Social Profile: 
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
#1 NY Pizzeria in the State of Colorado per The Washington Post, September 2023! Antonio’s Real New York Pizza is a haven for pizza lovers seeking authentic New York-style pizza in the heart of the Rocky Mountains. Established in 2014, Antonio’s has garnered a reputation for its delectable pies crafted by genuine New Yorkers, using time-honored recipes passed down through generations. The restaurant’s spacious 6,000 square foot interior, complete with cozy fireplaces and ample seating, provides a welcoming ambiance for both dine-in and takeout experiences. Open five days a week, Antonio’s stands as a testament to the passion and dedication of its founders, who have brought a taste of New York to Colorado.
Wood-fired pizza in a variety of styles joins subs & wings in this cozy eatery with a lodge vibe.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 1560 Big Thompson Ave, Estes Park, CO 80517
Phone: (970) 586-7275
Website: https://www.estesparkpizza.com/
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Antonio’s Real NY Pizza: Colorado’s #1 NY Pizzeria
Colorado’s #1 Ranked New York Pizzeria by The Washington Post 9/2023. Authentic NY Pizza awaits you in 2 locations: Estes Park, CO & Longmont, CO!
Antonio’s Real NY Pizza | Estes Park & Longmont
Authentic New York Pizza · Biggest Pizza in CO? · Signature Pizzas · Thin Crust NY Style · Sicilian (Thick Crust) · Margherita (Neapolitan) · Detroit Style · Ready to …
Antonio’s Real New York Pizza | Estes Park CO – Facebook
Antonio’s Real New York Pizza, Estes Park. 16699 likes · 3163 talking about this · 6335 were here. Washington Post Named us the #1 NY Pizzeria in…
Last Updates
Reviews
SFJ Something For Jake
I tried Antonio’s for the first time today for lunch, and knowing I cannot use inappropriate language, I will say that I had the best freaking pizza I have ever eaten in all my 60 years (soon to be 61)! My family and I agreed that the every ingredient of each of our pizzas was perfect, and the overall flavor was so great, we pushed ourselves to keep eating even though we were full! We brought the remaining slices home and had them for dinner. Even reheating in the microwave did not diminish the great flavor!
The service and atmosphere matched perfectly with the meal! The staff was extremely friendly, courteous, and efficient! They accurately took and submitted our order and made sure we were very well taken care of. The robots that brought us our meal is a great and entertaining touch! And I really appreciate the Veteran’s discount they provide!
I highly recommend Antonio’s to anyone and everyone! They are absolutely great and deserving of the awards and accolades they have received and well worth the money!
… moreThe service and atmosphere matched perfectly with the meal! The staff was extremely friendly, courteous, and efficient! They accurately took and submitted our order and made sure we were very well taken care of. The robots that brought us our meal is a great and entertaining touch! And I really appreciate the Veteran’s discount they provide!
I highly recommend Antonio’s to anyone and everyone! They are absolutely great and deserving of the awards and accolades they have received and well worth the money!
En Sabah Nur
The staff is the friendliest I’ve ever seen. They greeted us like we knew each other.
The food is great too.
We had a few different pizzas, a calzone, wings, salad and desert.
The pizza crust was really good and the toppings were interesting, different and really good too.
The calzone was similarly good. I got pepperoni, jalapeños and black olives.
The salad was large and amazing.
The wings were delicious.
I ordered the ghost pepper wings and they were spicy.
I am not one to really feel the spice but I did a bit which is more than most places I’ve been to and the rest of the table were feeling it. They were flavorful.
We had the tiramisu. It was good.
Restrooms are clean as is the whole restaurant.
They have robotic servers that are interesting.
The restaurant hosted a free meal for a special needs event this time that we came which really shows their character.
We have been here before (every time we come to town) and love the food but this make us love this place even more.
I highly recommend this restaurant.
A++++
What are you waiting for?
Stop by.
… moreThe food is great too.
We had a few different pizzas, a calzone, wings, salad and desert.
The pizza crust was really good and the toppings were interesting, different and really good too.
The calzone was similarly good. I got pepperoni, jalapeños and black olives.
The salad was large and amazing.
The wings were delicious.
I ordered the ghost pepper wings and they were spicy.
I am not one to really feel the spice but I did a bit which is more than most places I’ve been to and the rest of the table were feeling it. They were flavorful.
We had the tiramisu. It was good.
Restrooms are clean as is the whole restaurant.
They have robotic servers that are interesting.
The restaurant hosted a free meal for a special needs event this time that we came which really shows their character.
We have been here before (every time we come to town) and love the food but this make us love this place even more.
I highly recommend this restaurant.
A++++
What are you waiting for?
Stop by.
Rick Koch
Great service and delicious pizza! We loved the 1/2 pepper/mushroom/onion , 1/2 plain cheese pizza. The crust was perfect. The only thing to note was that the red sauce on the cheese pizza side was a little peppery (*not typical of east coast or NY style pizza). Other than that , what is to complain about? Great, friendly service with the added touch of a robot delivering the pie to the table.
… moreDan M.
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Antonio’s Real New York Pizza absolutely hit the spot. We ordered the 18-inch thin-crust New York–style pepperoni pizza, and it was everything you want—perfectly crispy fold, great sauce-to-cheese ratio, and solid pepperoni flavor. The garlic knots with marinara were extremely good too—soft, buttery, and packed with flavor.
Bonus points for their 4-blend pepper mix you can sprinkle on the pizza… that stuff is fire and takes the slice to the next level.
If you’re in Estes Park and craving legit New York–style pizza, this place is a must. We’ll definitely be back.
… moreAntonio’s Real New York Pizza absolutely hit the spot. We ordered the 18-inch thin-crust New York–style pepperoni pizza, and it was everything you want—perfectly crispy fold, great sauce-to-cheese ratio, and solid pepperoni flavor. The garlic knots with marinara were extremely good too—soft, buttery, and packed with flavor.
Bonus points for their 4-blend pepper mix you can sprinkle on the pizza… that stuff is fire and takes the slice to the next level.
If you’re in Estes Park and craving legit New York–style pizza, this place is a must. We’ll definitely be back.
Abigail Sage
i come to estes park once or twice a year for the last 8 years, so i am always looking for somewhere new to eat. my family & i finally tried antonio’s pizza, it did not disappoint! we ordered the godfather, a thin and thick crust pepperoni pizza, and the colors of italy. we all agreed the pizza was great! for dessert we got a key lime pie which was also delicious. the person who greeted us let us know it would just be him and one other person working, so they had a robot bringing out orders. would definitely recommend this restaurant & we will be coming back again!!!
… morechris welch
After an event in Estes Park, my son and I stopped here for a quick bite before we headed over to tour the Stanley hotel.
The pizza was fantastic. The biggest side I’ve ever seen and the crust is just perfect amount of chew and the sauce is the perfect balance of sweet and spicy.
It was very busy that days. It was hard for the staff to really be attentive and most were from other countries so sometimes that language barriers are tough, but they will take care of you.
… moreThe pizza was fantastic. The biggest side I’ve ever seen and the crust is just perfect amount of chew and the sauce is the perfect balance of sweet and spicy.
It was very busy that days. It was hard for the staff to really be attentive and most were from other countries so sometimes that language barriers are tough, but they will take care of you.
Jandrpru
We love the Longmont location!! And wanted to try this one. Didn’t love it.
We got our salad and garlic knots, then had to wait an hour for pizza! And couldn’t get any of the staff to even look at us! We just needed our dirty dishes removed from the table. We finally got pizza and thankfully it was pretty good. I would say the pizza was the only good thing about this experience. Staff needs to be more attentive.
Definitely will stick with the Longmont location.
… moreWe got our salad and garlic knots, then had to wait an hour for pizza! And couldn’t get any of the staff to even look at us! We just needed our dirty dishes removed from the table. We finally got pizza and thankfully it was pretty good. I would say the pizza was the only good thing about this experience. Staff needs to be more attentive.
Definitely will stick with the Longmont location.
Ms. Artichoke Cheese pizza w stuffed chz crust
What fun !!!!!!!! We came here bc I love pizza and was so happy , a robot dropped off our food !!!!!
So cool but also scary . Robots TAKIN OVER DA WORLD !
Really though , great food , good service ! And they have ARTICHOKE HEARTS !!!!!
Come here ! Wont regret it 🙂
… moreSo cool but also scary . Robots TAKIN OVER DA WORLD !
Really though , great food , good service ! And they have ARTICHOKE HEARTS !!!!!
Come here ! Wont regret it 🙂
PangNhia Burke
Update (Sunday, 9/14): They were open but operating as take-out only, which was a little disappointing since we were hoping to dine in—but still glad they were open!
On our first visit, we tried the calzone and were pleasantly surprised by how tasty it was. You get to pick three ingredients—we went with marinated chicken, fresh basil, and roasted red peppers, and it hit the spot. This time, we ordered the pesto, chicken, and roasted red pepper pizza, and it was just as good. The Sicilian pizza was another highlight—thick, hearty, and full of flavor.
One fun detail: a robot delivers your food to the table, which makes the experience unique and memorable. The servers were very attentive, and overall, their food is impressively true to New York style.
If you’re in Estes Park and craving authentic NY pizza (or a huge calzone you can customize), Antonio’s is definitely worth the stop—even if it’s take-out only for now.
… moreOn our first visit, we tried the calzone and were pleasantly surprised by how tasty it was. You get to pick three ingredients—we went with marinated chicken, fresh basil, and roasted red peppers, and it hit the spot. This time, we ordered the pesto, chicken, and roasted red pepper pizza, and it was just as good. The Sicilian pizza was another highlight—thick, hearty, and full of flavor.
One fun detail: a robot delivers your food to the table, which makes the experience unique and memorable. The servers were very attentive, and overall, their food is impressively true to New York style.
If you’re in Estes Park and craving authentic NY pizza (or a huge calzone you can customize), Antonio’s is definitely worth the stop—even if it’s take-out only for now.
Marely M
It’s a very nice place.
We went on a Wednesday afternoon.
They attended us right away and the host was accommodating.
The waiter was nice and responded all our questions. They have a big selection of pizzas. However, I was expecting the amount of topping to be more.
I would come back to this place again.
… moreWe went on a Wednesday afternoon.
They attended us right away and the host was accommodating.
The waiter was nice and responded all our questions. They have a big selection of pizzas. However, I was expecting the amount of topping to be more.
I would come back to this place again.