Social Profile: 
✔️Breakfast ✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 98 N Main St, Mansfield, OH 44902
Phone: (419) 526-2669
Website: https://www.facebook.com/people/Coney-Island-Diner/100063575170325/
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Coney Island Diner | Mansfield OH – Facebook
The Coney Island Diner is Mansfield Ohio’s oldest operating restaurant located @98 N. Main … See more. Diner · $.
Coney Island Diner for sale; owners cite declining sales amid Main …
The eatery is located at 98 N. Main St. MANSFIELD — Aubrey Caugherty said she saw sales plummet at her downtown eatery after the city of …
Order Coney Island Diner – Mansfield – DoorDash
Get delivery or takeout from Coney Island Diner at 98 North Main Street in Mansfield. Order online and track your order live. No delivery fee on your first …
Reviews
Ryan Davis
Ordered lunch here today. First time visiting, and I’ve been wanting to get lunch here for a while. I called in my order for pickup. The young lady was pleasant to speak with and took my order quickly.
I ordered two coney dogs with slaw, fries, and a piece of Dutch apple pie. For starters, the coneys are spot on. The coney sauce has great, nice soft buns, and the slaw is just the right amount of sweet to make these some of the better coneys I’ve had in a long time.
The fries were ok, but seemed a bit dull. They weren’t crunchy, but they also weren’t soggy. They aren’t thin cut, nor are they thick cut. Very basic and boring. Maybe they could have been fired a little longer to get more crisp to them.
The Dutch apple pie was good. Comparing it to a Dutch apple at most places, this would be a step up most assuredly. That being said, I wouldn’t put it up against my favorite pies from some of my favorite Amish restaurants, such as Boyd & Wurthmann.
For $15, I think the price is a little steep for the quality. But it’s not the worst deal in town?
Will I be back? Yes, for the coneys. But I’ll get something other than the fries, and will probably just skip the pie for some homemade cookies I made myself at home.
… moreI ordered two coney dogs with slaw, fries, and a piece of Dutch apple pie. For starters, the coneys are spot on. The coney sauce has great, nice soft buns, and the slaw is just the right amount of sweet to make these some of the better coneys I’ve had in a long time.
The fries were ok, but seemed a bit dull. They weren’t crunchy, but they also weren’t soggy. They aren’t thin cut, nor are they thick cut. Very basic and boring. Maybe they could have been fired a little longer to get more crisp to them.
The Dutch apple pie was good. Comparing it to a Dutch apple at most places, this would be a step up most assuredly. That being said, I wouldn’t put it up against my favorite pies from some of my favorite Amish restaurants, such as Boyd & Wurthmann.
For $15, I think the price is a little steep for the quality. But it’s not the worst deal in town?
Will I be back? Yes, for the coneys. But I’ll get something other than the fries, and will probably just skip the pie for some homemade cookies I made myself at home.
Chelsea Gutierrez
Amazing place! So glad we stopped in. We had family who came into town and decided we were finally going to stop by…. After years of wanting to come here we finally did … Didn’t disappoint and is exactly what I thought it would be. Good food… Definitely left full and treat prices! Super cool decor as well. The owner and her daughter seems to be truly nice and genuine people. If you get a chance to stop here, especially during the construction, please make it a point to do so. These business need us!
Thank you for the great experience and wonderful meal. We will be back
… moreThank you for the great experience and wonderful meal. We will be back
Tammy Zink
I stopped in to support a local business, Coney Island Diner, today that I heard was struggling and as I walked in the door, the waitress ( which I later learned is the owner) said when she seen me walk in, “Of course, when I’m working by myself!” I turned around and walked straight back out. Apparently they don’t need business too bad. Definitely don’t need mine. Won’t be back.
… moreVicki Buckner
The food here is so yummy you must try it. It’s my first time, but it won’t be my last. The waitresses were so kind and always check your needs. The inside takes us back in time.
… moreConstancia WR
Come for the nostalgia. Come for the friendly, quick and capable wait staff. Heck, come for the pea salad, even–just don’t come for the coneys unless you want a sizeable serving of slimy disappointment. The sauce was gelatinous, as though it had been thickened with cornstarch.
The rest was great, but as a Coney restaurant, that’s the part you’re supposed to get right!
… moreThe rest was great, but as a Coney restaurant, that’s the part you’re supposed to get right!
Kelly LaZette
If you’re in Mansfield you have to stop at this restaurant! The food was delicious we had sausage gravy and biscuits, the corned beef hash, and the eggs bacon and hash browns. Are server was absolutely excellent. She had a funny sense of humor and was just absolutely wonderful. I’m sad to say that it’s a 2-hour drive from my hometown.
… moreMelissa Weimer
This was my first experience here. And will not be my last! I love a quaint little dinner. The food was fantastic and the servers are amazing. Not to mention the food came out very quickly. 1000% recommend a visit. And very reasonable prices! Afterwards pop across the street and enjoy the Carousel!
… moreJon Vega
The new owners have given an already great menu better fries. They serve Hershey’s ice cream and pie for desert. The ambiance is retro diner and the service is friendly.
… moreKim Reed
Coney Island Diner is a gem for the Mansfield area! The food is always excellent, the atmosphere is very nostalgic and the service is the absolute best! It is always clean and you can find something for even the pickiest eaters! We absolutely love it!
… moreBob Reeves
Very nostalgic, the re retro atmosphere is wonderful. Of course we had to have the money dogs they were good. We seen a lot of great looking breakfast plates being served. We really enjoyed our experience.
… more