Michael Anthony Bennett
I moved to the area after living in NYC for the last 20 years and this is by far one of the best pizzas I’ve had. Their crust is flavorful, chewy and has a perfect crisp throughout. Their sauce is spot on, flavored with oregano and a hint of spice. I can eat the pizza fresh out of the oven when I dine-in with my family or after it cooled off inside the box on our 15 minute drive home. This is my go-to pizza spot and I will travel out of my way to come and get it instead of settling for other pizza joints nearer to my house.
… moreCat M
Such delicious food and great gluten free options! The staff is all so lovely and welcoming. Would definitely recommend and will be coming back.
… moreBrian Babcock
This place is absolutely fantastic… Antonio and Melissa the owners are awesome hosts! Custom meals for your diet. Keto, Gluten free you name it, they make it!
… moreJohn (John D)
The best calzone I’ve had in years! The balance of ricotta and mozzarella was spot on, and the pepperoni added just the right amount of flavor without being overly greasy. The crust was thick and sturdy, holding everything together perfectly without getting soggy. The portion size was generous, and the price was unbeatable—my son and I ate for just $13, including drinks. Great service and friendly staff made the experience even better. Hands down, the best calzone in the Hudson Valley. Highly recommend.
… moreNicolas C. George
I checked out Antonio’s around their third week upon moving in. I was skeptical, as the previous establishment has only lasted for a year, and the location has gone through many iterations as various delis. I was wrong to be skeptical. The food at Antonio’s has never once let me down. I specifically have ordered many different things in the past month and a half just to try and find something which I could keep off my list of recommendations when eating here. Unfortunately for any skeptics out there, the list of great foods has just kept growing. On my list of recommended foods when eating here are, the hamburger (my personal favorite and an absolute must for anyone who likes burgers), the caeser salad, the chicken tacos, the spaghetti, and actually pretty much every single menu item. I always make sure to order an appetizer of the homemade chips with homemade salsa, as they our well with every meal here. My father went into this restaurant skeptical because I wouldn’t stop mentioning how great the burgers were, and I finally got him to try it out by offering to pay for the meal if he didn’t enjoy it. He ended up paying because, in his own words “I cannot lie, that was a good burger.”
I give this restaurant my utmost recommendation and wish it a long and prosperous time in Montgomery NY
… moreEmily Rice
**I recommend everyone read the response below. The way they replied to the review shows exactly how they are as a person and how they run a business. Being called a “brat” for asking about dietary needs, while your staff cried when asked if fries were gluten free, says far more about your restaurant’s lack of professionalism and training than it does about me. Guests deserve informed, respectful service, not insults. Wish we had walked out when we could because this place didn’t deserve a single penny from us. I suggest anyone stay far away. Plenty of other options in the area.**
I came here after seeing it recommended on FindMeGlutenFree. As someone with celiac, dining out is already stressful — traveling adds an extra layer of food anxiety. Before visiting, I checked the online menu and felt confident there would be enough options for my group.
Once we arrived, however, things quickly went downhill. The printed menu had no gluten-free options listed. This created confusion- especially since we were left to sit with menus for 30 minutes without anyone checking on us. When we were able to ask our server about gluten free options, she seemed unaware of what was safe and had to check with the kitchen. We patiently waited, got our answers, and placed our order.
Then, instead of reassurance, the owner(?) came to our table and informed us that our questions were rude and had made the server “uncomfortable” to the point of tears. This turned an already stressful experience into an incredibly awkward one. We would have walked out if our order was not already placed.
For those with allergies or celiac- staff knowledge is limited, menu markings are nonexistent, and the atmosphere makes you feel like a burden for simply advocating for your health. If I were local, I would not return. A restaurant that truly welcomes guests with dietary restrictions should train staff properly, clearly mark menu options, and support, not shame, customers who ask necessary questions.
… moreR D
Absolutely amazing! The White Pizza is where it’s at – a total NY staple. Service is great and pricing very reasonable for the portion size you get. I recommend and would revisit.
… moreAiden Wheeler
I absolutely love this restaurant and so did my family . The service was great , the conversation with everyone who works there was great and the atmosphere was amazing . The food is amazing and the prices are great!!!! Amazing portions also . Been there two times and we are definitely gonna make it a weekly visit!!!
… moreNathan Laing
Ordered chicken fajitas and mussels marinara. Both full of flavor and great portion size! Great food and friendly service!
… moreBrittany Mele
I had the chicken tacos, rice and beans, and a cannoli. Everything was delicious! The service was even better. Our waitress Melissa was so welcoming and helped with suggestions. I will definitely be coming back when I’m in the area.
… more