Social Profile: 
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
A Slice of Brooklyn – New Holland, PA Craving authentic Brooklyn-style pizza in Lancaster County? A Slice of Brooklyn brings bold New York flavor to New Holland with handcrafted pies, fresh ingredients, and unbeatable taste. We offer convenient delivery and a speedy pickup window to make your pizza run even easier. Whether you’re grabbing a quick slice or feeding a crowd, we’ve got you covered—taste the borough in every bite! Let me know if you’d like to highlight any specialties like Sicilian slices, garlic knots, or dessert options—I can tailor it even more.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 808 E Main St, New Holland, PA 17557
Phone: (717) 355-0333
Website: https://www.asliceofbrooklynnewholland.com/?utm_source=gbp
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
A Slice Of Brooklyn – New Holland, PA – 808 E Main St – Hours …
Order Hours About. 10:00 AM-9:40 PM; Shop address is 808 E Main St, New Holland, PA 17557808 E Main St, New Holland, PA 17557; (717) 355-0333.
A Slice Of Brooklyn – 808 E Main St, New Holland, PA 17557 – Slice
A square thin pan pizza made with garlic, mozzarella & plum tomato finished with pesto and pecorino romano cheese. Our best seller. $25.00. $22.50. slices …
A Slice Of Brooklyn – Authentic NY Style Pizza Experience
A Slice of Brooklyn is a hidden gem located at 808 E Main St, New Holland, PA, known for its authentic New York-style pizza that tantalizes both locals and …
Last Updates
Reviews
Jesus Flores
10 wings, 1 flatbread? slice and 16oz Pepsi was $23. No lunch specials and order ahead of time. Women that attended me was very nice.
… moreJenitza Gonzalez
This is our normal go to place to order pizza but today was a little special. We had ordered a large pepperoni pizza with the pepperoni in the shape of a number 4 for our daughter’s 4th birthday today and a large cheese pizza. Not only did they make the 4 but they also left a little note for her in the box. Then when it was delivered the young man who delivered made sure to wish her a happy birthday. Thank you guys for doing this for her.
… moreJames Butta
Pizza was good. Crispy crust. Less cheese than your traditional pizza but it worked with what I got. Stromboli wasn’t bad, the dough was soft, no crisp to it.
… moreLee Godfrey
Was an absolutely amazing experience. I’m a truck driver from New Mexico and had a stressful day dealing with loads and traffic. Got down here to New Holland just to find out my next pick up is closed till morning. So I decided to just go relax and this was just the place. The young lady working was amazing with great attitude and one hell of a personality. We laughed and talked about where I was from and finally decided on the grandma pizza which was amazing. Will be back if ever in the neighborhood
… moreLisa Carson
Never had a problem before until tonight. Very hot inside and a lot of flies. We order take out we were still there 45 minutes later and left never got our food. People sitting there to eat waited over a hour to get their food. I will never order from them again. There were only 2 couples inside to eat. The cook was mouthing off to the waitress when she asked to the customers their food they been waiting for an hour or more.
… moreSeth Ester
Food was great but I needed to use the restroom and found out that they were broken and have been for some time
… moreDao Yang
Do not order the carbonara! Clearly the cook does not know what the dish is. Their own menu describes the sauce as: bacon, onion, spaghetti noodles with a Parmesan based sauce.
Instead, this “carbonara” was served with red sauce. Poor server explains, “I’ve always seen it served with a red sauce.”
Also, menus do not display the latest prices – what is listed at $11 is now $18. That information is not disclosed until you pay.
Do yourself a favor, stick with the pizza and then steer clear of everything else.
… moreInstead, this “carbonara” was served with red sauce. Poor server explains, “I’ve always seen it served with a red sauce.”
Also, menus do not display the latest prices – what is listed at $11 is now $18. That information is not disclosed until you pay.
Do yourself a favor, stick with the pizza and then steer clear of everything else.
Andrew Rountree
Loved that meat pizza! Thing is huge! Very nice decor. Very friendly staff. Mainly Togo orders it seems. I’m not a big fan of tv. Am from out of town and really wanted to watch the game. That’s the 5th star.
… moreChad Crompton
A Slice of Brooklyn? More Like a Slice of Disappointment!
My family has been coming to “A Slice of Brooklyn” since it opened. The food used to be good, and the service was decent—*until* last night. Now? I wouldn’t eat here if they were handing out free pies on the street.
We’ve spent *thousands* of dollars at this place over the years, especially during COVID when they probably should’ve been thanking loyal customers like us. But after last night’s fiasco, we’re done. We won’t be ordering here, we won’t be using them for business meetings, kids’ sports games, or ANYTHING, and you better believe I’ll be warning everyone I know about how abysmally this place treats its customers.
So, here’s what happened: we placed a massive order—multiple pizzas, subs, appetizers, the works. Well over $100. And what did they do? They forgot my niece’s food. No big deal, right? Mistakes happen. So I called them to let them know.
Instead of an apology, I got some cranky guy (not the owner, but definitely someone who shouldn’t be dealing with customers) who practically accused me of lying. He insisted he had “read the order back to me” and even had the nerve to imply I was trying to scam them for a few measly chicken fingers and fries.
Yeah, because after spending tens of thousands of dollars here over the years, my master plan is to defraud them out of a $10 plate of frozen chicken fingers. Genius.
And here’s the kicker: they made us pay again for the food they forgot. No apology, no refund, just another charge on the bill. I’m guessing they tacked on another delivery fee too, just to rub salt in the wound.
Well, congratulations, guy—you just lost a loyal customer and probably many more once word spreads. This place clearly doesn’t value its customers, and I’ll be making sure people know exactly how terrible their service has become. If you want overpriced pizza served with a side of condescension, go for it. Otherwise, take your money somewhere that actually deserves it.
… moreMy family has been coming to “A Slice of Brooklyn” since it opened. The food used to be good, and the service was decent—*until* last night. Now? I wouldn’t eat here if they were handing out free pies on the street.
We’ve spent *thousands* of dollars at this place over the years, especially during COVID when they probably should’ve been thanking loyal customers like us. But after last night’s fiasco, we’re done. We won’t be ordering here, we won’t be using them for business meetings, kids’ sports games, or ANYTHING, and you better believe I’ll be warning everyone I know about how abysmally this place treats its customers.
So, here’s what happened: we placed a massive order—multiple pizzas, subs, appetizers, the works. Well over $100. And what did they do? They forgot my niece’s food. No big deal, right? Mistakes happen. So I called them to let them know.
Instead of an apology, I got some cranky guy (not the owner, but definitely someone who shouldn’t be dealing with customers) who practically accused me of lying. He insisted he had “read the order back to me” and even had the nerve to imply I was trying to scam them for a few measly chicken fingers and fries.
Yeah, because after spending tens of thousands of dollars here over the years, my master plan is to defraud them out of a $10 plate of frozen chicken fingers. Genius.
And here’s the kicker: they made us pay again for the food they forgot. No apology, no refund, just another charge on the bill. I’m guessing they tacked on another delivery fee too, just to rub salt in the wound.
Well, congratulations, guy—you just lost a loyal customer and probably many more once word spreads. This place clearly doesn’t value its customers, and I’ll be making sure people know exactly how terrible their service has become. If you want overpriced pizza served with a side of condescension, go for it. Otherwise, take your money somewhere that actually deserves it.
Anthony Raffaele
A true NY style pizza !!!
Thin n crispy with good sauce to cheese ratio !!! The best pizza in Lancaster county !!!
… moreThin n crispy with good sauce to cheese ratio !!! The best pizza in Lancaster county !!!