Catch-a-Fire Pizza – Cincinnati
Best pizza in Cincinnati Restaurant offers handcrafted wood-fired pizzas, appetizers, sandwiches, salads. Bar & taproom serves wine, beer, …
Melissa Wilkerson
Tasty! This was a cool place. As you know, we are looking (in our opinion) for the best wood fire pizza in the area. This was our third one. It was sectioned off from the bar area and family casual seating. I loved that. They had specialty beers and hard cider. The strawberry cider was excellent with the pizza we had as well as the stout. I must say, the appetizer was excellent. Something I had never had before. It was creative and delicious. I do not care for extremely spicy foods, but this was crafted so well, that I ended up eating more than half. These were the Fire Bites. Peppadew peppers stuffed with goat cheese. It was so well paired that the goat cheese and roasted in the wood fire oven. EXCELLENT. I guess the goat cheese help keep the peppers mild enough for me. We also tried the wings with the dry jerk rub. Again, dang good. The Smile BBQ Pizza was good and flavorful. But I had one issue. I was looking for the crust to be light and airy. The chicken was cubed. I would have liked shredded. These two items for me, was the only things missing. The taste was there and good. No complaints on the service. It was warm, welcoming and friendly. We will go back. There are more items on the menu I would like to try. They even had connections under the bar for phone hook ups. Now that is a great feature.
… moretom dusseau
The building was nice and clean. They had the football game on. We were able to watch the game while we eat. The pizza was delicious we had the three pigs add bacon and extra cheese it was delicious. My grandson ordered the Italian sub, he said it was a 10 out of 10. The service was friendly and attentive it was a 10 out of 10. We will go back and would recommend to family and friends.
… moreJohn Bolin
The pizza was delicious, the meatball sandwich was as well. Caesar salad was a caesar salad, Nothing special. But the service… fantastic! They were friendly, attentive and even checked on us to make sure we were doing good on time as we had told them we had tickets for a timed event we were on our way to.
… moreNicola Busano
I’m from Chicago.
I was scared to eat pizza out here and…
Absolutely delish. You guys are killing the game. On top of the server pouring me a fantastic Woodford on the rocks. Nice place also!!!! Thanks for the great service and great zaaaaaaaaa!!!!
… moreKevin Mininger
Awesome wood fired brick oven pizza place with great service. The wait staff was awesome and friendly. The wings were great. The pizza was top shelf delicious. Best service I have had for a while.
… moreTaylor Le
We went for the first time for Cincinnati pizza week. They had two specials going on for this location. They were featuring the one love Pizza and the potato heads pizza. Both were only $10 for the Cincy pizza week!!
The one love pizza is your classic cheese pizza, it had a stringy pull and with red pepper flakes, it was really good!
The potato head pizza was our favorite, the crust was really crispy, and it had ranch on it, which we really enjoyed. It is something we would re-order again in the future!
We also tried one of their crafted sodas, just a regular cola. It was really good As well. Our service was great, everything seems really clean and the space is a lot bigger than I thought it was
… moreDeb O
We had a wonderful experience. Clay was amazing! He had great suggestions. We were able to do half a pizza bbq chicken and half Mr. Brown. We loved everything we ate. Fast and friendly service! We’ll be back!
… moreKim Doan
Tried Catch A Fire Pizza after hearing they were voted #3 for best wings—and wow, they did not disappoint! I ordered the loaded fire oven pizza and, of course, had to try the famous wings. They were perfectly crispy, and the buffalo sauce had just the right kick. I can definitely see why they made the list. This spot just earned a spot on my favorites list! AND, Trish was my server. Outstanding, made great recommendations, attentive and a kind person
… morePierce Gohlke
Service is phenomenal!
Food could be a bit better.
We got 2 pizzas, a few starters, and tried a few of the sodas.
The pizzas are well cooked but could use a bit more sauce. The cherry oh baby needed a bit more sweetness maybe from some honey and was improved with a bit of the chili oil they have on the table. The Stir it up had great toppings and was a really great combo pizza. Just needed a teeny bit more sauce.
The fire bites are a great starter would recommend grabbing an order.
Wings were fine they weren’t as roasted as I wanted. I was expecting something closer to chicken tikka. The amount of buffalo sauce also overwhelmed the charred flavor. Would recommend going with a dry rub if you get them.
The reggae ranch salad we tried was fine. Nothing special.
… moreMelanie Osorio
. Here I am again…inevitable to bring my favorite people to my favorite place. Delicious food and impeccable service. All my questions were answered. The waiter was very friendly and, most importantly, knowledgeable and able to answer any questions about the menu. Always a pleasure to visit.
… more