Social Profile: 
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Upscale bakeshop specializing in custom event cakes & a wide range of breads, pastries & sweets.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 229 Montauk Hwy, West Sayville, NY 11796
Phone: (631) 244-7288
Website: http://www.audreybakes.com/
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Audrey’s Fine Baked Goods
Audrey’s Fine Baked Goods has earned a well-known and respected reputation in the industry, providing high-quality baked goods for Long Island and New York tri- …
Audrey’s Bakery (@audreysfinebakedgoods) – Instagram
Custom Cakes • Pastries • Desserts Serving Long Island and NYC For all inquiries and orders, please call the storefront. No DMs for orders please.
Audrey’s Fine Baked Goods | West Sayville NY – Facebook
Stop by or give us a call for all inquiries. Tuesday- Saturday 7 am- 6 pm and Sunday 7 am- 4 pm. Follow @audreysfinebakedgoods for bakery updates! . . . . . # …
Reviews
M Harris
I recently returned to Audrey’s after a long break and was thrilled to find nothing has changed – everything is still amazing! I’ve been a loyal customer since my daughters were young teenagers. Audrey’s creates beautifully decorated cakes that taste delicious. My latest cake was no exception, though it had a bit too much frosting. Next time, I will definitely request less frosting. Despite this minor detail, the quality and service remain top-notch. It’s great to be back enjoying Audrey’s wonderful cakes! Highly recommended! #AudreysCake #ScrumptiousSweets #HappyCustomer
… moreAshley Genza
Audrey’s made our wedding cake and it was absolutely delicious!! They were so easy to work with and decorated our cake beautifully. We also recently had them make our gender reveal cake as well and again so fresh and delicious! Their rainbow cookies are one of our favorites as well. Definitely going to be our go to cake place from now one.
… moreKatherine Hartig
This was the second bakery my husband and I visited for our wedding cake tasting, and the difference was incredible! From the moment we walked in, the experience felt so much more personal and enjoyable.
We loved everything we tried and found it so easy to share photos of the cake design we had in mind, even though it wasn’t one of their standard templates. The team brought our vision to life beautifully, and the final cake was exactly what we had hoped for, we thought it was fun and delicious.
We couldn’t have been happier with the result and would absolutely go back for future celebrations or any occasion that calls for an amazing cake or sweet treat!
… moreWe loved everything we tried and found it so easy to share photos of the cake design we had in mind, even though it wasn’t one of their standard templates. The team brought our vision to life beautifully, and the final cake was exactly what we had hoped for, we thought it was fun and delicious.
We couldn’t have been happier with the result and would absolutely go back for future celebrations or any occasion that calls for an amazing cake or sweet treat!
Noelle Berardi
Audrey’s was absolutely incredible to work with from start to finish! We called very last minute to see about a cake for our elopement in NYC… they accommodated us without hesitation! They helped us build a beautiful cake full of flavor but not too sweet and kept the design smooth and natural as requested! The cake was beyond incredible— moist and full of flavor— and the filling was classic cannoli which was a huge crowd pleaser! I cannot thank Audrey’s enough for all they did for us— and just how AFFORDABLE it was— it felt like a steal! Thank you thank you thank you!!!! To be clear… we added the pearls after the fact and our design skills are not so good!
… morejennifer fraccalvieri
We are still blown away by our wedding cake from Audrey’s Bakery! It was everything we dreamed of — vintage, elegant, and absolutely stunning. People rarely go out of their way to compliment a wedding cake, but ours was getting praise all night long. Guests couldn’t stop talking about how beautiful it looked and how amazing it tasted. Every flavor was a hit! Audrey’s truly went above and beyond and made us the most perfect cake — it was such a special (and delicious) part of our day. I can’t wait edit this review with photos.
… moreCecile Harrison
We ordered our daughter’s wedding cake from Audrey’s in Oct. 2024 and were very happy with it! We had so many compliments from guests. Not only did it look amazing, the taste was out-of-this-world. Katie was very patient answering our many questions/concerns and explaining the process. I had tasted cakes at several bakeries before choosing Audrey’s, and felt Audrey’s offered the best combinations of designs, fillings, and flavors as well as overall taste. Also, Audrey’s was willing to deliver the cake to the venue which was 45 minutes from the bakery. It arrived in perfect condition! The price was very reasonable compared to several high-end bakeries closer to our venue and we thought Audrey’s tasted better as well. Highly recommend!
… moreT Bro
We used Audrey’s Fine Baked Goods for our cake, the recommended vendor through Land’s End. Since I’m not a big cake person, we decided to keep it simple with a small, vintage-inspired heart cake just for the cake-cutting ceremony. Katie completely understood our vision and executed it beautifully — the design was elegant, charming, and exactly what we had in mind!
Even though cake wasn’t a big priority for us, the one they created was absolutely delicious and exceeded our expectations. It was the perfect sweet touch to our day, and we’re so grateful for their creativity and professionalism. Highly recommend!
… moreEven though cake wasn’t a big priority for us, the one they created was absolutely delicious and exceeded our expectations. It was the perfect sweet touch to our day, and we’re so grateful for their creativity and professionalism. Highly recommend!
Hillary and Dan Troutman
We tasted cakes from three different bakeries while choosing our wedding cake, and after our planner recommended Audrey’s, we quickly understood why. Their cakes were by far our favorite — fresh, flavorful, and beautifully made.
Audrey’s was also so reliable and easy to work with. Delivery showed up exactly on time, everything was set perfectly, and the cake looked gorgeous on display. We wanted something that felt special but didn’t break the bank, and Audrey’s was the perfect fit — budget-friendly without ever compromising on quality or taste.
We chose two flavors: vanilla with fresh strawberry and whipped cream, and chocolate with cream cheese filling. Both were absolutely delicious, and our guests raved about how good the cake was.
A beautiful, tasty, and stress-free experience from start to finish — we couldn’t recommend Audrey’s more!
… moreAudrey’s was also so reliable and easy to work with. Delivery showed up exactly on time, everything was set perfectly, and the cake looked gorgeous on display. We wanted something that felt special but didn’t break the bank, and Audrey’s was the perfect fit — budget-friendly without ever compromising on quality or taste.
We chose two flavors: vanilla with fresh strawberry and whipped cream, and chocolate with cream cheese filling. Both were absolutely delicious, and our guests raved about how good the cake was.
A beautiful, tasty, and stress-free experience from start to finish — we couldn’t recommend Audrey’s more!
N dS
Inquired about their mousses- only chocolate doesn’t have gelatin. They make cute little cakes that are great for entertaining. Came early to a fully stocked bakery, and they were friendly from the get go. Ample parking.
… moreAlexandra McWhirter
My family and I have used Audrey’s for years and have also recommended it to my friend for their wedding and engagement party. They do not disappoint and truly make your cake dreams come true. Not only do the decorations on the cake look amazing but it tastes even better. I will always come back to this bakery (even though I am not local)
… more