Thomas Rice
No better or worse than most pizza joints. I keep hearing from northerners how much better NY pizza is than anywhere else. I’m not seeing it. Better than big chain pizza but about as good as any other small shop. If you’re a southerner, skip the sweet tea. It may have brushed the sugar container on the way to the table. The bruschetta was pretty good. The pizza was the Brooklyn and it was good. Just not all that and a bag of chips. Canolli was good though I prefer it with pistachios. Tiramisu was great, much larger than my wife expected. Service was pretty decent but server was waiting tables and running counter. Ignore the hype of Yankees about their pizza and it’s pretty good. Definitely, try them out. No negatives did I see.
… moresimonelli22
A++ I completely recommend coming here every time for all your Italian/pizza needs. The pizza is top-notch. New York style. Very flavorful, great tasting sauce and a good crust. I look forward to coming here with my family anytime I get a chance. If I lived here, this would be my normal spot. They are also very accommodating. Specially, when you have older parents that come off very elderly and aggressive. Then again it is Palm Coast. The large half salad was also fantastic. It sure hits the spot.. The calamari was also in A+. Every time I’ve been here the last two years I’ve never not enjoyed what I’ve eaten.
… moreJudith “Jude24” Barker-Waldt
There pizza is fresh an delious.an Calazon is so large an delious. There workers meet you with a smile. Great place for lunch or dinner
… moreLana Flanery
First time at Anthony’s Pizza and I really liked the place. Cute, inviting atmosphere, super friendly staff, and it’s fun watching them make the pizza.
The crust was excellent, but the eggplant on my pizza was very dry and cracker-like, which was disappointing.
I’d still give them another try and order a different pizza next time.
… morecrystiana butler
Brought both of my young kids in and they were super friendly to my kids. It’s quiet inside (at least the times I’ve gone) and the food is good. I had a salad the last time I came and it was really good! It’s a little overwhelming going out to eat with young kids by yourself but they made me feel very welcomed.
… moreMK
Huge portions but fabulous food! So sad I don’t have one near me in Minnesota!!
… moreDan Perez
We visited this location as it was my dad Mario favorite pizza place in Palm Coast. We are from Jersey so we have very high standards for pizza. We ordered a large cheese pie and a grandma pie with two penne vodka dinner dishes. The pizza was very good and had a good cheese. The penne vodka was good too with a good sauce. Like my father, I would recommend this pizza when in the Palm Coast area.
… moreBeth Anne Bauman
WOW! We ordered the antipasti & a Stromboli. The presentation was beautiful. Each item was packed with deliciousness. We have tried a few pizza restaurants in Palm Coast and this one is over the top. You definitely get your money’s worth. You have just gained new customers.
… moreAmber Oliveira
We are camping at Gamble Roger’s, wanted pizza tried this place & it’s literally the Best pizza ever! The Brooklyn is awesome they used fresh veggies and the garlic knots were loaded with fresh chopped garlic!!! Service was friendly. Definitely recommend this place to try!
… moreLuke K
Ordered 1 hour ahead. Service at pickup was great, workers were friendly.
Got 6 pizzas and garlic knots. Manhattan and Brooklyn pizzas were the best! Staten Island, Margherita, and pepperoni pizzas were great.
Quarrto Formaggio was okay. We were expecting it to be like a Quattro Formaggi but was not due to the cheese being different. The garlic knots were good. Baked but still a little doughy. A lot of garlic on them and the sauce makes them 100% better. Everyone loved the sauce! Next time I will be getting an extra side of the sauce!
… more