Social Profile: 
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out
… View more
Our professional team is waiting to serve you with a smile. A sophisticated wine list. Craft cocktails. We are housed in the historic, William Barringer Mansion. In good weather dine al fresco. Voted 2024 BEST OF THE REGION #1 Best Italian Food, #1 Best Chef, #1 Best Male Bartender and Best Wait Staff! Voted 2024 #1 Best Italian Restaurant Neighbors Choice too! Leave the euros and passport behind. Come eat at our house!
Classic northern Italian dishes, plus martinis & wine, served in a Victorian mansion.
Hours
| Friday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Monday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9 PM |
Address and Contact Information
Address: 302 S Main St, Crown Point, IN 46307
Phone: (219) 661-5829
Website: http://www.lucreziacafe.com/
Menu Photos
crownpoint.smartonlineorder.com
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Lucrezia Café – Taste Northern Italian Cuisine in all its Casual …
Three Great Locations. … Welcome to Lucrezia Café and Ristorante of Northwest Indiana and Lucrezia Trattoria near the beautiful shores of Lake Maxinkuckee in …
Lucrezia Ristorante – Crown Point – Facebook
Lucrezia Ristorante – Crown Point, Crown Point. 7716 likes · 18 talking about this · 19673 were here. Voted #1 Best Italian Restaurant year after year!…
Menus for Lucrezia Italian Ristorante – Crown Point – SinglePlatform
The award winning restaurant located in the beautiful and historic city of Crown Point … Lucrezia Italian Ristorante. Call Menu Info. 302 S Main St. Crown Point …
Reviews
Doug Hammond
This place was a real find. We were on our way from Chicagoland to Cincinnati and wanted something other than chain restaurant food and these folks exceeded our expectations. The restaurant is in this cute old Victorian house with high ceilings, crown molding, pocket doors, the whole 9 yards. The service is spot on from the hostess stand to the busses and the waitstaff. Then the food came. Huge portions, delicious. 2 entrees and a couple of apps would have fed us all easily (but we ordered 4 entrees and ended up leaving a ton of food behind because we had to travel on). Give this place a shot. You won’t be disappointed.
… moreRamsey_Jd
We found this place based on gluten free suggestions while on a road trip. Based on this pictures, I knew this was going to be a good choice, but I had no idea it was going to be incredible!
I love how knowledgeable and accommodating they are for people with gluten allergies and Celiac disease, the staff was friendly and the food was a must try!
We split the chicken Alfredo and the vodka rigatoni and it was hard to pick which one was better. I loved the richness of the alfredo but the vodka red sauce boasted so much flavor and depth. We will 100%be back!
This place is also in prestine condition, very well kept and very clean, deep and restored wood floors, and a unique atmosphere that you’ll want to experience
… moreI love how knowledgeable and accommodating they are for people with gluten allergies and Celiac disease, the staff was friendly and the food was a must try!
We split the chicken Alfredo and the vodka rigatoni and it was hard to pick which one was better. I loved the richness of the alfredo but the vodka red sauce boasted so much flavor and depth. We will 100%be back!
This place is also in prestine condition, very well kept and very clean, deep and restored wood floors, and a unique atmosphere that you’ll want to experience
John Allie
Nestled right in the heart of downtown Crown Point, Lucrezia’s is a gem. Met my dad here for lunch and it absolutely exceeded expectations. The Victorian house setting is charming, and the patio is hands down AMAZING—perfect spot to relax and enjoy a meal.
I had the Sausage and Rigatoni, and the red sauce was thick, rich, and full of flavor (a little spice would’ve taken it over the top, but still excellent). The highlight, though, was the lemon cake—absolutely killer. Do not leave without trying it!
A wonderful local spot in Crown Point that I’ll definitely be back to.
… moreI had the Sausage and Rigatoni, and the red sauce was thick, rich, and full of flavor (a little spice would’ve taken it over the top, but still excellent). The highlight, though, was the lemon cake—absolutely killer. Do not leave without trying it!
A wonderful local spot in Crown Point that I’ll definitely be back to.
Al B
The last couple of years i have spent my weekends traveling and looking for “THE” best place to eat. Finally! Absolutely the service was outstanding,absolutely the resturaunt itself amazing but the food makes everything else forgetable. This is next level good,in the top 3 of all time. This is as close to being as good as it gets, right there with grandma. A big thank you to Lucrezia.
… moreMartell Bone
This place has the best Italian food I’ve ever had in my life. First time here, friendly environment, clean. The Wait for our food wasn’t long at all. Drinks were good. We will definitely go again.
… moreRhi
I highly recommend coming here for a date night. The food, service, and atmosphere here is impeccable.
The short ribs are by far the best I’ve ever had.
… moreThe short ribs are by far the best I’ve ever had.
Eric J
We’ve been dining at Lucrezia for over 10 years, and it’s always been a special treat for us—even with the one-hour drive. Until tonight, the food and experience have consistently lived up to the hype, which is why this review is so disappointing to write.
Our entrées were excellent, as expected. Unfortunately, the calamari appetizer was not. It lacked any seasoning whatsoever—no salt, no flavor—clearly an oversight in the kitchen. We ate only a few pieces and sent the rest back.
We didn’t ask for a discount, but given that the dish was largely untouched and returned due to a clear quality issue, we reasonably assumed it would be comped or at least adjusted. It was not. No apology beyond taking it away, and no accommodation on the bill.
I chose not to make a scene because Lucrezia has earned years of goodwill from us. Still, when a restaurant of this caliber misses the mark, how it’s handled matters just as much as the food itself—and tonight, that part fell short.
We will likely return, but this experience was disappointing and out of character for a place we’ve long trusted and recommended. I would challenge you NOT to get the calamari!
… moreOur entrées were excellent, as expected. Unfortunately, the calamari appetizer was not. It lacked any seasoning whatsoever—no salt, no flavor—clearly an oversight in the kitchen. We ate only a few pieces and sent the rest back.
We didn’t ask for a discount, but given that the dish was largely untouched and returned due to a clear quality issue, we reasonably assumed it would be comped or at least adjusted. It was not. No apology beyond taking it away, and no accommodation on the bill.
I chose not to make a scene because Lucrezia has earned years of goodwill from us. Still, when a restaurant of this caliber misses the mark, how it’s handled matters just as much as the food itself—and tonight, that part fell short.
We will likely return, but this experience was disappointing and out of character for a place we’ve long trusted and recommended. I would challenge you NOT to get the calamari!
bing dcueto
Lucrezia Italian Café stands apart from the sea of generic, “Italian-inspired” eateries by staying true to what Italian food is meant to be—simple, honest, and deeply rooted in tradition. From the first bite, it’s clear this is not a place chasing trends or diluting flavors for mass appeal. The dishes feel thoughtfully prepared, balanced, and respectful of classic Italian techniques, the kind that prioritize quality ingredients over unnecessary embellishment.
The customer service adds to the experience rather than distracting from it. Staff are warm, attentive, and genuinely welcoming, creating an atmosphere that feels personal instead of transactional. You’re not rushed, but you’re never forgotten either—a balance that’s hard to get right and one Lucrezia handles well.
The ambience is beautiful and inviting, with a cozy charm that draws you in. At times, the space borders on being a bit tight, with minimal elbow room, especially during busy hours, but this closeness oddly enhances the experience. Dining here with family feels intimate, like gathering around a small table in an Italian home. The gentle hum of conversation, the shared plates, and the warmth of the space combine to transport you—if only briefly—to that comforting feeling of being somewhere familiar, somewhere distinctly Italian.
… moreThe customer service adds to the experience rather than distracting from it. Staff are warm, attentive, and genuinely welcoming, creating an atmosphere that feels personal instead of transactional. You’re not rushed, but you’re never forgotten either—a balance that’s hard to get right and one Lucrezia handles well.
The ambience is beautiful and inviting, with a cozy charm that draws you in. At times, the space borders on being a bit tight, with minimal elbow room, especially during busy hours, but this closeness oddly enhances the experience. Dining here with family feels intimate, like gathering around a small table in an Italian home. The gentle hum of conversation, the shared plates, and the warmth of the space combine to transport you—if only briefly—to that comforting feeling of being somewhere familiar, somewhere distinctly Italian.
Stephanie O’Neil
Anthony was absolutely amazing. I personally prefer service that gives real and approachable as opposed to corporate and fake. Anthony was extremely kind, knowledgeable about the food and asked questions if he was not, and made sure that we were taken care of. he even advocated for a different preparation of the creme brûlée based on our feedback and had open and honest conversations. i cannot tell you how much i appreciated the real attitude he had. the food was great. Lucrezia is our go-to Italian spot and I hope to have Anthony again!
… morejefferson lewis
Food was amazing! Service was ok. Jonah was great! Drinks were great. Not a fan of dark restaurants, couldn’t see the menu
… more