Diamond Oakes
I came in and ordered food, it took an hour and 20 minutes to get my food out. When I did get my food it was not hot and obviously burnt. I wanted to have it remade but already had waited almost an hour and a half for my food. I ordered extra ricotta and did not receive that, half my calzone was practically flat and barely had any cheese at all in it. I then went in to order a shake and the cup had dirt all over it as pictured and the shake wasn’t mixed so I had to get that remade as well. Overall just very disappointed.
… moreJohn kennett
Used to be great pizza. Now it’s burnt every time. If I complained every time I received a burnt pizza I would be complaining every time I ordered pizza. Better to just bribg my business elsewhere.
… moreHayden Gunnell
$0.75 for less than a handful of shredded lettuce? Ive never seen a restaurant charge an extra 3 dollars for basic sandwich toppings. Sandwich was okay, not as I remember, but when I worked at a different location I’d make it myself. I was also the only person in house and it took 12 minutes to receive my food.
… moreSandra Wozniak
Great meatball grinder, bread was so fresh and meatballs sliced with cheese. Delicious! The personal pan pepperoni pizza was also delicious.
… moreJared M
Great place for a local pizza! The staff are awesome and the pizza makes you remember how much fun it was to get a pizza as a kid in a pizza shop. Bellows falls is amazing and this is a staple 🙂
… moreSusan M
The pizza was great, I have tried the pizza at 2 other Athens pizza restaurants. This has the best crust between the 3 of them, toppings are plentiful and the price is right on point with any other pizza place around. The friendly service and quiet atmosphere( depending on when you go) is very welcoming, restrooms are clean and stocked the 3 times I’ve been in the last month. We have tried a small pizza, a grinder/sub and a family size pizza and each one has been as close to perfect as you can get. If you can lunch is a great time, or between regular meal times, it’s when it’s fast and quiet if eating in.. but they are fast enough if you’re taking out as well.
… moreAmanda Wilcox
This was a go to spot as a kid. Haven’t been in for over 20 years. Was so nostalgic going back in and it looking and tasting the same as I remember. Excellent!!!
… moreBethany Parish
Every time I have ordered from Athens pizza it takes over an hour to get delivered and when I call complaining I always get put on hold for 10-20 minutes. Worst service ever!
… moreBruce Silverman
Very disappointed with this steak & cheese grinder w/mushrooms, peppers & onions. The meat was excessively fatty & obviously of low quality. Had I known that this beforehand that is one of the ways they cut corners to improve profitability, I would never had ordered it & just stuck to my trusty turkey & provolone grinder. Now I know
… moreJaimie G
We recently had trouble with our order. I called and the manager on duty (I didn’t get her name) was so nice and had our burgers remade and delivered to our house. That was amazing. Thank you for going an extra mile for us. We appreciate it.
… more