Creative cocktails paired with modern Mexican small plates in a chic, wood-and-brick space.
Milton Paez
Love this spot for weekend brunch!
The food is consistently delicious and the staff is incredible friendly and attentive. It’s definitely a great place to enjoy a meal.
On the weekends they offer a brunch special with all-you-can drink for $29 over 90 minutes, plus the cost of food.
Highly recommended trying the crispy cauliflower tacos, French toast and tacos al pastor. They are all must haves!
… moreAndrew
First of all, I NEED to say that the service here is PERFECT. Me and my buddies were visiting New York City, and we ended up taking the wrong subway into Brooklyn, so we ended up being late to our reservation…by almost two hours. Even though we rescheduled our reservation almost 10 times (we’d push buck the reservation in 5-10 minute increments), the customer service was flawless, without a single hint of annoyance in the customer service spokesperson’s voice. Furthermore, when we explained to the waiters that we were in a rush (because we were so late), they made sure our order was delivered quickly. So yeah, the service was perfect.
Second of all, the food is top notch. I got a 3 pc beef birria taco, and needless to say that it was the BEST taco I’ve ever had. The meat was extremely tender and well seasoned, and perfectly paired with the consomme. It was a little pricey, but worth every single penny.
Third of all, the ambience of the place is SPECTACULAR. Absolutely perfect for a date. Anyways, I’d definitely recommend this spot!
… moreJoanie A
The vibe here is great and the shrimp tacos were very good. Margs are hit or miss on quality and my husband didn’t love the enchiladas. It was packed on a Friday night so definitely make a reservation if you want a table.
… moreAlfredo Louk
Great Mexican fusion restaurant. The ribeye steak fajitas was very well cooked and seasoned. Food was delivered pretty fast. Their pork belly will recommend. Didn’t have any reservations thru open table however I saw the restaurant empty and allow us to seat right away on the street table
… moreAiyana Fig
Añejo NYC is one of my absolute favorite spots in the city. The atmosphere is vibrant and welcoming, the service is outstanding, and the food is incredible. The tacos are full of flavor, the guacamole is fresh and delicious, and the margaritas are some of the best I have ever had. Everything came out quickly, and the staff made sure we were taken care of the entire time. Whether you are here for brunch, dinner, or just drinks with friends, you are guaranteed to have a great time. I cannot wait to come back!
… moreSydney Labhart
The food, service, & ambiance were 10/10. We tried the carnitas tacos, shrimp tacos, birria tacos, and churros as well as the blanco margarita with spicy rim. Everything was absolutely amazing. I’m a tough critic when it comes to Mexican food since I’m from a Southern California Mexican family. I highly recommend Añejo to anyone looking for an elevated Mexican cuisine experience.
… moreClifton Meek
Came here for the brunch with friends and had the best time! They’ve got a great bottomless cocktails deal for $29 at brunch and the Margaritas were delicious! Everything we had was super flavorful and prepared perfectly (with the exception of the chilaquiles which were too soggy). Service was excellent too. Will definitely be back!
… moreGogula Aryalingam
The best Mexican food I’ve ever had. Everything we tried was out of this world. It’s a place that wouldn’t be what it is if it wasn’t for all the noise the guests make. The servers were great; she made sure we were looked after despite it being very busy.
… moreRoss Cluver
We had such a wonderful meal here, and service was impeccable. Elizabeth, our server, was attentive and knowledgeable, while Juan, the manager, made our evening very memorable and introduced us to their most incredible Flan (highly recommended).
We came for an early dinner after a matinee show, and Añejo was the perfect choice—tucked away from the Times Square chaos but close enough to be convenient. The food was outstanding across the board. We started with the Pork Belly Tostadas, which were perfectly crispy with great balance of flavors. The Lamb Barbacoa Tacos were tender and beautifully seasoned, the Ribeye Fajitas were generous and cooked to perfection, and the Lomo de Cerdo was succulent with just the right accompaniments.
For dessert, the Churros were fresh and satisfying, but the real star was the Flan that Juan treated us to. Silky, perfectly caramelized, and one of the best we’ve had anywhere.
Beyond the food, what made the experience special was the genuine hospitality. Elizabeth was wonderful throughout our meal, and Juan’s warmth and great recommendations made us feel truly welcome. This is exactly the kind of neighborhood gem you hope to find in New York – excellent food, warm service, and a comfortable atmosphere that lets you actually enjoy your meal and conversation.
Highly recommend for anyone looking for quality Mexican cuisine away from the tourist traps!
… moreAndrew M.
Cozy, small, relaxing. Drinks are good good food portions. Loved the ambient lighting,Loved the food. The manager was attentive and so was our waitress. She herself was the mixologist that came up with a valentines day drink which we enjoyed.. we’ll be back…
… more