Welcome to Maestro’s, your go-to Italian restaurant in Quincy, IL. Established in 2024, we specialize in authentic Italian cuisine, offering a delectable array of dishes including fettuccine, lasagna, spaghetti and meatballs, stuffed shells, pizza, chicken parmesan, and more. Whether you’re craving a quick lunch, a family-style dinner, or catering for a special event, Maestro’s has you covered. Enjoy the convenience of carryout or savor the ambiance in our cozy dine-in setting. Come experience a taste of Italy at Maestro’s today!
Address and Contact Information
Address: 938 Maine St, Quincy, IL 62301
Phone: (217) 209-0256
Website: https://maestrosquincy.com/
Menu Photos
Related Web Results
Maestro’s – Quincy, IL
Welcome to Maestro’s, your go-to Italian restaurant in Quincy, IL. Established in 2024, we specialize in authentic Italian cuisine, offering a delectable …
Maestro’s | Quincy IL – Facebook
Maestro’s , Quincy. 2117 likes · 3 talking about this · 135 were here. Italian Restaurant.
DINNER MENU – Maestro’s Italian Restaurant
(If you have a food allergy, please speak to the owner, chef, or server). A fee of 5.00 will be charged for sharing.
Reviews
John Bary
I have read through these reviews over and over and I think most of these people must have never had real Italian. The place is absolute garbage. I took my wife here for Valentine’s Day as a recommendation from a friend. We got to the restaurant and a woman, who offered no greeting at all, showed us to our table. I should have left as soon as I saw the woman. She was wearing sweats like she just woke up, no bra, looking rough as hell and acting gruff as hell. The lighting in the place reminded me of a doctors office. I was sure there was about to be an operation of some sort. The waitress finally came and ask us about drinks. We asked about the drink menu and she informed us they didn’t have a bartender so we couldn’t order drinks. On Valentines Day!!!! So we ordered or Coke and the waitress overfilled it and spilled it on the table. No mention of cleaning it up or an apology. Just dropped them off and left. The table tops are white paper so it didn’t soak up it just ran all over the table. So we orders bruschetta for our appetizer. When it came I was blown away. A cold piece of bread, with raw cherry tomatoes thrown on top, and unmelted cheese. You couldn’t eat it because when you picked up the bread everything just fell off. I held hope hoping the main course would still be as good as my friend described. I was definitely let down in a big way. It was trash. Honestly Fazolis fast food is more Italian than this place and taste 10 times better. We ended up ordering a pizza from little caesars and heading back to the hotel. The pizza was much better as well. I would not recommend this place to anyone nor would I go even if someone else was paying for my meal. Super disappointed.
… moreJerry Durbin
Tues evening out and decided to give this place a try, so glad we did. They did a great job of transforming the old pizza place into an inviting first class Italian destination. The food was excellent with lots of flavor. Our services was top notch and with a smile. The atmosphere was inviting, what a nice place. We will be going back soon.
… moreChristina Turner
Tried for the first time. Service and food were excellent. No complaints there. Friendly environment, but the atmosphere is a bit noisy. You can hear every conversation and glass ding, phone rings throughout the whole building… only pointing that out in case someone has noise sensitivity that plans to visit.
… moreKimberly Page
Amazing. The best Italian in town. My whole family left feeling cared about and with full bellies. Credit card machine is down while they set up. Bring cash. Go to Maestros!
… moreLivia Perry
I made reservations for dinner date night and was super excited to try the new restaurant! Place is small and made for a very echoey room. No music or other noise except everyone talking over one another. Service was good but staff seemed a bit sloppy in appearance. I ordered vodka pasta which was not very flavorful and the sauce was extremely watery which all fell off my noodles. We were thinking dessert for the special occasion but just decided to leave. Overall glad I tried but probably won’t be returning.
… moreLora Stratton
This was so delicious. We had the house lasagna, Pollo Parmagiana and Calamari and it was all exceptional.
… moreJon M.
A spur of the moment decision to check this place out. As expected, they strive to be high-class dining.
The food was good, a tad dry for my taste but acceptable nonetheless.
Only real complaint, the nice waitress barely spoke to us. While she was very polite, she was short with her answers and did not offer any of their wine or other alcohol selection. Which, we found odd.
We enjoyed ourselves. Overall, a nice place to visit.
… moreThe food was good, a tad dry for my taste but acceptable nonetheless.
Only real complaint, the nice waitress barely spoke to us. While she was very polite, she was short with her answers and did not offer any of their wine or other alcohol selection. Which, we found odd.
We enjoyed ourselves. Overall, a nice place to visit.
Jonathan Baker
Best place, in town, great food, wife loved it, as a business owner any of the workers that works at that restaurant will get a 40% off discount anytime. Thanks again
… moreKelly Klinner
We want to commend Billie and her crew at Maestro’s for the wonderful meal they prepared for our graduation party. The food was outstanding. We loved it and most importantly, the new Grad loved it.
You went above and beyond and were fantastic to work with. In a world where quality and customer service is so frequently lacking, Maestro’s blew it out of the water from start to finish! You really made our day great and we sincerely appreciate everything – from the menu you created for us, the outstanding value, the excellent quality, exceptional taste, and even delivery. You guys are awesome and we highly recommend Maestro’s delicious, outstanding food for any event! Thank you Billie and the Maestro’s crew!
… moreYou went above and beyond and were fantastic to work with. In a world where quality and customer service is so frequently lacking, Maestro’s blew it out of the water from start to finish! You really made our day great and we sincerely appreciate everything – from the menu you created for us, the outstanding value, the excellent quality, exceptional taste, and even delivery. You guys are awesome and we highly recommend Maestro’s delicious, outstanding food for any event! Thank you Billie and the Maestro’s crew!
Angelia Maxeiner
Great place to enjoy as a couple/family. Fried calamari appetizer was very good the marinara that accompanied it was very flavorful. We ordered seafood ravioli. They ran out (great problem to have). We reordered cannelloni that was superb. House salad had a lightly sweet Italian dressing. Tiramisu for dessert was the perfect finish. We will be back again soon and hope to try the seafood ravioli the next time. Be kind and call for reservations. They have limited space and have become very popular very fast! Love the quaint personal feel. This is my new favorite date night! You won’t be disappointed!
… more