the cool beaches of Avalon. Do everything humanly possible to provide the absolute highest quality products.
… more