Lara H
We were in heaven after ordering the tomahawk with the lobster mac & cheese, stuffed artichoke & buratta prosciutto special. Everything was perfectly cooked and received at the right time. The wine pairing suggestions were excellent and on point with the meal.
… moreCarlos Vega
Nice little Steak house with too of the line choices. Good choices in meats, seafood, and pastas. Ambiance was good as they had already decorated for Valentines day. Music was at a good volume to allow you to hear your party. Drinks were great. Would def return.
… moreDean B
First time at Angelo’s for Mother’s Day and agree it is a hidden gem tucked away in a residential neighborhood in Kenilworth NJ. Food and service were excellent with a neighborhood restaurant vibe! Price was very reasonable which made it even better! Steaks were cooked just right paired with sides of creamed spinach and mashed potato. Also tried their classic chicken parmigiana and it was delish (not too salty like everywhere else). The owner Angelo added his personal touch by coming out to say hello to diners! Will definitely return to try other items on the menu!
… moreMichele De Mola
We waited an hour and a half for our food, even though we were one of only three tables in the restaurant, so I’m not sure what caused the delay. I also mentioned to the owner that it was my sister’s birthday, and she said, “I can throw a candle on the dessert, but that’s the best I can do,” which didn’t feel very warm or celebratory. The staff overall didn’t seem sweet or welcoming, and the vibes were honestly pretty off. I will say the food was good, but definitely not worth that kind of wait — I’d rather go to Olive Garden. Lol
… moreS B
We visited for a family member’s birthday. The staff were friendly and answered all of our questions. We ordered 3 steaks, creamed spinach, mac n cheese, and a salad. I did call to reserve in advance and asked if they do anything to celebrate birthdays. I was told they do but they didn’t do anything for us so that was very disappointing. We still had a good time and the food was good.
… moreEmily Iris
I had my 5 year anniversary with my boyfriend here and the service was really attentive. We had like 5 waiters come up to us to see if we needed anything. The bread they gave us in the beginning was hard. But the meatball as we had were so delicious and the ribeye steak was amazing. But the waiter told us what side we wanted, we were thinking it came with the meal but it didn’t. They charged us for the one side which was like 16 dollars u can’t remember. Please give a disclaimer to everyone if the entree doesn’t come with a side. But overall experience was great and food was tasty. I would come back
… moreDes KF
My boyfriend and I made reservations for this location for a Valentine’s Day dinner. When we arrived I parked on the street nearby. We walked in and was greeted by our server Jorge and he said we can sit where we please. Jorge was nice and attentive. We started with drinks and I ordered the red sangria and that was tasty. For our entrées I ordered the shrimp scampi and my boyfriend ordered the NY strip.
While we waited we observed the restaurant and it was so nice and I really liked the decor. The owner, Angelo, came over and checked on us and he was nice. When the food came out everything looked great. I dug in and my shrimp scampi was very good. My boyfriend really enjoyed his steak. We had a nice time and would return.
… moreSuzi Giam
Went with super high expectations and was very disappointed. Upon walking in there was a faint smell of must like there had been water damage turned me off immediately, then ordered the special appetizer. Some kind of pumpkin thing with sausage in it it was OK but strange that the owner’s wife kept lurking around the table, asking us if it was good…like was it supposed to be bad???Then I ordered the short rib special and my husband ordered the fish special. The short ribs came out so tough. I couldn’t even get one bite out of them and the fish was still raw on the inside. It was never cooked right so both dishes went back …they offered something else but At that point didn’t even wanna try one of their desserts on the house. Nope paid the bill left and will never go back very disappointed
… moreJuana M Familia
My husband and I came to the restaurant to have a date night , and try a new restaurant.
We had a reservation and the hostess couldn’t find us , mind you I had the confirmation but anyways she sat us down but the waitress awful , took her time did not ask any single question or suggest anything at all , steak was cold and forgot part of the order .
Do not go here , she looked bothered and we spent 300 dollars .
… moreJames M. Smith
Tomahawk steak was horrible. We had to send it back 2 times. The server was very misleading. He said we had 2 sides included with our order and wind up charging us for them. Drinks were ok, and the French onion soup. I definitely wouldn’t recommend it.
… more