Social Profile: 
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out
… View more
Old-world setting for thin-crust pies, made-from-scratch pasta, panini & an extensive wine list.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 842 N Old World 3rd St, Milwaukee, WI 53203
Phone: (414) 273-3236
Website: http://www.calderoneclub.net/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Reservations: opentable.com
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Calderone Club
Calderone Club has been a staple of the Milwaukee restaurant scene for decades. Our long history is a testament to the love our patrons have for our food, …
Calderone Club Downtown | Milwaukee WI – Facebook
Feelin’ HOT HOT HOT Welcome to the kitchen, where our talented array of chefs is whipping up your favorite Italian classics Tuesday-Saturday. We couldn’t do …
Calderone Club – Downtown Milwaukee Restaurant – OpenTable
Calderone Club offers a vibrant dining experience in downtown Milwaukee, perfect for pre-theater meals. Guests rave about the “amazing food” and “superb service …
Reviews
Corey Hanson
This place was truly incredible! I would consider it a gem in Milwaukee. The atmosphere felt right in every way and the service was perfect. We both got cocktails that were excellent and mixed perfectly. We both got pasta dishes, with noodles cooked exactly how they should be. The sausage in my dish was seasoned to perfection offer a blend of spicy and savory I haven’t had in years. I cherished every single bite. I can’t wait to eat here again!
… moreMichelle Yu
The food was outstanding! We started with an order of 6 mozzarella sticks, which were thin and crispy. We had the gnocchi and the rigattoni bognese, both of which were excellent. The gnocchi was the best I had ever had– complex flavors and the gnocchi itself was melt in your mouth. For dessert, we shared the turtle cheesecake– omg, not sure what is in that, but it was amazing. I would go back just to eat that dessert!
The seating is tight. We had a table that was so close to the next table that the waiter could not get through without it being intrusive. But it is a loud, busy vibe and we enjoyed it and would definitely recommend it. There is no dedicated or validated parking, so plan ahead.
… moreThe seating is tight. We had a table that was so close to the next table that the waiter could not get through without it being intrusive. But it is a loud, busy vibe and we enjoyed it and would definitely recommend it. There is no dedicated or validated parking, so plan ahead.
Chris Diddit
Random walk in met with a seat at the bar or a lone corner table on the sidewalk so of course I chose to check out the scenery which didn’t disappoint.
I started with the salad and ranch which was light and fresh along with some house made ranch dressing.
The NY strip was perfectly cooked and just the right amount of flavor which was accompanied by a vegetable medley.
The bread came out with softened butter and was perfect for cleaning my plates.
Luis was definitely a veteran and took great care of me.
Was it worth it? Yes sirrrrr!
… moreI started with the salad and ranch which was light and fresh along with some house made ranch dressing.
The NY strip was perfectly cooked and just the right amount of flavor which was accompanied by a vegetable medley.
The bread came out with softened butter and was perfect for cleaning my plates.
Luis was definitely a veteran and took great care of me.
Was it worth it? Yes sirrrrr!
Lisa Knoff
This is one of my favorite date night restaurants to go to! I like to try something different every time I go & my man usually gets the Spaditi (hope I spelled it right!) which is a huge stuffed chicken breast. Everything I tried so far was delicious! Drinks are bit on the expensive side. The staff is great. Its kinda loud on a Saturday night but hey, its ok! Definitely recommended if you love Italian food!
… moreRICK
There aren’t many words to explain how phenomenal my meal was. I ordered the Veal Parmigiano with a Rigatoni and a side of meatballs. Everything was delicious and authentic. For dessert I decided on the cannoli with an Italian coffee. I haven’t had Italian food this good at a restaurant in a very long time. Our waiter was great and very attentive. I wish I Iived a bit closer because I would definitely be back. Don’t miss our on this place if you want a delicious Italian meal.
… moreLashaunta Jones
The service was phenomenal! Had our team dinner here and we were seated, served, and ate in 45 mins. Appetizers, soups and salads, entrees, all came out in a timely manner. The servers were so friendly. The food was extremely good. The team had a choice of salmon, chicken fettuccine, chicken marsala, or chicken Parmesan. All the choices were delicious. No room for gelato
… moreStefany Neef
The very *BEST* authentic Italian food. We took our Italian exchange student here for dinner. She said it was fantastic & she even got to order in Italian. 🙂
The server, wait staff, atmosphere & food were fantastic. Well worth our hour & a half drive! We loved the pizza & the spaghetti with meatballs were AMAZING!
… moreThe server, wait staff, atmosphere & food were fantastic. Well worth our hour & a half drive! We loved the pizza & the spaghetti with meatballs were AMAZING!
Ω
Absolutely a great experience. I say experience because you’re not just there for a classic Milwaukee pizza. I think they may have other Italian offerings as well. (The other dishes look great, but I was there for the pizza) I like the oblong shape and the crust is superb. This isn’t a NYC slice to walk around with, it’s a different style and it’s a classic recipe still being made today for a reason. The sliced meatballs I got as a topping are not on the menu, but are not to be missed. I think the additional charge was effectively for a side of meatballs, but absolutely worth it. I had a slice of a friend’s pepperoni and that doesn’t disappoint.
… moreJess Meluch
Our go to Italian place in MKE! The lemoncello martini is amazing. They make the lemoncello in house. Every pasta dish has been great and they always have great specials. I love their lobster ravioli.
… moreCharlie Matthews
In a town known for beer, this Italian restaurant is a hidden gem. Let me preface that I travel and eat out a lot and this was some of the best Italian food I’ve had in a very long time. Excellent flavors and large portions abound. You can also tell everything is made in house from scratch. You will clean your plate and ask for more. I’m not typically a cheesecake fan, but this one melts in your mouth and I’d say definitely get it. If you love Italian, do not miss the opportunity to enjoy some of the best!
… more