Fast-food restaurant known for fried chicken, also serving up sandwiches & sides in simple digs.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 126 Montauk Hwy #2600, East Islip, NY 11730
Phone: (631) 581-1141
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Arthur Treachers Fish & Chips – East Islip – MapQuest
Get more information for Arthur Treachers Fish & Chips in East Islip, NY. See reviews, map, get the address, and find directions.
Arthur Treacher’s – Wikipedia
Arthur Treacher’s Fish & Chips is an American fast food seafood restaurant … In East Islip, NY, a small strip-mall store has a combination Pudgie’s …
Last one standing in Islip!!!!! Arthur Treacher’s 野 FISH & CHIPS 北N
Damian Buscemi East Islip, Pudgies chicken and Arthur’s Treachers in the same store front. … I worked in a fine restaurant in Batavia, New York …
Reviews
Maegan
I came here to get fish and I was disappointed. Food was DISGUSTING. I called back and spoke with a woman there and she told me that there is nothing wrong with their food. I explained to her that when I bit into the fish, the batter was grainy and she denied it and told me that if I don’t like it, don’t come again. I’m not sure why she became so defensive. I wasn’t rude. I’m more annoyed that they would think serving this is acceptable
I wouldn’t suggest anyone visit this establishment. It’s never good when a business talks to a customer like this. Fish shouldn’t look like this on the inside.
… moreI wouldn’t suggest anyone visit this establishment. It’s never good when a business talks to a customer like this. Fish shouldn’t look like this on the inside.
Nitrotripper
The French fries were undercooked and freezer burn taste. The popcorn chicken is just different shaped chicken nuggets (processed chicken). I couldn’t believe that they offer a chicken pot pie and they showed me that it is a Marie Calendars frozen in the box. They don’t even make their own. I do not recommend getting any of the fish products they offer because it is so old and dry with a bad taste.
… moreJeff Scott
This is the worst place on the south shore of Long Island. Don’t PATRONIZE this store. The owner is a rude and very stupid and aggressive Indian woman. She has no concept of customer services. When asked about a portion, she screamed about price complaints when price was never an issue. Refused to speak about it and created confrontation over chicken and fries. She in inconsiderate and unworthy of business. Prior owners were good people. This shop is horrendous and the ownership has diluted all the community value. I would rather not eat them give this establishment a nickel. The worst place you can go. Period.
… moreTeresa Jones
NO DINE IN- TAKE OUT ONLY. Fish was dry & grainy inside- greasy/oily on outside. No flavoring/no taste- very dissapointed. Pop machine was broken-had to buy cans. We weren’t asked what condiments we wanted- worker just threw a handful of condiment packets into the bag- ketchup & vinegar ones were thrown away- what a waste. In addition, after texting on her phone- she touched the forks, napkins & condiment packets with unwashed hands & no gloves. Where is the health dept ?? Will never return to this establishment.
… morePABLO A LOPEZ
This was my first visit to the East Islip Pudgies and it wasn’t a good experience. The pieces of chicken were extremely small and they didn’t have any taste. The Selden store chicken was a lot bigger than the East Islip store. I will not be ordering from the East Islip again.
… moreValerie Radocy
When I arrived the cook was standing outside, looked like a customer. When I went inside to place my order, also with the same person. She did NOT wash her hands or out on gloves and proceeded to cook out good with her bare hands. I will NEVER return it recommend this place. It should be reported to Department of Health. Good wasn’t that good either.
… moreGerard Białek
Arthur’s Fish and Chips has some bangin’ fish and chips. The fillets and fries are fried to perfection. Their tartar sauce is finger lickin’ delicious. And for the cherry on top, their prices are more than fair.
The only qualm I had was their portioning. I ordered a large portion of fish and chips and received three large fish fillets and the equivalent of a small fry at Mc’D*cks. What the heck? Please consider adding more fries to that fish. Even if I had been charged an additional $3, I would have never complained about the price and been 100% satisfied.
I still gave Arthur’s 5 Stars because the quality of my food and service was just that, 5 Star.
… moreThe only qualm I had was their portioning. I ordered a large portion of fish and chips and received three large fish fillets and the equivalent of a small fry at Mc’D*cks. What the heck? Please consider adding more fries to that fish. Even if I had been charged an additional $3, I would have never complained about the price and been 100% satisfied.
I still gave Arthur’s 5 Stars because the quality of my food and service was just that, 5 Star.
Paula R
Ordered recently and asked for corn on the cob. Received a phone call saying they were out of it and said they would substitute…i didnt get a choice, they decided for me and picked the 1 item i would never eat. The chicken was dry and overcooked and there was so much grease i could have fried an entire chicken in it…never again
… moreCheryl Dargis
This place is Awesome. The hush puppies are delish. We also ordered 30 wings and fries with brown gravy. Great wings. Thumbs up!
… moreVincent
I’ve been here twice and it has been an extremely long wait in a empty store.Its very small inside to wait. On our last trip there, the chicken was good and warm, but half our side orders were cold. I won’t go here again.
… more