Lynsey Jensen
This pizza is classic New York–style perfection. Thin, foldable crust, and that magical balance of sauce and cheese that makes you consider ordering just one more slice (or three).
Friendly, fast, and full of good vibes, they make you feel like a regular even if it’s your first visit. Service so good it deserves its own tip jar.
… moreSuzette Maes
I visited Anthony’s Pizza over the holidays and had a very pleasant experience. I was assisted by Jerry, and at the time was in a hurry and eager to get home. In my haste, I didn’t leave a review. Earlier this week I stopped in to pick up a pie, and to my pleasant surprise, Jerry was working! With his kind face and friendly smile, he happily assisted! Visiting Anthony’s Pizza in Central Park, and seeing Jerry’s friendly face, is always a treat! Kudos to a fun, neighborhood place with an awesome employee!
… moreJeremiah Fahlenkamp
One of my go to spots for a quick bite and a beer. Been at least a month since I’ve stopped in. Slices still great and same awesome staff with the friendly smiles and great service. Would usually rate at least 4. But they’ve made a big change which was the main reason I stopped in . NO CALZONE!! Nothing better than sitting here at the bar and enjoying a custom calzone that is so big I have to take some home. Some might complain about the 2 drink maximum which is new as well but it frees up bar space for someone wanting to enjoy a beer and a CALZONE. But staff, speed and quality can’t be beat in this area. Would recommend to anyone unless they want a calzone.
… moreAlejandra Moran
Anthony’s Pizza is the best in Colorado. The pizza comes out hot and fresh, the pasta tastes homemade, and the portions are huge. Everything I’ve tried has been really good. Gustavo is super friendly and always makes the place feel welcoming. Highly recommend!
… moreJustice Hollingsworth
Came back to my local pizza place after a long time only to find there was a two drink limit. Of which I am sure has led to the downfall of the place’s overall fun atmosphere that I once remembered. Otherwise, the staff is friendly and attentive.
… moreNancy Fg
To start off this is a great area to visit. The pizza & salads here are very good. A large slice of pizza and salad along with a drink are only $10. Extra toppings are $.90 On a nice day, you can sit outside on the patio & enjoy the pretty views.
… moreChad Rivard
Small portions. This picture of garlic bread? Almost $3. Didn’t give me extra sauce despite looking me in the face and saying he did.
… morexitz prodigy
They changed the recipe on the gluten free and now it’s one of the worst pizzas I’ve ever had and it cost more the old pizza was like 14 dollars and amazing now it’s 20 dollars and terrible i would’ve recommended in the past now i don’t and i genuinely recommend getting a simple truth pizza from king soopers and just cooking it at home it’s half the price and way better the crust is just awful now. Will not be coming back unless they go back to the old gf recipe. The response i got to this says they went to more traditional pizza but what i used to get was more traditional and the new one was a cracker type it tasted like a pizza on top of a bad saltine. Didn’t meant to get rid of their response… Blame Google on that.
… moreCody Erickson
Love the $3 slice deal on Tuesdays! Not to mention Jerry has been awesome. He speaks great English but helps me practice my Spanish and maintains positive vibes in general.
… moreJorge Nava
I was high recommended from Aron the cashier to get a 10 dóllar pastas on monday s. the slices on tuesday are the best
… more