Social Profile: 
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 301 E Altamonte Dr, Altamonte Springs, FL 32701
Phone: (407) 260-2354
Website: https://anthonypizzaaltamonte.com/
Menu Photos
Related Web Results
Anthony’s Pizza: Home | Anthony’s Pizza | FL, 32714
Here at Anthony’s we take pride in the quality of our food. We are passionate & dedicated about preparing Italian food with the freshest & finest …
Anthony’s Pizza | Altamonte Springs FL – Facebook
Anthony’s Pizza, Altamonte Springs. 21 likes. Anthony’s Pizza and Italian Kitchen 301 E Altamonte Dr St 1010 407-260-1988.
Menu | Anthony’s Pizza | FL, 32714
Our Menu … Appetizers … Sides … Soups & Salads … Calzones & Strombolis … Pizzas … Pizza By The Slice … Pasta … Baked Pasta Dinners … Italian Entrées … Subs.
Reviews
Richard Rost
Don’t listen to the bad reviews. This place is amazing. I’m an Italian from New York and I’m telling you this is some of the best pizza I’ve had outside of NY. The crust is nice and crispy. Friendly staff. Comfortable atmosphere. My wife is actually devouring her baked ziti (and she normally eats like a bird). Five stars all around. Oh, and they play authentic Italian music! Another plus.
… moreMichael L
Great service and pretty nice setting. Need photos of pizzas. We ordered based on descriptions and were slightly disappointed when we got back to our hotel room to eat. Overall, it was good. Foe the price, i think we could have bee happier if their site (or menu) showed us what to expect.
… moreAnjalee Thompson
This pizzeria is the real deal! We were visiting the area and happened to stop by because we were hungry. We are so glad we did because Anthony’s has the best pizza, it’s so authentic and they use quality ingredients! We dined in and the new owner introduced himself to us, he is top shelf. He has been in the food industry a very long time and it shows! He made our customer experience so delightful! Such a nice man! We ended up getting a pie to take back to our hotel for later, it’s that good!!!! We highly recommend this place. Amazing food and amazing prices! Can’t be beat!
… moreColette Langley
This is a great little spot for pizza and Italian dishes! We went on a Thursday evening and it was very busy. The waitresses were working really hard, but it was definitely a bit chaotic while we were there.
We had ordered garlic knots but never got them (they weren’t on the check either, so all good!). My boyfriend and I shared the small Bianca pizza and I got a Chef Salad as well. The salad tasted very fresh, but I wasn’t a fan that the meat and cheese came rolled up on the salad. The Bianca was delicious! The pizzas are made fresh and it was a great combination. The crust was very soft on the botttom, but it did not stop me from devouring it!
A great place for delicious pizza and a casual environment!
… moreWe had ordered garlic knots but never got them (they weren’t on the check either, so all good!). My boyfriend and I shared the small Bianca pizza and I got a Chef Salad as well. The salad tasted very fresh, but I wasn’t a fan that the meat and cheese came rolled up on the salad. The Bianca was delicious! The pizzas are made fresh and it was a great combination. The crust was very soft on the botttom, but it did not stop me from devouring it!
A great place for delicious pizza and a casual environment!
Jerri Patterson
Super cute restaurant. The New York pizza is fabulous. The dessert is even better. A must try. Super friendly staff. Definitely will come back
… moreLeonora Herring
I just ordered a 16″ Brooklyn Pizza from Anthony’s through Uber Eats, hoping that if I gave them one last chance they wouldn’t disappoint. I meant to order from New York Best Pizza but they were not an option on the Uber Eats site. The pizza was delivered and it wasn’t fully cooked, a puddle of grease accumulated at the center, the taste was completely off. It smelled and tastes weird. After 2 bites 30 minutes later I have a full blown headache and I’m nauseous. I am not feeling well. I thought maybe it was fresh off the oven and it needed to cool a little but the pizza stayed looking the same, like someone ate it and threw it back up. I am extremely disappointed with the quality of food at Anthony’s. They were once upon a time really good. I noticed some of their good reviews with good photos and it makes me wonder if we are not entitled to great food or service because we’re not dine-in customers? Are we not important enough, is our dollar of less value? This pizza cost $28 (just the pizza). This is NOT worth $28; it’s not worthy of human consumption. Hopefully, this won’t result in an ER visit after simply taste testing this pizza. It looks, tastes, and smells like food poisoning. I will never order from here again. Ever.
… moreSarah Summey
Hands down the very best pizza in Central Florida. We come out of our way to get a slice. Ironically, we just got back from NYC where we enjoyed some of the finest authentic NYC pizza and it was as if we never left because this pizza is incredible. The service is friendly and timely and the prices are very reasonable.
… moreMelissa Padilla
It’s the first time that I have ordered in this restaurant. We ordered carry out at night time on a Thursday. The place is clean and well maintained. The service is good and fast, also, have a parking very spacious in a mall closed to other restaurants and stores.
The garlic knots are tasty and come with a good amount of garlic on top and a side of marinara sauce to dip in.
The quality of the food is not the best, in my opinion. The pizza was salty, and I think with salt and pepper over it, which is weird for a pizza, at least I never saw salt and pepper over a pizza. The price is not that bad. It is an average price for what we get, which was 2 large pepperoni pizzas with a side of garlic knots with marinara sauce.
(*I left 2 pictures where I showed what I think is the salt and pepper on my pizza*)
I don’t recommend this place due to my experience with the flavor or the pizza, but if you want to, you can try it by yourself, and see if you have a different opinion or if you pizza taste better than mine. Maybe there was a mistake on the preparation of mine, or I don’t know, but I encourage you to try it and then get your own opinions about it.
… moreThe garlic knots are tasty and come with a good amount of garlic on top and a side of marinara sauce to dip in.
The quality of the food is not the best, in my opinion. The pizza was salty, and I think with salt and pepper over it, which is weird for a pizza, at least I never saw salt and pepper over a pizza. The price is not that bad. It is an average price for what we get, which was 2 large pepperoni pizzas with a side of garlic knots with marinara sauce.
(*I left 2 pictures where I showed what I think is the salt and pepper on my pizza*)
I don’t recommend this place due to my experience with the flavor or the pizza, but if you want to, you can try it by yourself, and see if you have a different opinion or if you pizza taste better than mine. Maybe there was a mistake on the preparation of mine, or I don’t know, but I encourage you to try it and then get your own opinions about it.
dougie j
The pizza that I ordered was advertised as New York style that’s not New York style. I ordered a 16-inch 8 slice pie, and the slices were small like they were skipping on the dough. The dough wasn’t evenly cooked throughout the pie. The cheese wasn’t smooth, and it was salty. Sams Club makes better pizza than that. The soda out of the fountain machine was very sweet, as if it wasn’t mixed right.
… moreDylan
As someone who is from New Jersey, the pizza taste is an average imitation. The pie looked too “perfect,” which made it seem fake. The taste was okay for imitation.
The garlic knots have no knots to them. They are biscuits with garlic and butter on them. Still tasty though. The sauce for them was nothing too special.
The server was friendly, but seemed as if she was rushing us. I wasn’t a fan of that. I just wanted to sit down and relax with my food, and maybe have some time to look at the menu.
All in all, the place was good, but not the best place I’ve been. I don’t think I’d go back, but I won’t openly avoid it either.
… moreThe garlic knots have no knots to them. They are biscuits with garlic and butter on them. Still tasty though. The sauce for them was nothing too special.
The server was friendly, but seemed as if she was rushing us. I wasn’t a fan of that. I just wanted to sit down and relax with my food, and maybe have some time to look at the menu.
All in all, the place was good, but not the best place I’ve been. I don’t think I’d go back, but I won’t openly avoid it either.