Family-run eatery serving NYC-style pies & slices, plus pasta dishes, Italian sandwiches & calzones.
Rus Trana
Consistent, friendly, delicious pizza! I’ve been coming here for years and it never disappoints. Would recommend eating the pizza in-store, the crust has a perfect level of crisp straight from the oven. The garlic knots are also an incredible side. My go to is the barbecue chicken pizza, it’s INCREDIBLE.
Dining area is clean with lots of red chilli flakes and parmesan shakers. Service is fast and warm. Perfect spot for casual lunch or dinner.
… moreDog Dude
I had never been to Amore, And I was looking for something different to take home as I drove through Zionsville. It was a great decision! I ordered a large barbecue chicken pizza to go. The pizza was delicious, and I judge pizza also on the amount of Grease in the container. There was virtually no grease in the box when I was finished! That’s ways a good sign. The inside was quaint even though I only walked in to pick up my pizza. The young lady at the host stand was very kind and provided excellent service as well, which I always appreciate. I’m looking forward to going back soon and trying some of their pasta that looked so good.
… moreDave Kahn
THE BEST! In the 13 years I’ve been in Indy, this is hands down the best Pizza & Italian I’ve had. Period. No one else even comes close. Garlic knots & red sauce…delicious! Plus…don’t sleep on the Black & White cookie. Best I’ve had since New York. The owner Danny was super cordial and took great care of us. Thank-you. We’ll be back.
… morePeter Merante
Former New Yorker, who has lived here for 18 years. I’ve had Westchester County, New Haven, Connecticut, and New York City pizza and I think I finally found the closest thing to home. ❤️ I was referred to Amore after meeting another former New Yorker at a friend’s party and her recommendation is worth it’s weight in New York style pizza! The crust was spot on, the ratio of sauce to cheese was right where it needed to be, and the temperature was perfect. I will definitely be back, thank you, Amore
… moreSonic Broadcasting
The pizza has that perfect crispy bite. The flavors are what they should be. Absolutely amazing food. Doing New York style pizza proud. If you have every had a real New York pizza this is close comparable, delicious pie that deserves a 9.5 out of 5 stars.
… moreJennifer Nolen
I love that you can buy pizza by the slice here. Our family ordered garlic knots, salad, several different slices of pizza and calzones. The only disappointment was the Greek salad – it was just greens, feta, and about a million olives. No dressing. Everything else was excellent!
Plenty of parking, lots of seating, easy to find and get to.
… moreAdam C
I received a pizza and didn’t know the bottom was burnt until I got home. I called and they said if I don’t bring back the pizza and wait for it to be remade the best they could offer was a 50% refund. I didn’t want to drive back during a storm so I took the 50% refund and threw the pizza away. This business did not do enough to remedy the situation.
… moreChris Murnane
Nice lunch specials ranging from $11-15. My wife got lasagna (pictured), garlic knots, and a drink for less than $15. And the lasagna was a huge portion!
I got the 2 slices and a drink special for $13+ I believe. These slices are NY style and the stuffed meat lovers slice really was great!
Very nice staff and I really liked the eco friendly touches like using real silverware instead of plastic.
Definitely will be back to try more stuff!
… moreA J
The chicken Parmesan was delicious. We also had salad and the dish came with garlic knots. They were very good! The service was great, very attentive and friendly.
… moreChristopher Conway
I would rate the Pizza a 6.9 Nice crisp on bottom major flop, a little tang, my only issue is that it’s small and pricey for the size. Out the door 16.00 (with tip) for drink, slice, and sticks with sauce. If the size of the slice was larger 7.2.. all day…. Sticks and cheese were on point! I gave 5 stars because of setup, cookies, pizza, pasta, calzones, salads… a little bit of everything. The staff was friendly and on it for sure. Definitely worth trying or a good lunch spot if your around Zionsville. Next time I’ll try a whole pie and see if it’s better value.
… more