Kaimilani Gilman
I was excited to finally try Amici tonight. Staff was super helpful when I accidentally ordered to the wrong location. Pizza was great, I really enjoyed the sausage they used. A large could easily serve 3-4 adults. We are looking forward to leftovers. Garlic knots were delicious, happily surprised by the amount of fresh garlic on top! Shirley was yummy too. Prefect Friday night treat. We will definitely order again!
… moreK M
I sooo want to love this place because I follow the owner on TikTok and I love her but….we’ve ordered a few times and a couple of times it was spot on but the rest of the times the food has been under cooked. Dough is almost raw and the topping slide off. We have to finish cooking the food ourselves. Hopefully in time this new location will get trained better.
… moreYasmeen Ortiz
This is my third time giving Amici Pizza a chance. Sadly, this time was the worst. I ordered the spaghetti and meatballs plus an order of garlic knots. The food was already almost cold by the time I got home and the meatballs were definitely not fresh. The meatballs looked somewhat undercooked(I could be wrong) and had an off smell. I tried to put them in the microwave just to heat them up more; but it still was bad. Unfortunately, I won’t be going back.
… moreRyan Minnix
So I came here to try them out on my birthday, as I was by myself (I know, depressing, right?) and felt like trying a different pizza place. First off, the staff is so overly friendly, I feel like I have some new best friends. I ordered 2 slices to try, they gave me 4 since I said it was my first time. When I said thank you for giving me extra, and mentioned it was my birthday, they also gave me a free cannoli. The pizza and dessert were, as Portnoy would say, a 7.9, which is top notch here in AZ! I will be back again Saturday, as I found out they also make a Philly Cheesesteak, and I love me a cheesesteak.
… moreBrittany Ashbaker
Went in today and got 2 slices, garlic knots, and a Shirley. I am impressed. The margarita pizza was fresh and the cheese pizza was so flavorful. You know a place is good just based off their cheese pizza slice. Definitely coming back and looking forward to this as our neighborhood pizza joint. A big win for small businesses coming to Queen Creek.
… moreaubrey devens
Very good NY style pizza. The crust was delicious! Perfect amount of sauce and cheese. So happy to have a good pizza place close to home! Affordable! Jalepenos are fresh and very spicy!
… moreCurtis D.
Have tried this place a couple times now, and it is seriously disappointing
First experience, there was so little sauce on the pizza that 2 of the slices were just air bubbles. Knowing that they have been busy, we let it go and tried again.
This time, our “extra cheese” upside down sicilian pizza had even less than a normal amount on it, and a pathetic amount of sauce compared to the misleading menu photo. (See photo) It was overdone and chewy. Just bad. It didnt help that it sat in an open box for 10 minutes because the employee didnt know it was done.
Our gluten free pizza wasnt even sliced. (See photo) Our wings were underdone. And it was the most we’ve ever paid for pizza in our lives.
The only reason i am not giving 1 star, is because the crust is good when not overcooked.
I literally dont think the cooks here care AT ALL.
I hope things get better here. The original location was very good.
… moreDNJ
I have been here four times now. Best pizza I have had in Arizona. No wonder Portnoy from Barstool gave it such a high score. I have only had pizza, mozzarella sticks, and wings. The sticks had great seasoning and all the pizzas have been great. Jury is still out on the wings. Next time I will get the wings with sauce on the side.
… moreShawn Lepka
Not only is the pizza incredible but the employees are just as great. My toddler and I waited inside for a pizza to get done baking and it turned into a little dance party and we had the most fun ever and so did the staff. Even though you can’t sit down and eat inside, they still made the best of it and made it welcoming and enjoyable for us.
We’ve been to the original Amici, but this one is much closer and we don’t mind taking it home to go. Their cheese pizza is literally out of this world and better than pizza I’ve had in New York City. It’s so good that I couldn’t wait to eat it and took a slice before taking this picture
Go see them and order up!!!!
… moreN
I guess it was how we decided to order that made this not a great experience. We wanted to try it in a pinch so we ordered 3 slices and an appetizer which she said would take 10 minutes. It took 40 minutes and the pizza wasn’t even that warm. It was also $24 which is way pricy for what we got. Also, the pasta was $10 and way small so not worth it either. I guess we’ll order a whole pizza next time but still… Don’t offer by the slice of you can’t do it right. Not exaggerating, I would have preferred a slice of Costco pizza for a fraction of the price.
… more