Joyce Dela Cruz
Just had a sweet surprise tonight – a box from Cookie Cottage, dropped off at my doorstep fresh from the store. The moment I opened it, the aroma of warm, buttery goodness filled my home. The cookies were still soft, chewy, and bursting with flavor, like they had just come out of the oven. You can taste the freshness and quality in every bite. A true Fort Wayne gem for cookie lovers. Thus is happiness in a box!
… morejackie Sleighter
It has been at least a year since we have gotten these cookies so we drove 40 minutes today to get some. My iced sugar cookie and his double chocolate mint chip were crunchy , almost burned on the bottom. I use to buy several dozen every Christmas and I’ve never had a bad cookie. The taste is pretty much still there we were somewhat a little disappointed this time.
… moreKaitlyn Dean
First time stopping by from FL. This week as soon as you walk in it smells amazing. We got a half dozen of cookies all was soft chewy tasty! I loved the butter pecan and oatmeal chocolate chip. My husband liked the chocolate chip with mint on top. My only recommendation would be to change the way the line is so right when you walk in you can walk up and see the cookies without walking around and getting in other people’s way and can tell who’s in line first or who’s waiting it
… moreProducer 9-0
I ordered a variety of cookies from Cookie Cottage, including peanut butter and snickerdoodle, and they were excellent as usual. The flavors were spot-on, and the texture was perfect—soft yet chewy, just the way I like them. Cookie Cottage continues to deliver high-quality treats that never disappoint. Highly recommend for any cookie lover! Producer 9-0
… moreAshley Rios Rizo
I get a box of sugar cookies every year for my daughter to take to school on her birthday. The cookies are here consistently delicious. You can never eat just one either! To darn good! Cookie Cottage reigns Queen!
… moreJulie McGuire
To the idiot who posted pictures from the ER with a bad review containing the disclaimer “do not eat four frosted sugar cookies from cookie cottage in one setting” maybe don’t eat four cookies in one setting, period. Blaming gluttony on a cookie recipe is ridiculous. These cookies are perfection defined. Every buttery bite of every single variety is an adventure in flavor town and Fort Wayne is so blessed to have this establishment call it home.
… moreAnnie
Great place to get cookies for self or a gift. They pack every cookie separately which is very nice and increase cookie life. Overall 10/10.
… moreDusty Sickle
Recieved these as a gift in a variety pack. They’re delicious. They listed the peanut butter cookie as “creamy” which shouldn’t be a big deal but it is. I have a gastro disorder, I can’t eat some nuts like peanuts UNLESS they’ve been processed down. I’m not allergic, they’re just sharp, hard to digest, and can cut my intestines.
… moreLindsey Swalley
Best cookies ever! Visited on a Tuesday around 1. There was a line but we were out in about 10 minutes. I ordered 2 dozen and I was ready when I got to the counter. The ladies are really fast at grabbing the cookies you want and keeping track of how many more u need if you’re trying to hit a dozen. One dozen is about $25 and I chose to have them in a box for just 50 cents. My total was only $35.50 so I guess there’s a discount on the second dozen!! Whew! These cookies are worth every penny either way!! I’ve been coming to the Cookie Cottage since I was a kid, when they were in a smaller store and it’s always been a special treat that gave me so much joy!
… moreLydia Troyer
I haven’t been inside, but these cookies are the best cookies I’ve ever eaten! Simply divine! I especially love their sugar cookies.
… more