Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 98 N Main St, Cedarville, OH 45314
Phone: (937) 766-5779
Website: https://www.colonialpizzamenu.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Colonial Pizza – Cedarville, OH – 98 N Main St – Hours, Menu, Order
View the menu, hours, address, and photos for Colonial Pizza in Cedarville, OH. Order online for delivery or pickup on Slicelife.com.
Colonial Pizza – 98 N Main St, Cedarville, OH 45314 – Slice
Colonial Pizza · Colonial Pizza – View Menu & Order Online – 98 N Main St, Cedarville, OH 45314 – Slice.
Colonial Pizza – Facebook
Details. . 4 Reviews. . 98 n main st cedarville ohio, 45314 ; Links. . toasttab.com/colonial-pizza-98-n-main-st/v3 ; Services. . Specialties. Outdoor seating …
Reviews
Simple Designer
Son goes to Cedarville… I was in the area to give a few things (home =2 hours away)… it was latER on a Saturday night… we went around 8pm. I asked him about it… he’s like “YES!!!! PLease? It’s great!!”. They had a special “brisket pizza” (brisket, onions, jalapeños, 2 kinds of cheese)… it was awesome!!! I hot thr chicken Alfredo pizza… also very, very good!!! Inside the restaurant is quaint and comfortable. You order @ counter… they’ll find you and bring it over to to table. Loved the lady who took our order. Will try to come again… THE CRUST IS AMAZING!!!
… moreDj Sullivan
I always enjoy going here when we come to visit our daughter at college. The ladies that work here are extremely friendly and funny. They make the children laugh, and they know and like their job. Exceptionally, the pizza is as good as it gets. I really enjoyed the chicken wings. And the garlic bread is good as well. We’ll definitely be going back here. Even though my daughter’s not in college anymore, we will stop in from time to time. Thank you again.
… moreTim Weaver
The food was delicious, but it was a bit costly for the amount we received. I came to Colonial after a neighbor suggested it. For $3 we received what looked like a happy meal amount of fries. They were good! We order the nachos and got very little cheese, chips, salsa, and peppers for $6. Our pizza was good, but we also had to carefully pull each piece apart. It was not cut too well. Tried it out and wanted to give it a better review, but couldn’t with the low portion sizes.
… moreSherri Lewis-Neuman
We were driving by looking for a place to eat lunch. The service was great. It appears no one is a stranger there. Loved the pizza great crust and toppings. Oh yea, cannot forget the cheese bread. Gooey cheese. Awesome!!
… moreJacob Pitzer
The restaurant has a nostalgic and cozy old pub feel that I enjoy. But the pizza is really what makes this place great. The house-made dough is amazing. It cooks up light and a little chewy under the toppings, and has large, crispy bubbles on the edges of the crust.
They even use stone ovens to cook with. Well worth the drive if your looking for a great pizza.
… moreThey even use stone ovens to cook with. Well worth the drive if your looking for a great pizza.
Andy
I’ve lived near Cedarville most of my life and I’ve always loved Colonial Pizza and will always support them. Tonight I got the Buffalo chicken pizza which I’ve always loved and it was different kinda dry and bland hopefully it was just this one and not a permanent change.
… moreBrian Stevenson
Between our visits to John Bryan State Park and the Indian Mound Reserve, we stopped by Colonial Pizza for a late lunch. To our surprise, the back patio overlooked a creek with some spectacular fall colors.
I thoroughly enjoyed my regular crust Works pizza with salad and breadsticks. My wife said the Gluten Free crust on her veggie pizza tasted very good.
The service was fast and friendly. We’ll definitely be back next time we visit the parks in this area.
The patio is dog friendly.
… moreI thoroughly enjoyed my regular crust Works pizza with salad and breadsticks. My wife said the Gluten Free crust on her veggie pizza tasted very good.
The service was fast and friendly. We’ll definitely be back next time we visit the parks in this area.
The patio is dog friendly.
Pamela Lyle
Great pizza. Extremely busy Friday early evening. We ordered 3 pizzas, Hawaiian, pepperoni, and Big meat. We ordered jalapeño breadsticks but devoured them before I remembered to get a photo. Food was hot and delicious. We will definitely return when we are in the area.
… moreMelissa
I’ll be the first to admit that I’m picky about my pizza. I’ve been wanting to try Colonial for awhile now but I was hesitant. So glad I finally did! We got it for my husband’s birthday. We all loved it. The size was huge! Absolutely full of toppings. It could use a little more cheese, but that’s minor. We will just get it with extra cheese next time. The flavors are on point! Prices are more than fair. We will definitely be back.
… moreJustin Rissmiller
Great food and service. The sub that I got was fully loaded up and delicious. The time waiting for my food too was minimal. I recommend this place for sure! Also plenty of seating on the inside too with zero wait times.
… more