Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 200 NY-32, Central Valley, NY 10917
Phone: (845) 928-1103
Website: http://www.amalfipizzeria.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Amalfi Pizza & Restaurant
Located in central valley, the closest pizzeria to the woodbury commons. Amalfi Pizza & Restaurant offers a delightful fusion of authentic Italian cuisine.
Amalfi Pizzeria & Restaurant – Central Valley, NY – 200 NY-32 …
View the menu, hours, address, and photos for Amalfi Pizzeria & Restaurant in Central Valley, NY. Order online for delivery or pickup on Slicelife.com.
Amalfi Pizzeria of Central Valley – Facebook
Amalfi Pizzeria Restaurant offers traditional and Roman style pizza as well as Italian cuisine. Dine in, take out, or delivery.
Last Updates
Reviews
Shawn Gee
Hands down the best pizza in the Monroe area – absolutely delicious! Every bite is pure perfection. If you’re craving pizza, this is the spot! ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
… moreThomas Yates
I just got a large pie and i must say Absolutely Disgusting Grease Trap
Do NOT waste your money at AlMalfi Pizzeria unless you enjoy eating a literal oil slick. Their pizza isn’t food—it’s a crime against Italian cuisine. The moment I opened the box and the 1st bite, I was hit with a wave of grease so thick I could practically hear my arteries clogging. The cheese was swimming in a pool of orange sludge, and the crust was so soaked in oil that it disintegrated in my hands.
Whoever is running this place should be ashamed. This isn’t pizza—it’s a heart attack on a cardboard tray. Even the toppings were drowning in grease, making every bite feel like chewing on a dirty dishrag. I wouldn’t feed this garbage to my worst enemy.
Save yourself the nausea and go literally anywhere else. The whole pie went straight in the trash normally the bears would ravish my garbage in search for food…it was untouched the following day, even they didn’t want it!
… moreDo NOT waste your money at AlMalfi Pizzeria unless you enjoy eating a literal oil slick. Their pizza isn’t food—it’s a crime against Italian cuisine. The moment I opened the box and the 1st bite, I was hit with a wave of grease so thick I could practically hear my arteries clogging. The cheese was swimming in a pool of orange sludge, and the crust was so soaked in oil that it disintegrated in my hands.
Whoever is running this place should be ashamed. This isn’t pizza—it’s a heart attack on a cardboard tray. Even the toppings were drowning in grease, making every bite feel like chewing on a dirty dishrag. I wouldn’t feed this garbage to my worst enemy.
Save yourself the nausea and go literally anywhere else. The whole pie went straight in the trash normally the bears would ravish my garbage in search for food…it was untouched the following day, even they didn’t want it!
Bella Caiafa
⭐️ 0/5 — Never Again
We placed an order for Black Friday weekend and scheduled delivery for 10 AM. I understand it’s a busy day getting into Woodbury Commons, but we didn’t receive our food until 6:30 PM — after my tenth phone call following up. That alone was unacceptable.
We ordered an assortment of sandwiches with sides, sauces, and wraps. What we received was the complete opposite:
• No assortment at all — just basic turkey, ham, and cheese.
• Everything was drenched in mayonnaise (no mustard or mayo packets on the side as ordered).
• No wraps, no variety, nothing we paid for.
• The sandwiches were simply cut in half and thrown into a tray — no presentation, nothing.
We paid $100 and got absolutely nothing close to what we ordered. The food was horrendous and completely ruined our expectation for a large order on a very busy day. If a restaurant can’t handle Black Friday orders, then they simply shouldn’t accept them.
I would never recommend this place based on this experience. Zero stars.
… moreWe placed an order for Black Friday weekend and scheduled delivery for 10 AM. I understand it’s a busy day getting into Woodbury Commons, but we didn’t receive our food until 6:30 PM — after my tenth phone call following up. That alone was unacceptable.
We ordered an assortment of sandwiches with sides, sauces, and wraps. What we received was the complete opposite:
• No assortment at all — just basic turkey, ham, and cheese.
• Everything was drenched in mayonnaise (no mustard or mayo packets on the side as ordered).
• No wraps, no variety, nothing we paid for.
• The sandwiches were simply cut in half and thrown into a tray — no presentation, nothing.
We paid $100 and got absolutely nothing close to what we ordered. The food was horrendous and completely ruined our expectation for a large order on a very busy day. If a restaurant can’t handle Black Friday orders, then they simply shouldn’t accept them.
I would never recommend this place based on this experience. Zero stars.
Hadi Barakat
Very good pizza, the buffalo chicken pizza was good, the plain was ok, the spinach pizza was very good
… moreMellissa Sevigny
I am so done with this place! We have ordered via slice many times and while the flavors are good the food is so inconsistent as are the portion sizes. The last straw is that I ordered a large calzone (they have small, medium and large) with extra sauce which I paid for. $29 for a plain cheese calzone served on a standard paper plate. Typically a large would arrive in a pizza box and feed several people. If this is a large, then the small must be the size of an English muffin. The solution they offered was to send a driver to pick it up and give me a refund. So after waiting an hour now I have no dinner? No thanks. I’ll eat your tiny calzone and never give you my business again. What a shame.
… moreJulian An-Khang Goetz
Totally blown away. Ordered 6 Roman style slices with the missus and each new bite was better than the last. The bread both fluffy and crunchy, the cheeses all well chosen, even the light oil on the margherita delicious.
… moreJr M Garcia
The delivery was slow and a mess. It look like the food was dropped, sauce everywhere. The delivery guy just gave the food like nothing was wrong.
… moreBeth Cable
I LOVE everything about Amalfi…. From the nicest owners, hardest working staff, and delicious food I come here a lot… and it never disappoints. My favorites are the drunken chicken parm (hero and fried wrap), Bronx pasta, crazy chicken pizza, cornerstone salad, and the cheesesteak on the garlic bread. YUM!! It’s my go to for pizza in this area! Recently I picked up 8 pizzas for an end of the year party at school and they were so appreciative I chose them and brought it out to my car & made sure I had plenty of plates and napkins! The staff work their butts off and still remain polite and attentive! Oh and the milkshakes are pretty incredible too – my favorites are the peanut butter one and the confetti cake one! I love this place!!
… moreoliver estevez
I was having a wonderful Mother’s Day with my wife and kids until I decided to give this pizzeria a chance. I’m a strong believer in customer service, and based on my experience tonight, they definitely lack it.
First, I asked for cups with ice, but they were never provided. When the pizza was finally served, one of the servers placed it on the table without saying a word. I asked the owner if they had plates, and he brought me six pizza pans with a bit of an attitude, in my opinion.
It felt like we were being rushed out of the restaurant. When I asked for to-go boxes, the same rude server tossed them on our table without saying anything and walked away. I will admit that I didn’t leave a tip initially because of the attitudes of the owner and his daughter. However, after some thought, I realized that it wasn’t my server’s fault she had a boss who doesn’t seem passionate about his work.
When I asked the owner if they could reprint the receipt so I could give the server her tip, he responded with an attitude again. Because of this experience, I will not be returning to this pizzeria in the future.
… moreFirst, I asked for cups with ice, but they were never provided. When the pizza was finally served, one of the servers placed it on the table without saying a word. I asked the owner if they had plates, and he brought me six pizza pans with a bit of an attitude, in my opinion.
It felt like we were being rushed out of the restaurant. When I asked for to-go boxes, the same rude server tossed them on our table without saying anything and walked away. I will admit that I didn’t leave a tip initially because of the attitudes of the owner and his daughter. However, after some thought, I realized that it wasn’t my server’s fault she had a boss who doesn’t seem passionate about his work.
When I asked the owner if they could reprint the receipt so I could give the server her tip, he responded with an attitude again. Because of this experience, I will not be returning to this pizzeria in the future.
Douglas Furr
The service was excellent. The food was excellent. It will definitely be in my favorites. If your ever in the area and you don’t go here to eat you are definitely depriving your self of a good meal. I had a half cheese half grilled chicken pizza with buffalo sauce on the side and a cheese steak a lemonade and a vanilla cream soda
… more