Kevin M
One of the best pizzas on the planet. So unique and in its own league. I grew up eating here with my grandparents and as I continue to grow older it only gets better. Quick and great service. 10/10 every single time no matter what you order.
… moreJonathan Williams
About the end of September 2025, I ordered 3 trays of pizza to be sent to my brother-in-law in Westfield MA for his birthday. Fr. Joe and my sister have lived in New England for the last 40+ years where they raised their children. They made a point on every visit to Pennsylvania to go to Andy’s Pizza. They truly love the pizza and it had become a tradition for them. Fr. Joe became very ill and has been battling cancer so the family cannot travel as much. When I told Joan at Andy’s about their No. 1 fans, the pizzas were sent gratis. I know the secret ingredient in Andy’s Pizza: Heart. All of us are ever so grateful for your kindness!
… moreB Forte
WHOOP They did it again!
Andy’s Pizza is that place that everyone heard of. If you haven’t, now is the time to visit. Fall is in the air, and the toppings are falling right onto every pie. The cheese makes you wonder with every bite how they make it so delicious. The dough is fresh and soft, and the crust can be a stand-alone itself. It’s Andy’s Pizza Season in Peckville, and all is good. This is just a friendly reminder that Andy’s is cash only, but cash is good to have along with some delicious pizza.
… moreKeystone Reviews
Pizza is not your traditional pie. The crust is very doughy as some mentioned. I would ask them to cook it a few minutes longer if you prefer a firmer crust. But regardless, the crust is very good. The cheese is Old Forge style.
… moreApril Balendy
Pizza was delicious..We ordered take-out but my husband said this seemed like a very nice place to have dinner and a few drinks..
… moreJill Stone
If you’re expecting a good old Italian pizza, well think again. Andy’s is different, and that’s why we here in the valley love it. You’re in cheese Heaven, and the taste is like no other here in PA. My daughter and her husband live in Atlanta, and Atlanta has no idea how to make a pizza (yuck, I’ve had some). So, for their anniversary every year, it is demanded that Andy’s Pizza be shipped as their gift, and my daughter normally hoards one just for herself. The pizza always arrives in perfect condition, and the cooperation I get from the owner is fantastic. Whenever they come to PA, I must have atleast 3 Andy’s Pizzas waiting for them. A PIZZA LIKE NO OTHER!!!!!
… moreRic Ravier
Pizza along the Lackawanna Drainage is a little different. Cooper Cheese vs. Mozzarella on the pie? Whatever is going on, it is good, and historic.
… moreJJ2FRYD
I got here at 6:30 and there was really only maybe two other party’s, yet it took our server quite a while to bring our drinks then we have been over an hour for pizzas mind you there was barely any orders coming in and the seating area where I was, was empty besides one party.
… moreMichael Uhler
A must try. Beware – Andy’s is cheesy. You will notice on the menu, “don’t be shy,” meaning that you can request lite cheese, burnt cheese, etc. So order the way that you’d like.
Also, CASH ONLY at the time of this review.
Great place…the interior is a bit dated but in a way that makes you feel like they have something great and they are sticking to it.
This is worth a try and I will be back to try their speciality pies.
… moreLiss
Andys is an experience. They have been there forever. Iv walked the streets as a little kid after a highschool football game, and nothing ever changed. Pizza is amazing. Get it well done, with some burnt cheese on top ❤️. Cozy little bar that seemed very quiet on super bowl. If I drank I’d sit there and enjoy it. They are still cash only.
… more