Tips From A Bellman
After moving here a month ago , my son had told me a couple times that All American Pizza had the best pizza in town and the calzones were good too. He’s been here for 2 years now. Anyway , the other night he went to get us each a calzone to bring home. He told me the guy who helped him was kind of rude this time and when he asked for Ranch the guy said I already gave you Marinara , which my son said yes my Dad likes Marinara , but I like Ranch for mine. He gave him the Ranch , but again said I already gave you Marinara. Okay was it really a big deal he wanted a Ranch instead ?
Anyway , my son gets home with both calzones and goes wow they are way smaller than the last time I got them. I was like yeah they don’t make them that small in Las Vegas. Now I got the pepperoni , sausage , and green peppers. It was pretty flavorless. This is the best pizza place in Mustang ? Dang. My son said his was better when he got it last month. The Marinara was not bad , but it didn’t save the calzone. I know times are tough and maybe they made them smaller to save a couple bucks , but you gotta have good flavor to get customers to come back. I was really disappointed after my son had told me several times how good this place was and the attitude he got when he ordered this time.
… moreAngie Kuaile (Angie Filkins)
The great American pizza salad and wings definitely live up to their name. The pizza was cooked to perfection with a deliciously crispy crust and the salad was fresh and flavorful. The wings were also a standout, with just the right amount of spice and a juicy texture. Overall, I highly recommend this restaurant for anyone looking for a satisfying and tasty meal.
… moremike doty
The Calizone is the best in Mustang! The pizza is also AMAZING! The service is friendly and on target. The prices are very reasonable as well! Jennifer is also a great manager and will treat you like family! This will be our goto for our family’s pizza night from now on!
… moreRandall’s Reviews
Grabbed a calzone today from here and man it was damn good !
The young gentleman that was taking our order was very polite and suggested to try there homemade ranch with the order and it was a very nice additive but that calzone didn’t need it it had a ton of flavor ! The sauce that came with it was a solid 7 the ranch is where it’s really at and the cheese and bread tasted fresh as well .
… moreCheyney Ney
Pretty upset with our order tonight, our pizza had no sauce, the cheesey bread sticks were great, our cinnamon “sticks” was a piece of crust barely cut and had a a small sprinkle of cinnamon light drizzle of icing. Our bread sticks were the only warm item as well. My husband usually loves this place and tonight I gave it a chance and we are all highly disappointed! The ranch saved our meal though!
… moreHeather Hinkle
We ordered 8 pizzas for a party and it was hot and fresh when we got there. They did excellent and the price was cheaper then i expected!
… moreChloe Guy
Look their pizza is good. However, they have continuously messed up my orders twice. One time I ordered a calzone and they sent me a pizza. This time I paid for ranch and they sent me marinara.
… moreBA S
The people here are so awesome. The pizza is delicious and consistent. The wings are absolutely the best we’ve ever had!
… moreLaura Ayers
Great pizza, In my opinion its by far the best in Mustang/Yukon area, very consistent. They are light on their sauce which I like but if you are someone that likes a little more sauce ask for extra!!
… moreCharlie
This place stinks. The ingredients are literally bread, cheese and sauce and I’ve still had my order under cooked on multiple occasions. I’ve given them chances to correct the mistakes and been met with “we will get you on the next one”. No thanks. I’ll pass on getting food poisoning. I tried to reheat the pizza and there are so little ingredients to it, it disintegrated in the oven lol. Strong work all around here.
… more