Micaella Gonzales
Overall amazing!! The service was great and the food was somehow even better. My husband and I got the seafood chowder to start; it was hearty and well seasoned. He got the duck sausage bomb and the mustard was great with it! I got the Cajun salmon sandwich and it was visually appealing and delicious. 10/10 recommend.
… moreJackie Adler
This was our last dinner in Bar Harbor during our vacation the 1st week of July. And it was a phenomenal experience!
We made a last-minute and later in the evening decision to stop here for dinner. There were no tables available and I stead of waiting for one we opted to eat at the bar. The bartender was very nice about the fact we don’t drink.
The restaurant itself was packed on a Thursday night with diners eating inside and out. As it was our last night, we were in no rush to eat.
The clam chowder was very good; more of a broth than cream base but yummy nonetheless. I ordered the haddock sandwich and found it delicious. It had a panko breading that was light but crunchy. Hubby chose the lazy lobster. Decent sized portion and tasty. I sampled the sweet potatoes, too, and they were sone of the best I have had. The bartender said they order a special kind that accounts for the flavor. Finally, the smoked ricotta chocolate Mousse. I had my doubts, but I absolutely fell in love. Trust the chef; if you love chocolate, you will love this.
Overall, an outstanding final dinner of a wonderful vacation. If we are back in the area, we will return.
Highly recommend.
… moreMarcos O. Diogo
Absolutely delicious seafood, we’ve ordered lobster and it was very fresh. Quiet mood and lovely to have dinner, it was a bit overpriced for my opinion a the portions sizes but overall a great dinner.
… moreLori Woody
Absolutely outstanding experience! We sat at the bar with Rory. She was so friendly and knowledgable about the menu. She was helped guide us through the menu with her personable favorites. The host who sat us have us a great recommendation of the baked brie and it did not disappoint! The oysters were fantastic and so fresh. We sampled all the varieties they had in stock. Each has one unique, but the unicorn was our favorite. We also had the clam chowder and Jonah crab roll. Both were amazing. If you want outstanding service and incredible food, you need to go here. Everyone that worked there was smiling and friendly. Bonus: they have a small seafood market on the side. Even though we were stuffed, we took bluefin tuna home with us.
… moreEdward Chen
Tldr: just okay. Nothing special. Good for brunch.
We got the pulled pork tacos, the breaded haddock tacos, the lobster bisque, and the features of the day. Overall, the food was ok but was unevenly seasoned. The bisque was quite salty while the feature fish did not have much taste. Both tacos had contrasting flavors that was not to our taste. Had a little bit trouble finding parking. No other issues.
… moreHanieh hosseini
Loved our experience in Peekytoe! The menu is broad and gives a lot of options.
We tried oysters, salmon, shrimp tacos and crab Berger. All were yummy.
Lobster roll was ok.
Portions are smaller than we are used too and this was mine and my family’s only complaint.
Servers were sweet and responsive to our questions.
… moreDana Waldrop
Food was excellent!!
We had the Haddock tacos with chips and fruit salsa and the BLT with kettle chips. The tomatoes were grilled and the sauce was yummy (did have a little kick in case you’re not used to that). The blueberry pie was delicious and the whipped cream was creamy not sweet. Wonderful.
We called in the order for carry out and the staff was confused. I almost walked out with just a bag of chips and a piece of blueberry pie. I had to be totaled out twice and still needed to double check the order.
Don’t know what inside service is like but make sure to double check carry out. It all worked out in the end.
… moreJoseph Quintana
I used to genuinely love this place but that was back before the remodel/rebrand. Back then it felt more authentic, casual, and cozy to the everyday person. The food was always good the place was always busy, and the staff was super connected to the restaurant. Now the first time for us coming back since the remodel/rebrand our waitress left dead in the middle of waiting on us, no “I’m sorry my shift is over but so and so will be taking care of you” the waitress who took over had no clue about the how the place was or even knew that there was a store front to it. While she was nice she never came to check on us or offer refills on our water and other drinks. My favorite thing there the Smoker Seafood Chowder which is one of my favorite things to eat in this town was so off. It was broken and overly salty, the blackened haddock sandwich I got was super salty and had almost no spice to it as a proper blackened sandwich should. My son’s salmon Rueben panini had little to no coleslaw/kraut on it and the dressing was overpowering to the point it seemed as though there was no salmon on it because it was so thin sliced. My other son however LOVED his lobster roll(he’s a bit of a connoisseur if you will) and my wife really enjoyed her salad and curry crab soup. Overall now I have to give this place a 3-3.5 stars as the atmosphere now seems to be geared more towards the “upscale” clientele rather than the local or “normal” tourist. It’s lost its charm and seems that some of the food quality has gone down a bit in the process. With so many options in and around Bar Harbor I’m not sure that we will rush back here next year when we are in town.
… moreValerie Nahorney
My martini was made with a mixture(!) of olive juices and was interesting and delicious. The oysters were a good size and full of flavor. The soups were unique and delicious. The scallop rangoons were hot and tasty and actually had scallops! The lobster panini was really good–big pieces of lobster and cheesy and gooey. We were too full for dessert, so we’ll have to come back for that. Rory and Rachel took great care of us–couldn’t ask for better service.
… morePeter Auv
This was a great spot for food and good vibes. The hot lobster roll was delicious. The standout meal item was the smoked fish chowder! All the food was so good that I was only able to document the oysters. Service was helpful and super friendly!
… more