Bethel Bakery

by

  4.6 – 1,219 reviews   • Bakery

Social Profile:

Popular, classic bakeshop whipping up house, seasonal & custom cakes, plus other sweets, since 1955.

✔️Breakfast ✔️Lunch ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery Bethel Bakery 15102

Menu Photos

bethelbakery.com

Photo Gallery

Related Web Results

Bethel Bakery – the cake place in Bethel Park PA – Bethel Bakery

Visit our online store. Be sure to place your order at least 72 hours in advance. Call us at 412.835.6658 to speak with an Order Specialist …

Bethel Bakery | Bethel Park PA – Facebook

Our Homestyle Nut Roll is our delicious sweet dough with ground walnut filling Apricot and Poppyseed fillings are available by order only for pick up April …

Bethel Bakery, 5200 Brightwood Rd, Bethel Park, PA 15102, US

A family-owned retail bakery and was founded more than 50 years ago. It offers decorative and wedding cakes, desserts, donuts, cookies, breakfast rolls, coffee …

Product

Wedding Cakes
Weddings

Reviews

Sharpey31
Bethel Bakery’s paczki are seriously awesome. I’ve been stopping in and trying the flavor of the week, and honestly every one has been a hit. They’re always fresh, soft, and filled the right way — not skimpy at all. Perfect treat and definitely worth the stop. Highly recommend grabbing a few before they’re gone for the season.
… more
ROFL Chopstixz
Came to try the paczkis and they did not disappoint. They were fluffy and stuffed with plenty of filling! Rasberry and chocolate ones were my favorite and also got a couple of the donuts which also were light and fluffy. I’ll definitely come back to try some of their other pastries!
… more
Taylor B
We used Bethel Bakery to buy a cake and extra goodies for our baby’s one year birthday party. The cake was amazing!! We did white cake with chocolate fudge filling, and it got tons of compliments. The design was amazing and adorable as well. We ordered online, and then my husband picked it all up the morning of our party… it was super seamless. The prices seemed incredibly fair, especially in comparison to the grocery store sheet cake prices. I’d much prefer to give a local business my money and business, even if it is a few dollars more. We will definitely use Bethel Bakery again!!
… more
Cynthia Richey
Bethel Bakery never disappoints. This trip I tried their pepperoni rolls and the veggie rolls and they were so amazing. The service was prompt and the young man who waited on me was very kind. I usually go to this bakery for cakes and it was nice to try the savory options:
… more
Carson Lankford
The wedding cakes were far more beautiful that I could have imagined. Wanted a gold rose base and thought it would be a light shimmer of gold at best. It was STRAIGHT UP gold and vibrant and gleamed in the light. And the top tier was beautiful and exactly what I wanted. Our personal wedding cake (gone too soon for photos) was spot on and my now husband loved it so much. The delivery guys were so friendly and punctual. Was great meeting them. Hope they enjoyed the cookies! You guys are incredible and thank you so much for the absolute show stopper of a cake. So gorgeous!!!
… more
Shannon Buckholt
Bethel Bakery did an incredible job with our wedding cake. It was exactly how I envisioned it—beautifully designed and absolutely delicious. They truly nailed both the look and the taste, which is so important for a wedding cake.

We chose an almond cake with raspberry buttercream and cream cheese filling, and it was phenomenal. We received so many compliments from our guests about how amazing the cake tasted, and some people took home a slice with them.

We couldn’t have been happier with our experience and are so glad we chose Bethel Bakery for our wedding day. We can’t wait to have this again on our 1 year anniversary. I would highly recommend them to any couple looking for a wedding cake that looks stunning and tastes just as good.
… more
Scott Wilson
My wife and I were in town and wanted to take a Bethel christmas cake home. We asked for just a small cake with snowmen, and they gave us the most beautiful cake you could imagine, looked like a painting, and was absolutely delicious. You’ve outdone yourselves for sure!
… more
Barbara S
Ordered our wedding cake with Bethel Bakery. Staff was very friendly and helpful. They answered all our questions and made suggestions on how to make everything we wanted fit our budget. They took away the stress of ordering the perfect cake. Cake was delivered on time, looked fabulous and tasted great! Overall a wonderful experience.
… more
Jacob “Jake” Salaj
One of the highlights of our wedding was the cookie table—a beloved Pittsburgh tradition that many of our guests from out of town had never experienced before. It was such a fun and memorable surprise for them! The cookie package was super easy to order from and the treats were delicious for guests to enjoy throughout the night. It added a personal and nostalgic touch to our celebration that made the evening feel even more special. We loved seeing everyone gather around the table, sampling all the different kinds, and even taking some home. It was a huge hit and a sweet way to share a piece of Pittsburgh with everyone!
… more
john c
I had heard a lot of buzz about the doughnuts here,I was not disappointed. the doughnuts were better than average, I got mostly paczki which were excellent and a few buttercream filled doughnuts which were good. The pepperoni was top notch the only issue with it was stuck to the container and fell apart when removed. Service was polite but slow, there were quite a few employees behind the counter but only a few were waiting on customers. I found the layout to be lacking it was hard to look at what they had and not be in the way of other customers. My only problem was it cost over $40.00 for 4 doughnuts 8 paczki and a pepperoni log that’s a hard pill to swallow the quality is good the size was good but the price was to high. I will go back though
… more
… View more

Leave a Comment

© 2026 Marketer • Built with GeneratePress

Privacy Policy

Terms

Contact