Social Profile: 
✔️Breakfast ✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out
… View more
Winner of the 2023 James Beard America’s Classic Award. Wagner’s Village Inn is a family-run restaurant in Oldenburg, Indiana, serving up a unique American tradition – chicken pan fried in hog fat. Passed down through three generations, their recipe promises a flavorful and crispy chicken experience.
Family-friendly chain serving homestyle American classics such as chicken-fried steak & pot pie.
Hours
| Monday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–7 PM |
Address and Contact Information
Address: 22171 Main St, Oldenburg, IN 47036
Phone: (812) 934-3854
Website: https://www.facebook.com/WagnersInOldenburg
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Wagner’s Village Inn | Oldenburg IN – Facebook
22171 Main St, Oldenburg, IN, United States, Indiana… 37 people interested.
Wagner’s Village Inn – Chicken restaurant in Indiana State – Website
Wagner’s Village Inn stands out as a beloved destination for comfort food enthusiasts, celebrated for its warm and inviting atmosphere that effortlessly …
r/Indiana on Reddit: Has anybody been to Wagners Village Inn in …
84 votes, 45 comments. Yep, several times. It’s very, very good. Oldenburg is a tiny town There are two stellar Restaurants there, Wagner s …
Reviews
Tamara Schwarting
Our Valentine’s Day adventure took us to Wagner’s Village Inn in Oldenburg, a spot long celebrated for its legendary fried chicken. The restaurant earned national recognition as a James Beard Award America’s Classic winner in 2023, a distinction that highlights beloved, locally owned institutions with timeless appeal.
The restaurant’s claim to fame is its traditional preparation: fried chicken cooked in 14-inch cast iron skillets using hog fat. Leaning fully into the experience, we ordered the family dinner — roughly two pounds of chicken per person with unlimited sides (coleslaw, mashed potatoes and gravy, green beans, and rolls). Portions are incredibly generous; if everyone at the table orders the family meal, expect to leave with plenty of leftovers.
The fried chicken is exceptionally moist, but both the chicken and gravy are distinctly pepper-forward. If you’re sensitive to black pepper, this may not be your favorite style. Let’s also be honest: this is indulgent comfort food, not a “light” meal.
For sides, the mashed potatoes were creamy and satisfying, but the standout for me was the coleslaw — slightly sweet, nicely dressed, and refreshingly balanced against the richness of the chicken. The only miss for me was the green beans. They were flavorful but very garlic-forward, which isn’t my personal preference and differs from a more traditional Southern-style preparation.
We both ordered tea. The sweet tea was well done. The half-cut tea was good, though those who prefer less sweetness might want to ask for a bit more unsweetened tea.
The rolls deserve a mention: fluffy, light, and delicious. We only received two but likely could have requested more. My minor quibble was the spread served alongside them — I would have loved real butter instead of margarine. A small detail, but worth noting.
Atmosphere-wise, the decor feels like stepping back in time — checkered tablecloths, wood paneling, and a cozy, old-school inn vibe. The staff was warm and friendly, adding to the charm.
One practical tip: home cooking is not fast cooking. Service wasn’t slow, but this is not a five-minute turnaround meal. Plan accordingly. They do bring coleslaw out early, which is a thoughtful touch while you wait.
Overall, this was a fun, nostalgic dining experience and we’re glad we made the trip. While it’s not somewhere we’d visit regularly, we absolutely understand why it has earned such a strong reputation. If you’re in the Batesville, Indiana area, it’s definitely worth a stop and trying at least once.
… moreThe restaurant’s claim to fame is its traditional preparation: fried chicken cooked in 14-inch cast iron skillets using hog fat. Leaning fully into the experience, we ordered the family dinner — roughly two pounds of chicken per person with unlimited sides (coleslaw, mashed potatoes and gravy, green beans, and rolls). Portions are incredibly generous; if everyone at the table orders the family meal, expect to leave with plenty of leftovers.
The fried chicken is exceptionally moist, but both the chicken and gravy are distinctly pepper-forward. If you’re sensitive to black pepper, this may not be your favorite style. Let’s also be honest: this is indulgent comfort food, not a “light” meal.
For sides, the mashed potatoes were creamy and satisfying, but the standout for me was the coleslaw — slightly sweet, nicely dressed, and refreshingly balanced against the richness of the chicken. The only miss for me was the green beans. They were flavorful but very garlic-forward, which isn’t my personal preference and differs from a more traditional Southern-style preparation.
We both ordered tea. The sweet tea was well done. The half-cut tea was good, though those who prefer less sweetness might want to ask for a bit more unsweetened tea.
The rolls deserve a mention: fluffy, light, and delicious. We only received two but likely could have requested more. My minor quibble was the spread served alongside them — I would have loved real butter instead of margarine. A small detail, but worth noting.
Atmosphere-wise, the decor feels like stepping back in time — checkered tablecloths, wood paneling, and a cozy, old-school inn vibe. The staff was warm and friendly, adding to the charm.
One practical tip: home cooking is not fast cooking. Service wasn’t slow, but this is not a five-minute turnaround meal. Plan accordingly. They do bring coleslaw out early, which is a thoughtful touch while you wait.
Overall, this was a fun, nostalgic dining experience and we’re glad we made the trip. While it’s not somewhere we’d visit regularly, we absolutely understand why it has earned such a strong reputation. If you’re in the Batesville, Indiana area, it’s definitely worth a stop and trying at least once.
Kevin Wathen
What a let down. How they won a James Beard award is beyond me. The food just wasn’t that good. It seemed old and warmed up. It definitely wasn’t fried fresh. When we arrived only 1 other patron was there. We sat fairly close to the kitchen and you could tell not a lot of cooking was going on. Little sound and the smell of food cooking.
There were four of us. We ordered the family style chicken dinner and one fish and fries. The fish and fries were good and you could tell freshly made.
The rolls were good except the second serving was microwaved, you could tell. The potatoes and gravy were okay. We all agreed the cole slaw was the winner. It was fantastic. The chicken was a big let down. Not real hot and a little dry. The fried mushrooms were okay.
For the price definitely not worth it.
… moreThere were four of us. We ordered the family style chicken dinner and one fish and fries. The fish and fries were good and you could tell freshly made.
The rolls were good except the second serving was microwaved, you could tell. The potatoes and gravy were okay. We all agreed the cole slaw was the winner. It was fantastic. The chicken was a big let down. Not real hot and a little dry. The fried mushrooms were okay.
For the price definitely not worth it.
Madeline Garcia
Charming little spot just a short jaunt off I-74 with food you don’t want to miss! Interior reminds you off a historic saloon, while the server (girl with brown straight hair) offered to let me try two drafts to see which I would prefer. Chicken gizzards (not pictured) are peppery and warm, while spicy cheese bites are rich and smooth like an elevated state fair experience. Mashed potatoes were well seasoned and topped with some of the best gravy I’ve had. The coleslaw was a perfect balance between sweet and bright. Subbed corn fritters for green beans. Chicken was well seasoned, but the sides were the stars of the show for me. Excellent affordable prices.
… moreCharles Benedict
First time visiting and im glad we did. Some of the best tasting fried chicken I’ve ever had. Came with green beans , mashed potatoes and rolls. All the sides were equally delicious. Very friendly staff as well. Highly recommend this restaurant to everyone.
… morebrett palmer
The food was delicious. The portions were reasonable and if you order the 4 piece meal the sides are bottomless.
… moreSteve Hicks
We drove 2.5hrs to eat here (we love road trips). Some of the best fried chicken we ever had. And the service, it was just amazing! We will be going back and will take some family members with us!
… moreZane Maguet
We made a special stop in town to eat at this James Beard America’s Classic, and it was definitely worthwhile! The service was friendly and the restaurant itself is so historic! We got the fried cheese bites to start and they were crispy on the outside and creamy on the inside. The fried chicken was heavily seasoned with black pepper and absolutely delicious. The mashed potatoes were excellent, although not as hot as I would have liked. However, the steaming hot gravy helped make it just right! Overall, I would highly recommend stopping by!
… moreTheresa Neff
Pan fried chicken with a wonderfully crisp pepper crust, real mashed potatoes with creamy butter, plump green beans and sweet, Angel hair slaw. This meal HITS. THE. SPOT.
Service was annoyed at us for asking questions about the menu, but that didn’t detract from the delicious meal.
… moreService was annoyed at us for asking questions about the menu, but that didn’t detract from the delicious meal.
Ben Richmond
I have been here a couple of times and have loved it both times. The service is good with friendly staff. It is homestyle cooking so it may take a little longer to get your food but the wait is not terrible and definitely worth it.
… moreTamara Batchler
I’m not going to say I was disappointed but I was expecting more small space with a party or large crowd it was extremely loud got the chicken livers and they were extremely overcooked the coleslaw was fantastic and the steak fries were delicious even after at room temperature they still had a crunch
… more