Local counter-serve chain that’s a take-out/delivery staple for NY-style pies & other Italian eats.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 20 Welcher Ave, Peekskill, NY 10566
Phone: (914) 737-0322
Website: https://www.anthonyspizzaofpeekskill.com/?utm_source=gbp
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Anthony’s Pizza – Peekskill, NY – 20 Welcher Ave – Hours, Menu, Order
Order Hours About. 10:30 AM-9:00 PM; Shop address is 20 Welcher Ave, Peekskill, NY 1056620 Welcher Ave, Peekskill, NY 10566; (914) 737-0322.
Anthony’s Pizza – Peekskill, NY Restaurant | Menu + Delivery
Pizza · Regular Cheese Pizza · $9.22+ · 18″ Sicilian Pizza · $17.07 · Anthony’s Special Pizza · $12.91+ · White Pizza · $12.91+. Salad Pizza. Cheeseless pizza, …
Anthony’s Famous Pizza, 22 Welcher Ave, Peekskill, NY 10566, US
Anthony’s Famous Pizza in Peekskill NY is a beloved local eatery known for its delicious hand-crafted pizzas made with fresh ingredients.
Last Updates
Reviews
Chris Tian
Today I decided to get pizza for dinner and stopped at this restaurant. As soon as I entered, the man at the counter was very rude. He didn’t greet me or acknowledge me—he just stared without being friendly.
I asked for a pepperoni roll and a slice of pizza, and when I pointed to ask which slice it was, he simply looked at me and said nothing. His attitude was dismissive and unprofessional.
This is the third time I’ve experienced this kind of behavior from him, and it will be my last time coming here. Customers should feel welcomed and respected. It’s important to remember that serving customers is not doing them a favor—it’s part of running a business.
I hope the management addresses this issue and improves customer service.
… moreI asked for a pepperoni roll and a slice of pizza, and when I pointed to ask which slice it was, he simply looked at me and said nothing. His attitude was dismissive and unprofessional.
This is the third time I’ve experienced this kind of behavior from him, and it will be my last time coming here. Customers should feel welcomed and respected. It’s important to remember that serving customers is not doing them a favor—it’s part of running a business.
I hope the management addresses this issue and improves customer service.
olivia simeone
Accidentally ordered instead of our hometown pizza. Called to get a refund because we live out of the area. My husband got cursed out and wouldn’t accept the refund. Even if I find myself in the area I am going to avoid this pizza place.
… moreJohn Lan
12/03/25 approx 7:00pm- got charged $7.80 for two plain slices to go. Current Grubhub listing is $2.99 for a plain slice. Now I’m seeing $3.23 (!!) on other platforms. That’s still not $7.80.
Oh, and it was lukewarm.
Don’t waste your money here.
… moreOh, and it was lukewarm.
Don’t waste your money here.
Dan G
Had a 3.75 dollar slice yesterday. The slice was just ok. Nothing to write home about.Was hoping it was better. The best pizza Comes from old school owners who have the best recipes.
… moreGary Wilson
Decent sized size slice for $3.
Heavy coverage of cheese , almost too much for the crust to hold.
Medium thin soft crust with good taste.
A little on the undercooked side.
A very filling slice.
Unfortunately, it’s kind of bland. No garlic flavor or oregano flavor or basil flavor or really any notable flavor.
Because of this, I’m going to give it a low ball rating of 77.
All the right parts are there, but they just don’t seem to connect.
… moreHeavy coverage of cheese , almost too much for the crust to hold.
Medium thin soft crust with good taste.
A little on the undercooked side.
A very filling slice.
Unfortunately, it’s kind of bland. No garlic flavor or oregano flavor or basil flavor or really any notable flavor.
Because of this, I’m going to give it a low ball rating of 77.
All the right parts are there, but they just don’t seem to connect.
Isling
This pizza not only looks nasty. I ordered Half mushroom and half pepperoni on an 8 slice pie. There are barely any mushrooms on the Pizza and only 3 slices have mushrooms. The guy tells me” I don’t know what to tell you. NEVER AGAIN WILL I ORDER FROM THEM.
… moreJessica Vecchio
Used to come here in the past and today was very disappointed. Ordered a chicken cutlet sandwich with like nothing on it. No mayo (when we ordered extra) like one or 2 onions (when ordered extra) etc. Will be going elsewhere from now on.
… moreSanday Simon
I can microwave my own food. The cheese tastes nice. I would be cautious. Last I remember they do the microwave thing at Applebee’s.
… moreDylan Argenziano
Awesome pie! Cooked perfectly and tasted amazing! Will definitely be ordering from here again!
… moreMhyrynde Noa
Ordered a large Sicilian with pepperoni. Received cheese only. No apology. No ownership of the error.
… more