Allegro Italian & Mexican Food

Discover Allegro Italian Mexican Food in Baldwin, NY, where savory Italian dishes and tantalizing Mexican flavors meet. Enjoy a diverse menu with vegetarian …

Allegro Italian & Mexican Food – 771 Brooklyn Ave, Baldwin, NY 11510

Order online at one of the best restaurants in Baldwin, NY! Allegro Italian & Mexican Food is a neighborhood favorite. Quick delivery and exclusive offers …

Last Updates

Reviews

Roxxanne Cearth

The Italian is excellent, the Mexican is just alright. It’s clear upon walking in that the Mexican is secondary. But the pizza is so good that I still feel they deserve 5 stars for it. Besides being delicious, the pizzas have finely-diced toppings which are much nicer to bite into than the giant toppings you’ll almost always see elsewhere. The garlic knots are also super garlicky and great. For the Mexican, the empanadas were quite plain and the burritos were much more akin to wraps. I won’t be trying anything from the Mexican menu again (though who knows, maybe there’s something good I’m missing out on), but I want to try all of their pizza!

… more

PTA Council Corresponding Sec Baldwin

This is a nice cozy restaurant right by the train station. Food is always good. Service is kind and efficient. My favorite pizza joint in Baldwin.

… more

Tayler Engel

Had an amazing meatball hero. It was cold outside and hot inside, so was nice! Staff was awesome.

… more

Vittoria St. Rose

I forgot to take a picture but the chicken tacos are soooo good! By far the best I’ve had, and the staff is so very kind 10/10!!

… more

Miranda Urena

Love this place! I have gone three times already (all in person). First time, I tried their grandma slice and ended up buying another! Last two times I got the chicken quesadilla which is soo good. Tried their tres leche too. It was very moist and was a great price. Other places charge double for a smaller portion. Prices are good. Food is delicious. Service is great! Very welcoming. Def try this spot out 🙂

… more

Grace Austin

Excellent food and service. The owner is amazing. Prices are reasonable and the pizza has superb taste. Highly recommend! ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

… more

Unknown Guart (R19)

Mexican and Italian!

Probably one of the best two types of food in one store, can’t beat that!

This place is a hidden gem! A la vodka was perfect, their tacos were very tasty and cheap! The plain slice has the crisp you need and the Marsala slice was to die! Cheap, delicious and a must! This place is not a just a hidden gem, but a well kept secret!

… more

Amanda T Acevedo

A I am a bit disappointed on my experience. I would come here for years and the guy behind the counter with the glasses was always kind and a pleasure to talk to. I have not been there in awhile and today I decided to place an order of meatballs to go got pick up. I walked into tte restaurant and as soon as I walked in he pulls out a meatball slice and says to stay or to go with an attitude no hello no how can I help you. When I tell him I ordered a side of meatballs he sucked his teeth and rolled his eyes no apologies nothing and just told me the price of the meatballs. At first I was thinking did I donsomething to this man until another customer came behind me and he was greeted with the same cold attitude. I want to give him the benefit of the doubt because you never know what someone is going through but I will never go back at all. Sorry to say quality of food has declined. Service is so important and how you treat people.

… more

Gurpreet Singh

Great experience overall – we had a chicken broccoli slice and meat lover pizza! It was amazing – fresh, rich in taste and crust was so light. Delighted with the experience.

… more

Irshat

Nice, friendly staff, delicious pizza, cheap prices! Thanks guys! I wish you prosperity!

… more

… View more

Address and Contact Information

Menu Photos

Order and Reservations

Photo Gallery

Related Web Results