Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Family owned since 1995. Andy’s is an easygoing and family friendly dine-in or to-go Italian restaurant with a large selection of hand made pizza, fresh paninis, home made pastas & many more delicious Italian staples like eggplant parmigiana and baked ziti.
Easygoing sit-down spot with a large menu of Italian staples like veal parmigiana & baked ziti.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 2204 NJ-35, Sea Girt, NJ 08750
Phone: (732) 223-9250
Website: http://www.andyspizzeria.com/
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Andy’s Pizzeria: Home
Andy’s Pizzeria. Pizzeria in Sea Girt, NJ. Appetizers · Entrees · Pastas · Specialty Pastas · Side Orders · Pizza · Subs/Paninis/Wraps · Catering Menu. Come …
Andy’s Pizza and Restaurant | Sea Girt NJ – Facebook
Andy’s Pizza and Restaurant · Appetizer special  this week, toasted garlic bread with fresh tomatoes,and burrata · Happy Valentine’s Day · Happy Valentine.
Andy’s Pizzeria | Authentic Pizza in Sea Girt, NJ
Located at 2204 NJ-35 in Sea Girt, Andy’s Pizzeria offers a wide selection of delicious, handcrafted pizzas made with fresh ingredients.
Reviews
Eddy Cantrel
Hungry. I didnt even know it was around the block from Me.
Compared to other pizzerias the slice is a little smaller but very good!! Slice was $3.75 with pepperoni.
Pizza reminds Me of old school NY Pizza. Actually im gonna go there in a little bit to get a slice!
New post-
After discovering Andy’s was close to where I live, and enjoyed a slice the few times I’ve been there, I decided to order a pie for delivery.
I ordered a pepperoni pizza. Unfortunately I will never go back or order from them again. I was so hungry and ready to dig in!
Took a bite and there was a “slightly bitter” aftertaste. I thought about it for half a second and told Myself….”its probably fine”. I was so hungry that I ate 3 slices.(they’re not that big)
Sure enough My stomach starting making noises, I felt very gassy, headache started, and it gave Me “ah-gi-da”…like it was stuck between My throat and chest when it wasn’t.
Sometimes canned tomatoes which are used to make the sauce can be a little bitter, which applies to everyone that uses them which is the norm.
Thats why old school Italians will put a little sugar in there sauce to cut down on the bitterness.
However there’s a difference between bitterness and acidity when a sauce with tomatoes is used like pizza sauce, Marinara, tomatoe juice, salsa, etc….
When a sauce is “turning” it takes on a bitter, acidity like metal taste and needs to be thrown out, or it will make people sick, or worse depending on what stage it’s at.
If you ever see a sauce with tomatoes used in it, with what looks like tiny air bubbles on top be sure to check it. If these bubbles are popping on there own and reproducing while you’re looking at it, head for the hills cause its spoiled and dangerous to eat.
I suspect the pizza sauce was left out all day for a busy night, or the refrigerator where its kept is not working properly keeping it at the correct temperature, hot or cold, and it was starting to turn.
I tossed the rest of the pie in the garbage, popped a few Tums, and that’s that! No more Andy’s for Me!!
Happy Holidays Everyone!!
… moreCompared to other pizzerias the slice is a little smaller but very good!! Slice was $3.75 with pepperoni.
Pizza reminds Me of old school NY Pizza. Actually im gonna go there in a little bit to get a slice!
New post-
After discovering Andy’s was close to where I live, and enjoyed a slice the few times I’ve been there, I decided to order a pie for delivery.
I ordered a pepperoni pizza. Unfortunately I will never go back or order from them again. I was so hungry and ready to dig in!
Took a bite and there was a “slightly bitter” aftertaste. I thought about it for half a second and told Myself….”its probably fine”. I was so hungry that I ate 3 slices.(they’re not that big)
Sure enough My stomach starting making noises, I felt very gassy, headache started, and it gave Me “ah-gi-da”…like it was stuck between My throat and chest when it wasn’t.
Sometimes canned tomatoes which are used to make the sauce can be a little bitter, which applies to everyone that uses them which is the norm.
Thats why old school Italians will put a little sugar in there sauce to cut down on the bitterness.
However there’s a difference between bitterness and acidity when a sauce with tomatoes is used like pizza sauce, Marinara, tomatoe juice, salsa, etc….
When a sauce is “turning” it takes on a bitter, acidity like metal taste and needs to be thrown out, or it will make people sick, or worse depending on what stage it’s at.
If you ever see a sauce with tomatoes used in it, with what looks like tiny air bubbles on top be sure to check it. If these bubbles are popping on there own and reproducing while you’re looking at it, head for the hills cause its spoiled and dangerous to eat.
I suspect the pizza sauce was left out all day for a busy night, or the refrigerator where its kept is not working properly keeping it at the correct temperature, hot or cold, and it was starting to turn.
I tossed the rest of the pie in the garbage, popped a few Tums, and that’s that! No more Andy’s for Me!!
Happy Holidays Everyone!!
Madison Rodriguez
We ordered two burgers and chicken fingers to go. The food was beyond disappointing. Burger was literally black to a crisp and half the size of the bun. I also asked for sautéed onions on the burger and the onions were probably on a pan for 10 seconds. The tenders were also over cooked and the meat was beyond dry inside. Disappointed cause the pizza is usually decent.
… moreDaniel
Been coming here since I was in high school, the quality of food for the price here remains unmatched. Easy to find with plenty of parking. Some bench seating up front and even more seating in back. BYOB! Caesar salad was nice and fresh and a good sharable app. Shrimp red sauce and Calamari linguini with red sauce was tasty! No nonsense flavor, no heavy at all
… moreZach Goldstein
Garbage pizza. Locked in place at a job site. Needed to order local pizza for delivery the idiot kid driver can’t find it anywhere despite be given deliberate instruction and delivers cold pizza and warm soda. Terrible. I want a refund. Never ordering from here again.
… moreAmbrose Bin
Fried calamari chewy. Definitely frozen. My wife had penne vodka pasta was under done. Pizza is always good and fresh.
… moreEmily Duerr
I love Andy’s and have been a proud supporter for years. The most kind workers and incredible food. If you want a great restaurant this is the spot! I got their shrimp parm and it was delicious.
… moreJudy C
Just brought home white pie (freakin delicious!) for my husband and a plain cheese pie for me. It could be the best plain pie I’ve ever had…no joke. Thank you guys for standing over an oven when it’s 95degrees out!!
… moreChad Hensler
Consistently great! We’ve been going here for 20+ years. Great service at the counter and table. Pizza is excellent along with all the dinners and sandwiches. Can’t go wrong with Andy’s!!!
… moredorothy davis
The meatball sub was one of the best meatball subs I’ve ever had and the people working were very nice 🙂 !
… moreJanet Card
We placed a huge order @ work. Chicken Tenders & Fries are served plain, I ordered honey mustard, 2 sides were 1.00 each!! Ketchup for the SOGGY fries was 50 cents each. That was an extra $ 2.50 plus tax & tip! The girl that took the order should let us know their is an extra charge for condiments!! No thanks, we will NEVER order from here again.
… more