Rebecca Gellar
I was in NY for 48 hours and chose one place to get pizza. It was literally the best slice of pizza I’ve ever had! I’m 53 and I’ve been to NY many times! I got the pepperoni with ricotta cheese. I was also huge! I ate half and took the other half home with me to Florida and ate it the next day! Delish!
… moreIvan Avalos
Angela’s pizzeria by far best pizzeria in islip! The staff is very nice and friendly. The owner Vinny is also very nice. Check them out and their specialty slices and try my favorite slice the angry Italian: Mozzarella sticks,pepperoni,vodka sauce, hot honey on a garlic knot crust! Insanely good. Great Prices!
… moreZachary Riyaz
Stopped in for a quick bite and grabbed two slices of pizza —classic cheese slice with perfectly browned mozzarella, and the other a hearty meat-topped slice. The crust on both was thin and crisp along the edges, just the right amount of chew without being doughy. The cheese slice had a buttery flavor with slight caramelization that gave it a nice depth, while the meat slice delivered that satisfying savory hit you expect from a solid pizzeria!
… moreAshley Robles
Angelas Pizza is a Great Pizzeria, they have great costumer service always greeting with a smile and they have quick service with the food coming fresh and savory. Not to mention if you order the Zeppoles you will not regret it they are nice and hot when they arrive with the sweetness of the powder sugar they add to a universal sweet tooth. This pizzeria is really the best pizzeria in town! This is what they look like!( sorry I ate them all)
… moreEsther Mueller
I love Angela’s pizza it’s incredible the food is always perfect, and mario who works in the back makes the best pizza ive ever had in my life, el es mi causa for real. All the staff is friendly, efficient, and you can’t leave without being fed so well!!
… moreJewel S.
Delicious Crazy Italian Pizza slices. Good service and 4 tables to sit at. What more could you ask for when driving through the area??? Even better… so many varieties of slices to choose from and heated in the oven to perfection… share some with your friends.
… moreTam
I wish I found this pizzeria sooner! Their lunch box is a great deal. The pizza slices are very generous. Fresh pizza was coming out constantly as we waited for the pasta to be made. It was hard to pick a slice, everything looked and smelled so good. Staff was friendly and working efficiently to fill the displays and help the ongoing flow of customers. This is going to be my new go to for all my pizza and pasta needs.
… moreCarolyn Kandie Renee
Walked in and was greeted immediately. Then Vinny offered the lunch box special and I ordered that with fried chicken penne vodka pasta, small salad and 3 garlic knots. Also got a slice of margherita pizza which was delicious! Taking some Zeppolis to go and def couldn’t eat it all so excited to warm up the rest for dinner!
… moreJoel G
Ordered three items for delivery; received two. Seems simple enough to put all the items in the bag. I guess not. Pretty over it. The food that did come was mediocre at best. When I called to let them know I was missing some of my order I had to repeat my address and phone number probably five times. The kid was just not listening. They sent a driver who showed up 30ish minutes later to some address I’m still unsure of. After trying to help him find my front door for over 20 minutes I decided to give up. More stress than worth it. Could have made three trips to the supermarket in the time I wasted waiting. Not even hungry anymore.
… moreLauren Michaeli
Visiting from NYC for the day and stumbled across this pizza shop – you must come here!! The vodka ravioli slice was epic!!! I also tried the Mac and cheese slice and garlic knot pizza, also delish!! Friendly staff who casually socialized. What a gem!!! I will most certainly be back!
… more