Anthony’s Coal Fired Pizza & Wings

  4.5 – 588 reviews   • Pizza restaurant

Social Profile:

Anthony’s Coal Fired Pizza & Wings in Woodbury, proud to be ranked the #1 Best Pizza Chain, combines coal-fired tradition with fresh, seasonal offerings. Enjoy Mike’s Hot Honey® & Burrata pizza, Broccoli Rabe & Sausage pie, or burrata & prosciutto spaghetti, all starting with hand-picked Italian tomatoes and freshly grated pecorino Romano cheese. Our fresh never-frozen jumbo chicken wings and Italian Sausage & Peppers sandwiches are local favorites. Located near Trail View State Park and Woodbury Village, we’re perfect for dine-in, pizza delivery, or takeout.

Casual chain serving charred-crust pies, plus wings, subs & Italian plates in a modern setting.

✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings 11797

Menu Photos

Order and Reservations

Reservations: acfp.com

Order: Order online

acfp.com

Related Web Results

Coal-Fired Pizza, Pasta & Sandwiches in Woodbury | Anthony’s

North Shore Coal‑Fired Pizza & Italian Eats in Woodbury … Right on Jericho Turnpike, Anthony’s fires every pizza in a 900‑degree coal oven, sealing fresh dough, …

Anthony’s Coal Fired Pizza & Wings | Where Fire Meets Flavor

Experience the flavor of Anthony’s Coal Fired Pizza & Wings. Enjoy handcrafted & authentic pizza, wings, & Italian cuisine. Order takeout, delivery or …

Anthony’s Locations | Find a Pizza Restaurant Near You

Woodbury, NY 11797. (516) 367-2625 · Get Directions · Order · Wantagh. miles. Hours … Anthony’s Coal Fired Pizza & Wings · Order · Locations · Menu · Catering.

Last Updates

Reviews

hemmy cho
Easy to park – located in a little strip mall. Not a huge place but decently sized. Staff was friendly and the service was an adequate pace.
Regular large pepperoni pie 8/10
Carnivori 16″ 9/10
Garlic knots 6/10
Italian Sausage & Peppers Sandwich 9/10
Spicy pineapple margarita 4/10
Will definitely come back but will probably skip the drinks and the garlic knots.
… more
Jun Yuan-Murray
I would had rated 0 if I can.

No matter how good the pizza tastes, I will never come back to order any more.

The TL; DR: order was placed at 517pm on Uber, delivered 850pm.

Granted, it was a super bowl night and some extra wait was expected. But 3.5 hours wait and 3 uber drivers inquiring? Really? What is your basic courtesy to at least notify one of them or call me so that i can cancel my order? I do have a young child at home waiting for food.

I can understand business overflowing on a special date. But the level of ignorance, poor custom service and arrogance is stunning, no matter how good your pizza is, it’s not worth my disappointed child’s crying.

Also many thanks to the Uber delivery personnel who pressured to prepare my order, or I’m sure it would had been delivered midnight or never come.

It was just a call or a button to cancel, but you didn’t care.

Thanks for reading!
… more
Barb Kessel
My group of ladies have been coming bi-monthly since 2021 when some of us retired. The food has always been consistent and the servers great, last night was no exception to the service. However I thought the regular pizza with mushrooms was different. Way more cheese than usual which I was not that thrilled with. Or maybe it was a different cheese. I know most people would be thrilled to be getting more but I always liked that it was lighter on the mozzarella. Maybe a new pizza cook? I try to go along with the flow and eat what everyone else is having, but the next time we come I’ll be getting a different meal.
… more
Ali Jumabhoy
Nice place with pretty good food. Service staff are very friendly and attentive. The pizza crust was made really well.
… more
King Zone
Very friendly staff very helpful and will make you custom pizzas to fit your taste buds. Bit on the pricey side but you do definitely get what you pay for. They have a full bar and place to sit for lunch and dates. So far everything I had was very well seasoned be down to try everything worth it!!
… more
Craig Fish
A frequent flyer at this best of Anthony’s Pizza. The food is always good but me and my crew are hoping for a return to more abundant pre pandemic selections! Drink specials are appreciated as are the rewards program. TV’s and piped in tunes are good. Love the help! Great parking with bustling takeout!
… more
Fern Karhu
Great pizza place, italian food and bar fun place to be with.Plenty of seating and conveniently located
… more
Jesse Jones Marshall
The Pizza crust was Smokey flavored, loaded with toppings and and had gooey stretchy cheese. The wings were tangy and juicy and the staff was overly accommodating and the service was quite quick for a wood fired pizza
… more
Sylvia Mendoza
Anthony’s used to be my favorite place for Italian food. I ordered butter noodles for my children and they were overcooked and cold. My eggplant Marino had no flavor. Very disappointed.
… more
Robert Ferrari
We’ve been to this location many times. Unfortunately the last time we were there the waiter provided poor customer service. Actually was socializing with another table and forgot about us (we had to get up and get another server). We didn’t go back for a while but decided to again today. We got the same waiter and nothing much changed. Took our order but never came back to check or see if we needed refills (which we did). When I paid the bill, and tipped (as he stood there) he just dropped the receipt on the table and walked away, no thank you or anything. That’s enough…never again.
… more
… View more

Leave a Comment