Brie Rock
This pizza is AMAZING. Yes, it’s attached to a club but you just ring the doorbell, open the door, go to the left and bam there is your pizza. And let me tell you it is the best pizza I’ve had around the Youngstown area. We’ve ordered 6 pizzas in the last two weeks and not a single one “wasn’t good”. They were all cooked to perfection. My personal favorite is the Giacomo. The greens had so much flavor and the pizza was cooked just right. I recommend this place all the time. There are no left overs when we get pizza here, which is a love/hate situation for me.
… moreJustin Petrello
Definitely a hidden gem in the pizza world!! If you have never had it, its a must try! We ordered the Brier Hill with hot peppers and it was so good we had to get another to go (white with hot peppers). Which also did not disappoint! I put this above Wedgewood!
… moreNick
For someone that grew up in The Valley I take our pizza very serious. I grew up on the Westside of Youngstown and have been a lifelong fan of Wedgewood…with Elmton being a close second…..with that being said and just had St. As for the second time I can confidently say without a doubt they have the best pizza in the area. The Downtown pizza they have is a revelation. Bravo
… moreBecky Steed
Soggy pizza on one and burnt on the other. They will not make it right, dont understand how they have good reviews. I will stick with other places that know how to make a good pizza!
… moreMike Hilton
The staff are so nice, I got wings to-go and they were perfect. The dude in the back is slaying the wings! So patient on the phone as I was driving and couldn’t see the menu. Friendly service seems to be rare these days but no shortage here. Awesome people. Great food!
… moreJared Lyder
Definitely not a place for the faint of heart. Between being buzzed into the society and calling and feeling like you have a 50/50 shot of getting a pizza in the next 3 hours, it may cause some people frustration. But if you want the best pizza in the area, you HAVE to try St A’s bistro. Can’t recommend his Brier Hill options more passionately. One of the best pizzas I have ever had! Great young local guy slinging perfect pies!
… moreSiR_StReTcHmArKs
Very chewy dough even when I asked for “well done” I got the Detroit style and nothing was hockey town about it. Got a traditional pie as well and that was even tougher to eat. 5.4 on the deep dish and I give the traditional a 4.2. If I had to order from this place again I would but I’m sure there is better pizza places here in Youngstown I have just yet to discover them. I’m from Cleveland and it is my mission to find the best pizza in Youngstown. This is not it.
… moreDan G
Just tried this for this first time and it was very good! Very high quality ingredients and cooked to perfection. This is the best crust I’ve ever had. We had the chicken bacon ranch and the Youngstown pizza. A great amount of care went into crafting these different flavors and both were amazing in their own way. Thank you!
… moreDaniel K
I have yet to experience a St. A’s pie that was less than stellar. As others mention, the crust is incredible–a touch on the thicker side, with a crisp outer shell, but light and fluffy inside. The subtle sprinkling of herbs and cheese is a great touch. The chicken bacon ranch is my personal favorite, but the pulled pork is a close 2nd. Best pizza in the Youngstown area.
… moreDevin Warren
Absolutely, hands down, the best pizza that I have ever had, and I have had a LOT of pizza. I got a Neapolitan and a cheese and it was so good, I ate the entire Neapolitan in one sitting. The pie is cooked pretty well done by default, which is the mark of a quality pie in my eyes. Not greasy or heavy in the slightest. This pizza is what dreams are made of. Will reccomend to every human being I speak to for as long as I live. Bravo.
… more