Milton Anderson
Arni’s has been a favorite of mine since I was a kid. The Shadeland location is the closest one when I’m at work. I tend to eat in or carry out from this location several times a year. The pizza is delicious. I also like the decor. I wish I would have taken a picture of the stained glass window. I’ll have to be sure to on my next visit. I’ll also get some pictures of my pizza and salad.
… moreTyler Smith
Absolutely love this location. They always get my order correct and it’s almost always ready to pickup in 20 mins or less. Keep up the good work and I’ll keep coming lol
… moreChristine Prickett
The lady making the food had no gloves on was touch everything and not washing her hands and is still making people food. The lady that took my order was very nice and did a great job. The tables were all dirty. The wait wasn’t long.
… moreSteven Collier
Spent 70 dollars on 1 pizza 1 sub and 1 salad the pizza was covered in so much sausage that you could not tatse or see any other toppings a d the sub was undercooked
… moreRobin S
Once you have it, you’ll crave it! Since each Arni’s is individually owned, you will have slightly different experiences. The Arni’s Jr salad is incredible. We opted for the stromboli and breadsticks with their hot/spicy cheese this time. Very delicious. Loaded with meat, cheese, onions and sauce. Nice to switch it up once in a while. Their pizzas are fantastic as well. The sauce is more of a tomato paste, the cheese, like on the salads, is diced up and makes for a great melt. Their sausage is crumbly, which I like on a pub/tavern style pizza. Now since they are owned individually and each vary a bit, I’d have to say the Crawfordsville and Rensselaer Indiana locations have a better spicy cheese sauce, in my opinion. The price is reasonable and a great value. My goal is to eventually visit all the Arni’s across the state! Go, try it, I bet you’ll find something unique that you’ll like.
… morePauley SaysSo (Pauleysaysso)
Always feels like home walking in the door. Super friendly staff and consistent food every time.
… moreDavid Sutton
The food at Arni’s is really good. I enjoy the gut buster but everything is good. Constant stream of carryouts and small number of places for dining in. Clean and nice!
… moreJennifer Logan
We have eaten here twice now. Food was great, we had the stromboli the first time and a Deluxe pizza well-done. Both were cooked perfectly. The staff was very friendly. Food came out very quickly. We will definitely be coming back.
… moreRandol Logan
Delightful Arnis. Maned by three employees and they can hold their own. Little busy on Thursday afternoon. Boys from fire department were in as well. Placed order, and didn’t seem like a long wait. Food was hot. Burnt my tongue on the pizza.Good experience during this visit. Will return and tell friends.
… more