Bianca Dvorsky
Hands down, one of the best sandwiches I’ve ever had. I got the Cousin Mikey, just how it comes. Absolutely fantastic. Next time I would order it with extra coleslaw, but that’s just a personal preference. You NEED to check this place out if you’re event remotely in the area. There’s no AC inside, so I’d recommend the outdoor seating in the very back. My sub was $15, massive, and worth every penny. I can’t wait to eat the other half.
… moreMichael Vangi
Great sandwiches in the morning ! Come hungry! They are yummy! Home fries are exceptional and a hearty amount of meat ! Get the healthy start it’s delicious!!
… moreJenn Torre
do yourself a favor and go across the street to lombardi’s where you’ll actually be treated like a human being. we came in on a monday off-season and the employees there helped 10 other people and made their sandwiches first because they knew who they were. 20 min after ordering, we checked on the status of our sandwich and watched them put the ingredients on the grill in front of us, even though they knew we had been waiting. they had been helping other people all along and prioritizing the orders because they’re regulars. we walked out empty-handed and went right across the street where we were helped right away and the sandwiches were excellent
… moreMathuaerknedam !
This is my go-to early/fast breakfast on the North Fork. I usually get a sandwich with egg/cheese and a different meat each day. The pancakes are also good, but hard to eat on the run.
… morePhyllis Montgomery
Stopped here starving after my fifth 12 hour shift at the hospital this morning, wanting to reward myself with a hot breakfast after a very long week. I don’t go here very often because parking on Love Lane can be difficult, however, I am a local to the area year round. I came in to a quiet place- one woman at the counter waiting for her order, one man and his small son eating at a table, and me. The staff saw me walk in and look at the board. I looked over the breakfast board quickly then followed the signage to order at the register. Was in there less that one minute. Two people walk in just then. The male employee that saw me come in, saw me look at the menu board, saw me standing there to order, comes over, and immediately starts helping the two he knew that just walked in, completely ignoring me. I never said a word besides good morning, was not rude, hurried or irritated. I just walked out. They can’t say they didn’t know, or misunderstood, they simply chose to skip me in favor of familiar faces. I guess if you are a frequent flyer, you get some sort of preference. I promise to never bother this establishment again or recommend it to anyone if asked. Went somewhere else and will continue to do so. Born and raised on the North Fork. Seriously disappointed.
… moreJohn Burns
The..London..Calling.. almost don’t want to say anymore. When I saw my favorite roast beef headlining the private stock menu I began to drool. Now the wait, it’ll keep you drooling but busy means good in my book and I couldn’t have been the furthest from upset. This sandwich and deli has landed in the top five hero for me on this island and I haven’t even tried a second one yet. I am wayyy less reluctant to be dragged out to the north fork by my wife!
… moreSophia Giuffrida
My boyfriend and I came here a couple of months ago and had such a lovely experience. Our sandwiches were amazing, and the owner is the kindest man. We will be back!
… moreMatthew “Matt from the North Fork” Chizever
We’re currently working our way through their VERY EXTENSIVE SANDWICH MENU and haven’t had a stinker yet!
These guys are the real deal, and easily our new favorite sandwich spot on the North Fork! I’d write recommendations, but seriously, we’ve been back five times since coming a couple months ago and every sandwich we order is an absolute masterpiece!
… moreHolly Albertson
We worked with Greg, remotely, for a memorial service and he and his team were great. Easy communication, with wonderful suggestions. The food was wonderful as was our server, Eileen. My family is so appreciative of the ease and high quality. We can’t recommend them enough!
… moreP Magaard
Coming from the west coast, I had the seared ahi tuna wrap with wasabi slaw that was out of this world!
… more