winter kornfield
A Disappointing Decline at Anthony’s Pizzeria
I have never felt compelled to leave a negative review before, but my recent experience with Anthony’s Pizzeria on Route 9 in Lacey, attached to the 7-Eleven, has unfortunately changed that.
We ordered a large pizza with extra cheese — and paid accordingly — but what we received more closely resembled a thin, round tortilla lightly sprinkled with cheese. It was not only underwhelming, but also devoid of the saucy substance one would expect from a proper pizza.
Regrettably, this experience is not an isolated incident. Over time, we’ve observed a noticeable decline in quality and consistency. Staff turnover appears high, with new and seemingly untrained high school employees cycling through regularly. This lack of continuity and oversight has clearly impacted the product and the service.
This latest experience was the final straw. Anthony’s Pizzeria has, unfortunately, lost our patronage. I share this review not out of spite, but as a caution to others who may be considering dining here. I hope the management takes these concerns seriously and works toward restoring the quality and reliability that once made this establishment a local favorite.
… moreErik Fatovic
Anthony’s Pizzeria & Grill is hands-down the best spot in town for pizza! Their crust is perfectly crispy on the outside and soft on the inside, with just the right amount of chew. The sauce is rich and flavorful, and the toppings are always fresh and generously applied. Whether you’re a fan of classic pepperoni or something more adventurous, every slice is perfection.
The atmosphere is warm and welcoming, making it a great place to hang out with friends or enjoy dinner. The staff is friendly and attentive, ensuring a great experience from start to finish.
If you’re craving pizza that hits all the right notes, Anthony’s is the place to go. Highly recommend!
… moreCarol Fell
I’m usually quite happy with my purchases from Anthonys. Today was a different story. I am very disappointed in everything we purchased spent over $60 picked it up ourselves. They messed up the order and gave us regular cheesesteaks when we ordered California cheesesteaks and a person on the phone repeated the order back to me. So they clearly understood that I wanted two California cheesesteaks and I got regular, cheese and steak on stale hard bread. The mozzarella sticks were like sponges. We each tried one and threw the rest in the trash. They were horrible. The wings were dried out and tasted terrible. They were not eaten. The french fries were also dried out. Extremely unhappy, I will not be going back.
… moreNick Luongo
Soppy mess… i have good experiences with their single slices but this mess of a slop is not right… sorry you and i had to disappoint my family.
… moreLaura Lange
If all the pizzerias in Lacey , Anthony’s is always the best. Great food , prices a d atmosphere
… moreKaren
Our Favorite pizza place in the area. Our kids ask to go here. Reasonably priced and all staff very friendly.
… moreElizabeth Parsons
Went in for my first time, checked the menu before hand since one got delivered in our mailbox. I order a wrap, I got asked if I wanted fries, I said well it comes with fries or a side salad, the cashier said well the fries is an up charge, I replied with but on the menu it says different, then another person behind the counter said well you can get the wrap just by its self, in that moment I should’ve told them NEVERMIND AND WALKED OUT. I got the food and was charged extra for the fries, I’ll never be returning and giving them my business! On the menu for wraps/panini’s it states ‘served with fries or salad’ nothing about an up charge! So you charge 13.50 just for the wrap/panini and extra for fries or a salad. They need to RE-WORD it on their menu. The wrap was very good I got the boom boom chicken but I will not give someone my business that screws over customers and charges more then they should, should honor whats on the menu/price
… moreJose Alvarado
We Ordered two family size meal trays and a large pie, over the weekend. Food was very good!
… moreSGT Luie
Best food in Lacey Township. I moved to Lacey township recently and tried all the Italian restaurants. I am amazed at the great taste in the food, the quality and the customer service experience. I ordered from the a 2nd time and the delivery time was fast. The food arrived hot and fresh. If you are looking for a taste of Brooklyn or just great Italian food made from scratch then call this place. You will not be disappointed. It is the best.
… moreMelissa Perrine
Sad because I liked this place other times. Just ordered delivery tonight and the pizza was a mess. Entire pizza fell apart. On top of that it was cold and didn’t taste good.
… more