Mike Topper
After a long week of work travel was craving Italian and did pick up on my way home. Ordered baked mostaccoili. Image of menu vs what I got. I could have made this at home & saved myself $20. No baked anything!
… moreJ R
There’s a reason this place is always packed! The atmosphere is a fun “WI Supper Club” vibe! The food is fantastic, as are the drinks & the service is excellent! Their pizzas are truly delicious! Even their gluten-free cauliflower crust pizza tastes sinfully delicious! I’m still not sure how they pulled that off! Their Cajun Shrimp appetizer eats like a meal & is truly outstanding, along with their fluffy bread! The cheesy hashbrowns & pastas are incredible, as are their meatball sliders, but the real star of the show is their walleye, which is easily the best in all of Wisconsin! While yes, that’s a bold statement, it’s absolutely true! Angelo’s never disappoints, they are a well-oiled machine & you will leave happy! ❤️
… moreKit Donahue
The service at Angelo’s is always wonderful! Rick, the owner, always greets us with a smile and makes us feel very welcome. Last night, our bartender (Sam) was fantastic – very friendly and attentive. We ate our favorites appetizer at the bar (spicy spinach bread with sausage – so delicious!!) and took a calzone to go (HUGE and also delicious!) We haven’t had a meal at Angelo’s that we didn’t love. Some of our favorites are the Cajun fettuccine, the chicken pesto pasta, the BBQ ribs, the vegetable lasagna, and the cauliflower crust pizza. You can’t beat the food or the atmosphere at Angelo’s – don’t change a thing!
… moreConnie Jelle-Hegerfeld
We went to Angelo’s, McFarland tonight. It was very busy, even at 5:00. We were lucky to get a table quickly. Our server was Jennie. She was very attentive & the food was amazing! We will definitely be back!
… moreApril Ossmann
Angelo’s in McFarland is a great Italian restaurant with many tasty dishes and beverages to choose from. An authentic place with a nice patio. Our server, Yareli & staff were very friendly and efficient. I highly recommend this restaurant!
… moreJess
We’ve been here quite a few times and the food is always good! This most recent visit was our first time trying Angelo’s for Friday fish fry. We both enjoyed our fried cod and the sweet potato fries and baked potato were great. I think I prefer their regular menu though, and Mondays are great for happy hour with 1/2 price apps!
We often sit at the bar, but whether the bar or a table, we always get good, friendly service.
… morepatti christel
I took my daughter and two grandson out for dinner at your restaurant tonight. My grandsons are 5 and 3. Our waitress was topnotch! She went out of her way to make sure my grandson who doesn’t like “sauce” got plain spaghetti- and that was after he did not like the Fettuccine! Plus, she didn’t change extra! Our food was delicious! Great bread! Definitely coming back!
… moreRon Olson
Love the chicken alfredo family meal deal. Also got the shrimp scampi loved it. Family meal deal no longer offered. Food is still great, desserts were outstanding and drinks were just how I like them. Staff was friendly and helpful. We bring our out of state friends here to eat and have eaten here now back to back years on our anniversary.
… moreDanica Jackson
My husband and I went here on a random date. He sent me four different links of restaurants to try, and this one struck me instantly. It already had great reviews, so that was a plus. I’m glad I picked it.
The restaurant itself is elegant looking, which made for a nice atmosphere overall. The food was delicious, and our waitress was attentive, knowledgeable, and friendly.
My husband and I ordered the Bruschetta as our appetizer (as we usually do when the option is available), and it was extremely tasty at a very decent price! You give you complimentary bread and butter as well, which is always a bonus.
We ordered pastas for our main meals. My husband ordered the “Baked Mostaccioli” and I ordered the “Chicken Pesto Pasta”. Both were wonderfully prepped. All pastas come with your choice of soup or salad. I chose the soup, which had the perfect amount of flavor, in my opinion. I’m not sure if this is something they always do, but when we received our bill, the waitress had two hershey kisses placed with our bill. A cute little treat.
We really enjoyed this restaurant. We will be going back again for our anniversary. It’s a wonderful restaurant with great service, food and prices!
… moreNancy Gardner
Really love this restaurant. Always welcoming and food is so good, I had Thai Chicken Cashew pasta, that was very tasty. Portions equal 2 meals for me. It can be quite loud in the dining area making it hard at a larger table to communicate, but not so bad I won’t return.
… more