Austin Avocado
I called in to order a delivery, large cheese, pizza; the lady I spoke to was very nice and sounded smart enough to figure out what I needed because I wasn’t sure if I wanted to pay with cash or card due to the fact that I only had $20 cash on me and I still wanted to be able to pay the driver. So she said then you want to use card and I gave them a tip. She said they would be there soon and they came very quickly within probably 15 minutes. I heard them driving down the road and pulled out my spotlight and they were able to pull at the end of my driveway. The young man who had my pizza was not driving, but he had a friend driver for him. he seemed very nice and intelligent and handed me the pizza. I said you have a nice Saturday night and a nice Sunday and have a nice week too. He called me, sir. I thought that was funny! But it was a very nice experience. I didn’t put any stars for the atmosphere because I obviously did not even step inside their establishment.
… moreSarah Morgan
When this was schianos it was my favorite local pizza joint. Once it switched over to Angelo’s a lot of things changed and it definitely made this my last resort for pizza in the area. The sub buns were too soft like cheap store bought rolls rather than a good Italian sub roll. They cut their onions paper thin for every single thing they use them for and it is annoying. You can’t even chew the onions and enjoy your food because your choking on these long thin onions that can’t be chewed into smaller pieces due to their thickness. They switched up the meats they use on their Italian subs and you can tell they use the cheapest meats available. There’s more but I believe this is enough of a review. The pizza is ok.
… moreMandi Maiden
Ordered pizza tonight, and it was the best it’s been in a long time! Definitely have someone on that table that knows what their doing! Not a bunch of excess burnt crust, it’d actually cut all the way through.. these are two beautiful pizzas right here! Couldn’t stop my family from digging in before I could take pictures! Very happy bellies tonight!
… moreT S
Today they lost our business. We would eat there every time we met in Millersburg. Today they definitely messed up. We were there during lunch and they have a hamburger/fry/drink lunch special. They charged for the burger and the fries separately. Then argued over it. Another order was pasta special, which is pasta, salad, drink, rolls. The waitress asked if I wanted to add a salad for extra. I said it’s supposed to come with a salad. Then I asked if they could mix marinara and add a little Alfredo. They charged me to do that. It’s not like they gave me extra sauce or anything. This is not how you do business. We will definitely never be back!
… moreGregory E
I have to say since Angelo’s took over the business, the place has underwent a real makeover. I like the new improved interior looks; the atmosphere has reached a new level too. There is waitress service once again and it’s great. We have only been in a few times, but the food we’ve tried has been excellent. My wife and I love the shrimp and fries in a basket; served piping hot and just the right amount for lunch. If you haven’t visited in awhile, give it a try. I’m sure you’ll agree with me!
… moreDawn Miller
Fantastic pizza place here in Millersburg. Everything is so very good. And the staff is always friendly. Only downfall is how they pack the to go at times. Got pierogis and the butter leaked out and the bag tore dumping French Fries everywhere. Maybe put the pierogis and items like them in their own bag? Just a thought
… moreG Wenhold
I’m a contractor that travels around the Harrisburg area alot. Usually, you’ll end up paying around $15-20 elsewhere for a full sub and a slice of pizza. Here, I paid $13 for an exceptional portion size on both foods. I swear I’ve paid $10 elsewhere for a sub half the size of what I got here. Good prices, good fresh bread. Top tier pizza place for lunch.
… moreChristina Zeiders
One of my favorite places to go for a quick bite. Pizza’s great and the bread is delicious. The restaurant vibes are relaxed too, when we decide to do something other than takeout.
… moreStephanie hanvey
NEVER AGAIN! I have been eating here for along time. My family loved Angelos and as a treat I would get it for them. This time we order pizza I gave it to my autistic son and 5 year old grandbaby. My grandbaby complained it tasted funny, but I thought a kid being a kid was trying to skip out on eating. My autistic son shoveled it down because he doesn’t have the same sense as we do due to his disability. Then I went to taste a slice and found that it tasted like chemicals and smelled like chemicals. My opinion it tasted and smelled like oven cleaner. I instantly called Angelos they denied it stating im the only one who complained. They never offered an solution to make it right and denied everything. So I called poison control they said without proper knowledge of what chemical was on the pizza it would be difficult to tell us what steps to take. So he instructed us to have a glass of milk and if I notice and symptoms to go straight to the ER. I saved the pizza in a zip lock bag if something happens and they need to know what was in it. I am very upset about how angelos handled the situation they could of at least told me what chemicals was used so I know where we stand. Or at the least give us a refund after being served poison pizza. Never again will I buy from Angelos Poison Pizza
… moreKiki
As a tip: you can get any sub turned into a wrap or vice versa. Retro arcade system for the kids to be entertained with as you wait too. The lunch special is a good option for affordability too as usual, but $20+ for pasta at a run of the mill Italian place!! Can get slices in NYC for less than here. Cheap way to run business. Don’t like the way I’ve heard about how management handles pay or falsely disputes some claims and jokes about POC either. It may be a small rural town, but word gets around very fast. Decent people don’t do that or act / think that way
If you’re fine with that in 2026 go ahead. but if you’re looking for better somewhere else (both food and attitude wise) or just something different, the café up the street has a nicer atmosphere and more accepting attitude. I choose to support there now and spend my money elsewhere.
Though it does have more limited evening hours and no pizza or italian food, they have a large menu with breakfast and sandwiches. and extensive coffee options that aren’t available elsewhere locally.
Disparaging remarks aren’t funny jokes, especially for those who are supposedly religious or act like it! Absolutely not aligned with the moral values or teachings of Christ, and contributes to reinforcing unhealthy bad narratives. We all must do our part to make things better in this world. Both socially and culturally. Including being mindful of others.
Hope pray for a change of heart and attitude towards others, and for this establishment and its employees to receive the abundances that come with acceptance. God bless you for better and more! ✝️
… more