Social Profile: 
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Emilio’s is your go-to Italian restaurant and pizzeria in Commack, NY, serving authentic Italian dishes since 1980. From house-made pastas to wood-fired pizzas, every plate is crafted with tradition and modern flavor. We offer Italian food catering for events of all sizes, plus dine-in, takeout, and delivery through Uber Eats, Grubhub, and DoorDash. Our Italian pizzeria is known for having the best pizza and pasta in Commack NY. Hosting a party? Ask about our private event room and catering options. Visit us at 2201 Jericho Tpke for real Italian comfort food done right.
A mix of classic pastas, pizza & creative Italian entrees in an upbeat, modern strip-mall space.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 2201 Jericho Tpke, Commack, NY 11725
Phone: (631) 462-6267
Website: https://www.emilioscommack.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Reservations: opentable.com
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Emilios: HOME
2201 Jericho Tpke. Commack, NY 11725. . HOURS. MON-THURS: 11:30 AM – 9:30 PM … Our casual, Italian eatery serves fresh, delicious, fun to eat and satisfying …
Emilio’s Italian Kitchen & Pizzeria | Commack NY – Facebook
Our family has been bringing our pizzas, pastas, and the rich, authentic flavors of Italy to the pe… See more. Restaurant.
Emilio’s Of Commack (@emiliosofcommack) – Instagram
8.1K+ followers · 2.2K+ posts · EST. 1980 RATED LONG ISLANDS BEST Quality Italian • Pizzeria Napoletana • Cocktails.
Reviews
Kendal Thompson
My experience at Emilio’s tonight was nothing short of spectacular. From the moment we sat down, Sergio made us feel like VIP guests — warm, attentive, and genuinely passionate about the food and service. He elevated the entire night.
We ordered the sangrias, the Chicken Milanese, and the Bolognese loaded with clams and mussels, and let me tell you… this was the best meal we’ve had all year. Every single dish was perfection. The sangrias were beautifully balanced and dangerously delicious, the Chicken Milanese was crisp and tender with flawless seasoning, and the Bolognese with the seafood? A masterpiece. Rich, fresh, and so thoughtfully prepared — a dish you don’t forget.
The service was top-notch, the drinks were crafted with intention, and the food was on a level that rivals restaurants twice the price. Emilio’s is operating in Michelin-star territory, and if I had the power to award them one, I would do it in a heartbeat.
Sergio, thank you for giving us a dining experience we will be talking about for a long time. This restaurant is a gem and absolutely worth every bit of praise.
… moreWe ordered the sangrias, the Chicken Milanese, and the Bolognese loaded with clams and mussels, and let me tell you… this was the best meal we’ve had all year. Every single dish was perfection. The sangrias were beautifully balanced and dangerously delicious, the Chicken Milanese was crisp and tender with flawless seasoning, and the Bolognese with the seafood? A masterpiece. Rich, fresh, and so thoughtfully prepared — a dish you don’t forget.
The service was top-notch, the drinks were crafted with intention, and the food was on a level that rivals restaurants twice the price. Emilio’s is operating in Michelin-star territory, and if I had the power to award them one, I would do it in a heartbeat.
Sergio, thank you for giving us a dining experience we will be talking about for a long time. This restaurant is a gem and absolutely worth every bit of praise.
okmattyboy
Took my lady out to Emilio’s and Sergio made the whole night flawless. The sangrias were unbelievable, the Chicken Milanese was perfectly crispy, and the Bolognese with clams and mussels was easily the best dish we’ve had all year.
Service, drinks, food; everything was top-tier. If I could give this place a Michelin star myself, I would. Perfect spot to impress your woman and have an unforgettable night.
… moreService, drinks, food; everything was top-tier. If I could give this place a Michelin star myself, I would. Perfect spot to impress your woman and have an unforgettable night.
Julia M.
We ordered takeout from Emilio’s and the experience is just as good as dining-in. We had a chicken parm dinner and a chicken francese dinner. They were both outrageous. The flavor and the amount you get is unbelievable. Looking forward to dining-in soon as well.
… moreE Northport
Hit or miss here.
Usually too busy for me hence I will not frequent this establishment.
Food is almost always good although on more than one occasion I have received cold dishes.
My guests always enjoyed their meals though.
Careless waiters but probably because they are too busy.
The landlord of the property is a colleague of one of my clients and clearly stated that the owner is in and out of jail. I don’t believe it but I must say that this comment stuck.
Food is good. Too busy though which in itself says good things as far as freshness.
Mid day is my recommendation for comfort and service.
… moreUsually too busy for me hence I will not frequent this establishment.
Food is almost always good although on more than one occasion I have received cold dishes.
My guests always enjoyed their meals though.
Careless waiters but probably because they are too busy.
The landlord of the property is a colleague of one of my clients and clearly stated that the owner is in and out of jail. I don’t believe it but I must say that this comment stuck.
Food is good. Too busy though which in itself says good things as far as freshness.
Mid day is my recommendation for comfort and service.
DIY DAD
Great Place! Great food! Desert and espresso as great. Love the cheesecake And love the Italian atmosphere and music! My family enjoyed Mother’s Day brunch! Thank you!
… moreRich Mikol
Food was delicious and flavorful. Portions were large, you can order entree, or for one and or family style. Can’t wait to go again.
… moreVictoria Johnston
Food was good, but we waited 45 minutes for only one of our two dishes (ravioli) to be brought out, then another 20 for the second dish (pizza) to finally be brought out. They offered to heat up the ravioli, but brought it back still cold, just with new meatballs. We finished our food and waited another 30+ minutes for our waiter to walk back past us, we actually had to yell to get him to stop and bring the check and a box for our leftovers and luckily we didnt let him leave the side of the table (which he immediately tried to do) so we could pay in a timely fashion. We felt completely ignored the entire time we were there, even though it was lunch time and there was only one or two other tables seated there. Will not be coming back to waste my time or money here again.
… moreNyallah Fowler
If i could give this place 0 stars, I would. I’m a pizza lover and this place was a complete disappointment. First of all, I bought two regular slices for $8. The cashier took my order and then serviced the two people after me and they were able to get their food first before the cashier remembered to put (unfortunately he literally threw) my slices in the oven. When I opened the box, the dough was completely RAW and extremely THIN. I called to make the manager on duty aware of this and her response was “i can give you your money back or you can get two new slices” that is very unsafe and this place was a waste of money. I do not recommend.
… moreEric Proctor
Sicilian slice was one the best I ever had. Tried the Brooklyn too, stick with the Sicilian!
… moreGina Mangione
We were a party of 6 on New Year’s Eve and had a reservation for 5 pm. Not crowded when we arrived. Ordered coffee. It was served with no milk. By the time the milk was served, the coffee was cold. Waited an hour for our meals which were served cold. Sent them back and after 15 minutes, they were returned still cold. If they were heated up the cheese would’ve been melted which it was not. Not sure why our food was just in the back and not served when it was ready. When the check was brought to us, the waiter said that it was not his problem. I then asked him then why was it mine? I came out for a hot meal. Nothing was taken off the bill and I don’t believe that we will be going there again nor will we recommend it. We live in the neighborhood and hoped to have been treated better. The service was extremely slow and partial. Sorry that I left a tip at all.
… more