Josh Hocum
Just stellar service from start to finish! We had a large group of high school seniors going to camp nearby and Pete and his team took such great care of us. Called ahead to let them know we were coming (24 people) and they worked hard to have a space ready for us, provide A+ service, and we’re super quick getting the pizzas out to the table. And then all our kids were raving about how good the pizza was!! It was a win all the way around! 10/10 recommend!
… moreBrian Andrews
Picked up some items to go and eat back at my place with the ‘Slice’ service. Very easy to order. Very easy to walk in and pick up my food and the staff seemed nice and the dining area seemed big and clean.
When I got home I opened my food and it seemed as though it had been sitting for a while, not sure if there was communication issue with the ‘slice’ app or the service was just too quick but it gave me an estimated pick up time of 30-40 minutes so that is when I arrived. Probably my fault for not checking the pizza at the counter when picking it up so I don’t want to fault them there.
Pizza was OK. Crust very thin which tastes good but doesn’t fill you up. Cheese was a decent amount (not too much and not too little). Sauce was the same that I’ve had on ice rink pizza which is heavy on the oregeno. Overall I wouldn’t go out of the way to get it again and seems a little overpriced with the crust being so thin. The picture makes it look better than it was since it was cold by the time I got to eat it.
Hot Italian sub, would not get it again. Tasted good but really tiny and presentation was pretty bad (see pictures). Poor value and not a lot of flavor.
Gyro wrap, bad presentation again but tasted good and a decent sized portion. Could have used a bit more sauce on it. I’d get it again though.
Steak and cheese, good taste, good presentation, good value with the exception that every topping is extra (peppers, onions, cheese, etc) . Definitely would get this again(I mean just look at that picture) !
Overall I’d give them a 4/5 and the benefit of the doubt about the food being cold or pick up time not being communicated properly with the 3rd party app. The food was mediocre and a tiny bit pricey but the friendly service helps bump the overall rating from 3 to 4.
… moreUnity Realty
Excellent all around! Very friendly customer service and delicious pizza! I’m gluten sensitive and they have a lot of options! The key lime cheesecake was a winner and their GF pepperoni was very good. Will definitely make this a favorite
… moreCharles Rothermel
We had an awesome experience at Lake Gaston Pizza and More! Our server Crystal was incredibly helpful and made us feel right at home. The wings were the standout — we tried both the Insane Asylum sauce and Pete’s Fireball sauce, and they were packed with flavor and heat. The pizza was also excellent, with a perfect crust and plenty of toppings. Definitely worth the visit — great food and even better service!
… moreMark J
Went on a Monday night and they were very busy. However the staff was outstanding. Moving food faster than a fast food chain. Steak and cheese was delicious and pizza was great. Will go back.
… moreBill McMillan
We visited upon a recommendation from a friend. Good location just across the Eaton Ferry Bridge. We tried the coconut shrimp appetizer. The shrimp was served hot and fresh. The thin crust pizza was loaded with toppings. The calzone was ginormous! Enough for two meals. Friendly attentive staff makes this a must try when in the Lake Gaston area.
… moreK Rosa
I’m pleasantly surprised.
The food was excellent. Excellent! The Stromboli, pizza, fries, everything.
The atmosphere was as expected for a local pizza place. The service was okay. I would call it limited table service. We had a service who took our orders and served us our food, but drinks are self-serve.
I will return. This could become our new local pizza place in the area. While there aren’t too many, Lake Gaston Pizza is head and shoulders above Pinos Pizza in Gasburg. I wish Lake Gaston Pizza was closer to us.
(They do offer white and red sauce and have gluten-free options)
… moreChris Allen
This five star review was encouraged by my kids, whom, on their first visit, deemed this their favorite restaurant ever. Kerry came out and invited everybody inside while they were standing outside trying to decide where to go. Later, he brought my kids the friendship bell for their first time visiting. It was overall a pleasant experience. Clean, friendly, and delicious. As an occasional lake visitor, this is our new go-to when we pass through!
**Middle picture** why so many doors?
… moreElizabeth Fletcher
We ordered 2 calzones and 2 personal pizzas for pickup. We got them home and they are all incredibly small. For $50 you’d think you’d get a lot more food. The calzones were also a bit over done. The upside was that they were quick.
… moreMichael Gilmore
Good food, good service, good atmosphere! Ordered some pepperoni pizza, the house beer and recess cup cake pie for dessert. Would come back. Interested in trying the ribs next.
… more